Law School Admissions Advice from Former Dean Donald Tobin

^{Last Updated: October 2026}

Choosing the right law school is one of the most important decisions an aspiring attorney will make. Beyond academic rankings and standardized test scores, applicants must consider financial commitments, educational opportunities, career prospects, and whether a law school will help them achieve their professional goals.

In an interview with Top Law Schools, Donald Tobin, former dean and professor of law at the University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law, shared his perspectives on law school admissions, personal statements, academic preparation, and legal education.

Tobin served as dean of Maryland Carey Law from 2014 to 2022 and subsequently returned to the faculty. He is the Gordon, Wolf & Carney Professor of Law, specializing in tax and election law.

Although his interview took place during his deanship, much of his advice remains useful for prospective law students.

This guide explores those insights and explains how applicants can apply them when preparing for law school.

What Law School Applicants Can Learn from Donald Tobin

A central lesson from Tobin's interview is that law school admissions and educational success are not determined by one factor.

Applicants should think carefully about their strengths, motivations, learning preferences, and professional objectives.

Academic credentials remain important. However, personal statements, letters of recommendation, employment experience, and extracurricular involvement can help admissions committees understand an applicant's potential.

Equally important, choosing a law school involves more than gaining admission to the highest-ranked institution.

Students should evaluate whether a school offers the academic resources, financial support, practical experience, and professional opportunities they need.

Key takeaways from Tobin's admissions philosophy include:

Choose a law school where academic and personal growth are possible.
Consider educational fit instead of relying exclusively on rankings.
Write a personal statement that reflects authentic experiences.
Select recommenders who understand your strengths.
Demonstrate readiness for demanding academic work.
Evaluate clinical programs and experiential learning opportunities.
Consider tuition, scholarships, debt, and employment outcomes.
Develop a realistic understanding of the legal profession before enrolling.

These principles provide a useful foundation for comparing law schools and preparing competitive applications.

How to Choose the Right Law School Beyond Rankings

Law school rankings can provide a starting point for research. However, they cannot fully capture the educational experience or career opportunities available to individual students.

During his interview, Tobin emphasized the importance of identifying a school where an applicant could thrive.

Different students may have different priorities. One applicant may value faculty accessibility, while another may prioritize clinical training, geographic location, or specialized courses.

Consider Academic Fit and Faculty Accessibility

Law school involves intensive reading, legal research, writing, and analytical reasoning.

Students benefit from environments that encourage intellectual development and provide opportunities for meaningful interaction with professors.

Before choosing a school, prospective students should investigate:

Faculty accessibility and mentoring opportunities.
Course offerings in areas of professional interest.
Academic support programs and legal writing instruction.
Research opportunities and faculty expertise.
Experiential learning requirements.
Student organizations and extracurricular activities.

Applicants should also consider whether the school's academic culture aligns with their learning preferences.

Look Beyond Law School Rankings

Rankings summarize institutional information through selected metrics. However, those metrics may not reflect every factor important to a particular student.

An applicant interested in public interest law may prioritize clinics, government placements, and loan repayment assistance.

Someone pursuing corporate law may focus more heavily on business law courses, recruiting relationships, and graduate employment patterns.

Rather than using rankings as the sole deciding factor, applicants should compare the schools' educational offerings and demonstrated outcomes.

Evaluate Geographic Location

A law school's location can influence networking, internships, externships, and employment opportunities.

Students considering a particular region should examine whether the school maintains relationships with local employers, courts, government agencies, and legal organizations.

Location may also affect living expenses and the accessibility of part-time legal work during the academic year.

For additional school comparisons and admissions resources, visit the Top Law Schools admissions section.

What Law School Admissions Committees Look for in Applicants

Prospective law students frequently ask whether undergraduate GPA or LSAT scores matter more.

Tobin explained that, during his tenure, Maryland Carey Law did not use a single formula that assigned identical weight to every component of every application.

Instead, the admissions process examined applicants' qualifications and evidence of their potential to succeed in law school.

