Iowa WL-- Response from Admissions Forum

[krj02004]

So I was WL at Iowa 2 weeks ago. They emailed today that they have an opening, however they would like me to respond to a couple questions before an Admissions Rep calls me. Here are the Q's:

1) Am I still Interested?
2) How likely am I to accept an offer of Admission

Here's my dilemna... I got into Vandy but they gave me crappy financial aid. I'm very open to going to the MidWest but ONLY if they give me a significant amount of financial aid. I doubt I should email those exact words to Iowa, but it's the truth that I need them to give me $$. I'm a single mom so I have other costs to factor in, namely childcare expenses.

I'm trying to figure out a way to tell Iowa I'm very interested in them academically, but only with significant scholarship $$ without sounding completely unprofessional and ending up without an official offer of Admission. How do I approach these questions? Or, should I completely forget mentioning financial aid?

[missinglink]

So I was WL at Iowa 2 weeks ago. They emailed today that they have an opening, however they would like me to respond to a couple questions before an Admissions Rep calls me. Here are the Q's:

1) Am I still Interested?
2) How likely am I to accept an offer of Admission

Here's my dilemna... I got into Vandy but they gave me crappy financial aid. I'm very open to going to the MidWest but ONLY if they give me a significant amount of financial aid. I doubt I should email those exact words to Iowa, but it's the truth that I need them to give me $$. I'm a single mom so I have other costs to factor in, namely childcare expenses.

I'm trying to figure out a way to tell Iowa I'm very interested in them academically, but only with significant scholarship $$ without sounding completely unprofessional and ending up without an official offer of Admission. How do I approach these questions? Or, should I completely forget mentioning financial aid?

I would write back that you are interested and would accept. You're right that it isn't really the right venue to talk financial aid. Once you're on the phone with the admissions rep is the time to talk cash, I think.

I'll let some other people chime in here, as I'm just an uninformed 0L, but this is my best sense of the situation.

[im_blue]

I'm surprised you got into Vandy (3.71/168 medians) but got WL at Iowa (3.61/161). Are you an extreme splitter, URM, or other special case?

[JOThompson]

If your acceptance of the offer is contingent upon financial aid, then let them know ASAP. Your chat with the admissions rep will probably be more productive if he/she knows the situation before calling you.

[09042014]

If your acceptance of the offer is contingent upon financial aid, then let them know ASAP. Your chat with the admissions rep will probably be more productive if he/she knows the situation before calling you.

Fuck that, let them take the yield hit if they won't pay up. What they are doing is cheating.

[krj02004]

I'm surprised you got into Vandy (3.71/168 medians) but got WL at Iowa (3.61/161). Are you an extreme splitter, URM, or other special case?

My merits speak for themself

I've been accepted and waitlisted all over the place...accepted at Cornell but waitlisted at American. Makes no sense.


So it seems I'm getting split advice.... maybe I should call a rep and ask about what's left of financial aid at Iowa before submitting my "official" response?

[webbylu87]

Having visited Iowa two weeks ago and spoken with Dean Byrd about financial aid, I honestly doubt any will become available. There are 78 people who were admitted and nominated for scholarships but who aren't receiving any money because they ran out of cash. I was told that if money were to become available it would be reallocated to those nominated for full rides before anyone else. Dean Byrd made it sounds like only 4-5 people out of this 78 might get some more money.

Like I said, I doubt they'll be able to throw cash your way but I suppose it's worth a try. With that said, it's always been my understanding that if you get in off the WL you should be expecting to pay full price. I'm thinking this is their understanding as well. When you email them back I might just ask if they think there's any chance of some financial assistance outside of the loans. That way you're not telling them you'll only go with money, but you still get your answer.

[JuTMSY4]

If your acceptance of the offer is contingent upon financial aid, then let them know ASAP. Your chat with the admissions rep will probably be more productive if he/she knows the situation before calling you.

TITCR. Be honest but professional. At worst, they'll just ultimately reject you and you'd be going to Vandy anyway. At best, they'll give you a better offer.

Vandy's a bargaining chip in my mind.

[krj02004]

I took people's advice, and I decided to call Dean Bird first before writing him back to tell him how very interested I am in Iowa, but wanted to know the possibility of any scholarship availability for WL candidates.

He said that he had my file right in front of him actually, and that that recent scholarship money came available ... and he is confident they can offer me an attractive financial aid package.

We'll see.... it would have to be a crap load of money if I'm going to turn down Vandy. I'm crossing my fingers though!

[webbylu87]

I took people's advice, and I decided to call Dean Bird first before writing him back to tell him how very interested I am in Iowa, but wanted to know the possibility of any scholarship availability for WL candidates.

He said that he had my file right in front of him actually, and that that recent scholarship money came available ... and he is confident they can offer me an attractive financial aid package.

We'll see.... it would have to be a crap load of money if I'm going to turn down Vandy. I'm crossing my fingers though!

This is great news for you. Congrats!

I do have to say though that this is somewhat disappointing for others who were admitted months ago and have been hoping for scholarship money to be reallocated to them. I can't help but feel like this is somewhat unfair.