This offers an important lesson: a competitive application should communicate both academic readiness and personal strengths.

The Importance of GPA and LSAT Scores

Undergraduate grades and standardized test scores can help admissions committees evaluate academic preparation.

A strong GPA may demonstrate consistent performance, while an LSAT score can provide additional evidence of reasoning and analytical skills.

However, applicants should not assume that these credentials tell their complete story.

Admissions policies vary by institution and can change between application cycles. Applicants should review each school's current standardized testing requirements, accepted examinations, and application instructions.

Can Other Application Materials Make a Difference?

Tobin observed that personal statements and recommendation letters sometimes influenced admissions decisions among otherwise qualified candidates.

These materials may help a committee understand qualities not captured by numerical credentials, including:

Intellectual curiosity.
Maturity and judgment.
Leadership experience.
Research and writing abilities.
Professional responsibility.
Community involvement.
Persistence and resilience.
Motivation to pursue legal education.

Applicants should use their materials to present a consistent and credible picture of their abilities.

How Work Experience Can Strengthen an Application

Applicants do not necessarily need professional experience before entering law school.

Nevertheless, Tobin recognized that employment and life experiences can provide useful perspectives and transferable skills.

Professionals who have managed demanding responsibilities may enter law school with stronger organizational habits and a clearer understanding of their long-term goals.

Experience in business, education, public service, technology, healthcare, or other fields can also help applicants connect their backgrounds to particular legal interests.

However, recent graduates can demonstrate comparable strengths through academic projects, internships, leadership roles, and volunteer work.

The most effective approach is to explain what an experience taught the applicant rather than merely listing responsibilities.

How to Write a Strong Law School Personal Statement

The personal statement is one of the most flexible components of many law school applications.

It allows applicants to communicate their motivations, experiences, values, and personal perspectives.

Tobin emphasized that a successful personal statement should be genuinely personal.

A compelling essay should help the admissions reader understand the applicant as an individual.

Tell an Authentic Story

Some applicants attempt to impress admissions committees with unusual formats or exaggerated language.

However, a straightforward narrative often communicates more effectively.

A strong personal statement might describe:

An experience that shaped the applicant's professional goals.
A significant academic or intellectual interest.
A responsibility that demonstrated maturity.
A personal challenge that contributed to growth.
An experience involving leadership or community service.
A professional situation that sparked an interest in law.

The strongest essays explain not only what happened but also why the experience mattered.

Applicants should select examples that reveal something meaningful about their character, judgment, or aspirations.

For additional strategies, read the Law School Personal Statement Guide: Tips and Examples.

Avoid Common Personal Statement Mistakes

Tobin cautioned against several approaches that can weaken an application.

These include unnecessarily elaborate creative formats, generic descriptions of the law, and statements that fail to reveal anything meaningful about the applicant.

Common mistakes include:

Repeating information already available in the resume.
Using overly formal or artificial language.
Writing an essay that could apply to virtually any applicant.
Focusing excessively on the institution rather than the individual.
Including grammatical errors or spelling mistakes.
Adopting a tone that appears arrogant or entitled.
Ignoring the school's specific application instructions.

A personal statement should demonstrate thoughtful self-reflection while remaining professional and concise.

Should Applicants Explain Why They Want to Attend a Particular School?

School-specific research can strengthen an application when the applicant explains a genuine connection between personal interests and institutional offerings.

For example, an applicant interested in environmental law might discuss a relevant course, faculty research area, or experiential program.

However, applicants should avoid generic compliments that could be copied into applications for multiple institutions.

If a school offers a separate "Why This Law School?" essay, applicants should follow its instructions rather than automatically including that material in the personal statement.

Should Applicants Submit Optional Statements?

Optional essays can provide context that does not fit naturally into the main personal statement.

Depending on the school, these may involve personal background, perspective, educational experiences, significant challenges, or other specified topics.

Applicants should read the current prompts and explain meaningful experiences rather than submitting an additional essay simply because the option exists.

A thoughtful supplemental statement should add useful information instead of repeating the primary essay.