[letsgo]

I took people's advice, and I decided to call Dean Bird first before writing him back to tell him how very interested I am in Iowa, but wanted to know the possibility of any scholarship availability for WL candidates.

He said that he had my file right in front of him actually, and that that recent scholarship money came available ... and he is confident they can offer me an attractive financial aid package.

We'll see.... it would have to be a crap load of money if I'm going to turn down Vandy. I'm crossing my fingers though!

I wouldn't pick Iowa over Vandy under any circumstance.

[webbylu87]

I took people's advice, and I decided to call Dean Bird first before writing him back to tell him how very interested I am in Iowa, but wanted to know the possibility of any scholarship availability for WL candidates.

He said that he had my file right in front of him actually, and that that recent scholarship money came available ... and he is confident they can offer me an attractive financial aid package.

We'll see.... it would have to be a crap load of money if I'm going to turn down Vandy. I'm crossing my fingers though!

I wouldn't pick Iowa over Vandy under any circumstance.

I wouldn't either but OP is a single parent so their considerations are slightly different than the average law student.

[JuTMSY4]

I took people's advice, and I decided to call Dean Bird first before writing him back to tell him how very interested I am in Iowa, but wanted to know the possibility of any scholarship availability for WL candidates.

He said that he had my file right in front of him actually, and that that recent scholarship money came available ... and he is confident they can offer me an attractive financial aid package.

We'll see.... it would have to be a crap load of money if I'm going to turn down Vandy. I'm crossing my fingers though!

Did you mention that your other offer is from Vandy? I think this is an important detail...

[letsgo]

I took people's advice, and I decided to call Dean Bird first before writing him back to tell him how very interested I am in Iowa, but wanted to know the possibility of any scholarship availability for WL candidates.

He said that he had my file right in front of him actually, and that that recent scholarship money came available ... and he is confident they can offer me an attractive financial aid package.

We'll see.... it would have to be a crap load of money if I'm going to turn down Vandy. I'm crossing my fingers though!

I wouldn't pick Iowa over Vandy under any circumstance.

I wouldn't either but OP is a single parent so their considerations are slightly different than the average law student.

Mmm..yeah tough call.

[Sias]

If your acceptance of the offer is contingent upon financial aid, then let them know ASAP. Your chat with the admissions rep will probably be more productive if he/she knows the situation before calling you.

Fuck that, let them take the yield hit if they won't pay up. What they are doing is cheating.

+1

[MoS]

I took people's advice, and I decided to call Dean Bird first before writing him back to tell him how very interested I am in Iowa, but wanted to know the possibility of any scholarship availability for WL candidates.

He said that he had my file right in front of him actually, and that that recent scholarship money came available ... and he is confident they can offer me an attractive financial aid package.

We'll see.... it would have to be a crap load of money if I'm going to turn down Vandy. I'm crossing my fingers though!

Did Dean Byrd tell you Rodney Dangerfield jokes? Just curious.

My guess is that they want some part of your numbers if they are letting you in off the waitlist. And you told them the truth so kudos to you. If they offer you money, which I hope they do, they have only handed out full scholarships this year so far, you won't be disappointed. If they don't, well you told them the situation and that is all you can do. But be wary of their contingencies.

[krj02004]

Yeah, I totally understand that possible picking Iowa over Vandy is a head-scratcher. But I have TWO babies, a divorce I'm paying for, and my ex-husband is unreliable when it comes to the child support.

I loved Vandy when I visited.... but they only gave me $10k.... I have to take out an additional $10k for childcare loans, so basically I would be paying full sticker price at Vandy and come out with around $200k in debt.

If I was single with no children, I would be at Vandy in a heartbeat...or hope to get off the WL at Columbia and head to NY . But I honestly think that when you have kids, there are so many unknowns in the future that I have to take into account. I want my kids to go to good schools and have a good quality of life... that's going to be hard to do with $200k in debt and I feel even more pressure to make sure to get a high paying job when I graduate in biglaw.... but my heart is in public interest. ANd what if one of my children became ill and it was necessary for me to work only PT... or some other unexpected life event? SO many things to consider. And also, I'm trying ot be realistic here... to graduate top of your class at a highly ranked school requires A LOT of time... time I may not have while raising 2 children. But I don't know... I will find out. But the last thing I need to happen is to graduate bottom of my class at Vandy... or anywhere... that won't look good to any employer.

I think for me I have to go where the money is, even if it isn't my top 20 dream school. Hey, at least I'm GOING to law school and for me, with everything I've been through, that's a success story in itself . And Iowa is still ranked 26th!


What do you think? Am I way off base?

[webbylu87]

Yeah, I totally understand that possible picking Iowa over Vandy is a head-scratcher. But I have TWO babies, a divorce I'm paying for, and my ex-husband is unreliable when it comes to the child support.

I loved Vandy when I visited.... but they only gave me $10k.... I have to take out an additional $10k for childcare loans, so basically I would be paying full sticker price at Vandy and come out with around $200k in debt.