Choosing Strong Letters of Recommendation for Law School

Letters of recommendation provide outside perspectives on an applicant's abilities and potential.

Tobin encouraged applicants to consider who could best describe their particular strengths.

Rather than choosing recommenders solely because of their professional titles, applicants should identify individuals familiar with their academic work, responsibilities, and accomplishments.

Who Should Write a Law School Recommendation Letter?

Potential recommenders may include:

Professors who supervised substantial academic work.
Research advisers familiar with writing and analytical abilities.
Employers who can discuss professional responsibility.
Supervisors who observed leadership and problem-solving skills.
Mentors familiar with an applicant's intellectual development.

Different recommenders may highlight different abilities.

For example, a professor might discuss analytical writing, while an employer could describe initiative and professional judgment.

How to Approach Potential Recommenders

Applicants should contact potential recommenders early and explain their educational goals.

Providing relevant supporting materials can make the process easier.

These may include:

An updated resume.
A summary of academic or professional accomplishments.
A draft personal statement.
Application deadlines.
Instructions for submitting recommendations.
A brief explanation of why the applicant values the recommender's perspective.

Applicants should also ask whether the individual feels comfortable writing a strong recommendation.

A detailed endorsement from someone who knows the applicant's work can be more persuasive than a generic letter from a prominent individual.

What Maryland Carey Law Illustrates About Practical Legal Education

A law school's academic reputation is important, but students should also investigate how the institution prepares graduates for legal practice.

During his deanship, Tobin highlighted Maryland Carey Law's clinical education, experiential learning opportunities, and commitment to public service.

His interview discussed programs involving immigration, intellectual property, entrepreneurship, community legal services, and other areas.

These examples illustrate the broader value of learning through supervised practical experience.

Program availability and participation requirements may have changed since the interview. Prospective students should verify current offerings with the university.

Why Clinical Programs Matter

Law school clinics provide opportunities for students to apply classroom knowledge to legal problems under appropriate supervision.

Depending on the clinic, students may participate in:

Legal research and writing.
Client interviews and counseling.
Case preparation.
Administrative proceedings.
Policy research and advocacy.
Negotiation and mediation.
Business and nonprofit legal assistance.

Clinical education can help students develop professional judgment, communication skills, and practical confidence.

It may also help students identify which practice areas interest them most.

Externships and Legal Internships

Externships and internships provide additional opportunities to learn about legal workplaces.

Students may gain exposure to law firms, courts, government agencies, public-interest organizations, and corporate legal departments.

However, applicants should examine the structure and availability of these programs.

Useful questions include whether placements are guaranteed or competitive, how students receive supervision, whether academic credit is available, and whether participants can develop meaningful professional skills.

Students planning their first legal work experience can also explore LawCrossing's legal career resources for law students.

Understanding the Relationship Between Law School and Legal Careers

Law school is both an academic undertaking and a significant professional investment.

Applicants should therefore consider how their educational choices may affect their future careers.

During his interview, Tobin discussed the range of legal opportunities associated with the Baltimore-Washington, D.C., region.

These included private law firms, government agencies, judicial clerkships, public-interest organizations, and other legal employers.

His observations highlight an important consideration: the location and professional network of a law school can influence students' exposure to different careers.

Compare Employment Outcomes Carefully

Prospective law students should review recent employment reports rather than relying on generalized statements about graduate success.

Important information includes:

Employment requiring bar admission.
Employment where a J.D. provides an advantage.
Full-time versus part-time employment.
Long-term versus temporary positions.
Law firm employment by firm size.
Judicial clerkships.
Government and public-interest employment.
Geographic distribution of graduates.

Applicants should also investigate the school's career services resources, alumni network, and recruiting opportunities.

The most relevant employment outcomes will depend on the applicant's intended career path.

Does Class Rank Determine Legal Career Success?

Grades and class rank can affect access to certain employers, particularly highly selective hiring programs.

However, legal careers develop through multiple factors.