If I was single with no children, I would be at Vandy in a heartbeat...or hope to get off the WL at Columbia and head to NY . But I honestly think that when you have kids, there are so many unknowns in the future that I have to take into account. I want my kids to go to good schools and have a good quality of life... that's going to be hard to do with $200k in debt and I feel even more pressure to make sure to get a high paying job when I graduate in biglaw.... but my heart is in public interest. ANd what if one of my children became ill and it was necessary for me to work only PT... or some other unexpected life event? SO many things to consider. And also, I'm trying ot be realistic here... to graduate top of your class at a highly ranked school requires A LOT of time... time I may not have while raising 2 children. But I don't know... I will find out. But the last thing I need to happen is to graduate bottom of my class at Vandy... or anywhere... that won't look good to any employer.

I think for me I have to go where the money is, even if it isn't my top 20 dream school. Hey, at least I'm GOING to law school and for me, with everything I've been through, that's a success story in itself . And Iowa is still ranked 26th!


What do you think? Am I way off base?

I think your logic is sound. Not everyone can afford to take the risk of high loans and honestly the financial health of your family must come first. I don't think anyone should fault you if you decide on Iowa with a large scholarship over Vandy in your circumstances. Did Dean Byrd have any inclination when you might know your financial package?

[letsgo]

Yeah, I totally understand that possible picking Iowa over Vandy is a head-scratcher. But I have TWO babies, a divorce I'm paying for, and my ex-husband is unreliable when it comes to the child support.

I loved Vandy when I visited.... but they only gave me $10k.... I have to take out an additional $10k for childcare loans, so basically I would be paying full sticker price at Vandy and come out with around $200k in debt.

If I was single with no children, I would be at Vandy in a heartbeat...or hope to get off the WL at Columbia and head to NY . But I honestly think that when you have kids, there are so many unknowns in the future that I have to take into account. I want my kids to go to good schools and have a good quality of life... that's going to be hard to do with $200k in debt and I feel even more pressure to make sure to get a high paying job when I graduate in biglaw.... but my heart is in public interest. ANd what if one of my children became ill and it was necessary for me to work only PT... or some other unexpected life event? SO many things to consider. And also, I'm trying ot be realistic here... to graduate top of your class at a highly ranked school requires A LOT of time... time I may not have while raising 2 children. But I don't know... I will find out. But the last thing I need to happen is to graduate bottom of my class at Vandy... or anywhere... that won't look good to any employer.

I think for me I have to go where the money is, even if it isn't my top 20 dream school. Hey, at least I'm GOING to law school and for me, with everything I've been through, that's a success story in itself . And Iowa is still ranked 26th!


What do you think? Am I way off base?

Follow the Money work really hard at Iowa ---> profit....i gave up a full scholarship at Iowa ...maybe it will go to you...But you should call them and tell them ur situation and i can see a full ride coming your way.

[JOThompson]

If PI is your ambition, you may want to consider Vandy at sticker over an Iowa full ride. Vanderbilt is going to offer the best boost to your career and you need every edge ITE. IBR is an imperfect safety net, but still a decent fallback. Using that logic, If Vandy offers me admission, I know I'd readily take the offer and forego my scholly at Iowa.

[krj02004]

Yeah, I totally understand that possible picking Iowa over Vandy is a head-scratcher. But I have TWO babies, a divorce I'm paying for, and my ex-husband is unreliable when it comes to the child support.

I loved Vandy when I visited.... but they only gave me $10k.... I have to take out an additional $10k for childcare loans, so basically I would be paying full sticker price at Vandy and come out with around $200k in debt.

If I was single with no children, I would be at Vandy in a heartbeat...or hope to get off the WL at Columbia and head to NY . But I honestly think that when you have kids, there are so many unknowns in the future that I have to take into account. I want my kids to go to good schools and have a good quality of life... that's going to be hard to do with $200k in debt and I feel even more pressure to make sure to get a high paying job when I graduate in biglaw.... but my heart is in public interest. ANd what if one of my children became ill and it was necessary for me to work only PT... or some other unexpected life event? SO many things to consider. And also, I'm trying ot be realistic here... to graduate top of your class at a highly ranked school requires A LOT of time... time I may not have while raising 2 children. But I don't know... I will find out. But the last thing I need to happen is to graduate bottom of my class at Vandy... or anywhere... that won't look good to any employer.

I think for me I have to go where the money is, even if it isn't my top 20 dream school. Hey, at least I'm GOING to law school and for me, with everything I've been through, that's a success story in itself . And Iowa is still ranked 26th!


What do you think? Am I way off base?

I think your logic is sound. Not everyone can afford to take the risk of high loans and honestly the financial health of your family must come first. I don't think anyone should fault you if you decide on Iowa with a large scholarship over Vandy in your circumstances. Did Dean Byrd have any inclination when you might know your financial package?

24-48 hours

[webbylu87]

Just out of curiosity, did Iowa ever get back to you?

[krj02004]

Just out of curiosity, did Iowa ever get back to you?

Yes... In! Good luck to everyone .

[MoS]

Any aid money?

[krj02004]

Any aid money?

They said it's in the mail... so waiting to review the package. Hopefully it's substantial.