Practical experience, writing ability, professional relationships, reliability, persistence, and the ability to serve clients can all influence career opportunities.

Tobin's historical interview emphasized that students across different academic performance levels could pursue meaningful legal careers.

Still, applicants should recognize that employment prospects vary significantly by school, employer, geographic market, and economic conditions.

Start Career Planning Early

Students should not postpone career exploration until graduation.

Early career planning may involve meeting with advisers, researching employers, participating in student organizations, and developing professional relationships.

Internships and externships can help students clarify their interests.

For practical guidance, review LawCrossing's legal employment and law student job-search articles.

How to Compare Law School Scholarships, Tuition, and Debt

The cost of legal education deserves careful attention.

Tuition is only one component of the total financial commitment.

Students should also consider housing, transportation, books, university fees, insurance, and other living expenses.

Tobin emphasized the importance of evaluating financial decisions alongside educational opportunities and professional goals.

However, applicants should not interpret that principle as a reason to disregard debt or minimize meaningful scholarship differences.

Evaluate the Total Cost of Attendance

Before selecting a school, estimate the full cost of earning the degree.

Consider:

Tuition and mandatory fees.
Living expenses.
Transportation and educational supplies.
Scholarships and grants.
Scholarship renewal requirements.
Available financial aid.
Potential borrowing and interest.
Expected employment opportunities.
Possible loan repayment assistance programs.

A scholarship that substantially reduces borrowing may have a major long-term financial benefit.

Applicants should compare realistic net costs rather than published tuition figures alone.

Understand Scholarship Conditions

Not all scholarships operate under identical rules.

Some awards may include conditions involving academic performance, enrollment status, or other eligibility requirements.

Applicants should request clear written information about scholarship renewal and understand the conditions before accepting an offer.

They should also review the school's current financial aid materials and required disclosures.

Consider Long-Term Financial Goals

Prospective students should evaluate how projected debt obligations fit their intended career paths.

A student interested in public-interest work may face different financial considerations than someone pursuing private practice.

At the same time, expected employment and earnings are uncertain.

Students should avoid basing major borrowing decisions on a single optimistic salary assumption.

Preparing for Law School Academics and the Bar Exam

Law school requires students to develop legal reasoning, research, writing, and analytical skills.

Tobin discussed the importance of academic preparation and the responsibility of law schools to provide students with a strong educational foundation.

Although bar preparation generally involves dedicated study, law school coursework contributes to the knowledge and skills students need.

Build Strong Legal Research and Writing Skills

Writing is central to legal education and professional practice.

Students should prioritize opportunities to improve their ability to analyze problems, interpret authorities, organize arguments, and communicate conclusions clearly.

Research and writing skills are valuable across nearly every practice area.

Choose Courses That Support Professional Goals

Students should explore relevant electives after completing their foundational requirements.

For example:

Aspiring litigators may benefit from evidence, trial advocacy, and procedure courses.
Future business attorneys may consider corporate law, business associations, and taxation.
Students interested in public policy may explore administrative, constitutional, and legislative subjects.
Prospective intellectual property attorneys may consider specialized IP courses.
Students considering public-interest careers may benefit from clinics and courses related to access to justice.

Tobin also expressed support for broad exposure to business and taxation concepts.

Students should balance specialized interests with foundational legal knowledge and applicable bar examination requirements.

Advice for Law School Transfer Applicants

Some students consider transferring after completing their first year of law school.

Transfer decisions should involve careful evaluation of academic, professional, and financial consequences.

Tobin indicated that first-year law school performance was especially important when Maryland Carey Law evaluated transfer applicants during his deanship.

Strong 1L grades may demonstrate that an applicant can succeed in a rigorous legal academic environment.

However, transfer admissions policies vary by school.

Applicants should evaluate:

First-year academic performance.
Transfer application requirements.
Available seats and deadlines.
Transfer credit policies.
Scholarship and financial aid considerations.
Participation in journals and other activities.
Career services access.
Recruiting timelines and employer eligibility.

Transferring may offer advantages in some circumstances, but it does not automatically improve career outcomes.

Students should compare the opportunities available at their current institution with those offered by the prospective transfer school.

Frequently Asked Questions About Law School Admissions

What Matters Most in Law School Admissions?

Academic performance and evidence of readiness for legal study are important. However, applicants may also be evaluated through personal statements, recommendations, professional experiences, and other materials. The relative importance of each factor depends on the school and its admissions policies.

Can a Strong Personal Statement Improve Law School Admissions Chances?

A strong personal statement can help an applicant communicate qualities not obvious from grades or test scores. It may be especially useful when admissions committees compare candidates with similar academic credentials. However, no essay guarantees admission.

Should Applicants Choose a Law School Based on Rankings?

Rankings can be useful research tools, but they should not determine the entire decision. Applicants should compare academic programs, faculty, geographic location, employment outcomes, scholarships, and total educational costs. The best choice depends on individual goals and circumstances.

Does Work Experience Help with Law School Admissions?

Work experience can demonstrate maturity, responsibility, professional judgment, and time management skills. Nevertheless, it is not universally required. Applicants entering directly from college can also demonstrate readiness through academic work, internships, leadership, and community involvement.

Who Should Write a Law School Recommendation Letter?

Applicants should generally select individuals who can provide specific, credible examples of their abilities. Professors, research supervisors, and employers may be appropriate depending on the applicant's background and the school's requirements. Detailed recommendations are often more informative than generic endorsements.

How Important Are Law School Clinics and Externships?

Clinics and externships can provide supervised practical experience and expose students to different professional environments. They can also help students develop skills and assess career interests. Applicants should examine each school's current offerings, eligibility requirements, and placement opportunities.

What Should Applicants Consider Before Accepting a Law School Scholarship?

Applicants should examine the scholarship amount, renewal requirements, total cost of attendance, expected borrowing, and financial implications of different career paths. Scholarships should be evaluated as part of the overall educational investment.

Can Law School Transfer Students Participate in Recruiting and Extracurricular Activities?

Transfer students may have access to recruiting programs, journals, student organizations, and other activities. However, eligibility and deadlines vary by institution. Prospective transfers should confirm these details before enrolling.

Final Advice: Choose a Law School That Supports Long-Term Success

Donald Tobin's original interview offers a lasting lesson for prospective law students: a successful law school experience depends on more than rankings, credentials, or institutional reputation.

Applicants should consider whether a school provides the educational environment, practical opportunities, financial support, and professional resources they need.

Equally important, they should approach the admissions process with authenticity.

A thoughtful personal statement, credible recommendations, and a clear understanding of personal goals can help communicate an applicant's readiness for legal education.

Ultimately, the strongest law school decision is an informed one.

Students who carefully compare academic fit, affordability, experiential learning, and career outcomes are better positioned to choose a school that supports their long-term development.

Editor's Note: This article is an updated editorial adaptation of a historical Top Law Schools interview with Donald Tobin, who served as dean of the University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law from 2014 to 2022. The guidance reflects themes discussed during his deanship, supplemented by general admissions and career-planning information. It is not a new interview. Current admissions requirements, tuition, academic programs, and employment outcomes should be verified through official institutional sources.

Related Law School Admissions and Career Resources

For additional guidance, explore these resources:

Top Law Schools Resources

LawCrossing Career Resources

Join the Top Law Schools Forums

Connect with law school applicants, students, and graduates to discuss applications, essays, scholarships, school selection, and legal careers.

Law School Admissions Forum — Discuss admissions strategies, application requirements, and recommendation letters.
Law School Personal Statements Forum — Share essay ideas, request feedback, and discuss personal statement strategies.
Choosing a Law School Forum — Compare schools, rankings, educational opportunities, and student experiences.
Financial Aid Forum — Discuss scholarships, borrowing, tuition, and financial planning.
All Top Law Schools Forums — Browse additional discussions on law school admissions, legal education, and employment.

Join the conversation and explore the resources available through the Top Law Schools community.