My question is: On RC "which of the following situations is most closely analogous to the situation described [somewhere in the passage]" questions, can the analogous terms be reversed?
For example, PT 11-S3-P2 "Dahl and democracies"
We are looking for a situation that is most analogous to pluralist democracies as they are described in relation to democratic principles of political equality.
Here's my Pre- Question Analysis:
Pluralist democracies are the closest match to political equality, even though they are not a perfect match, so we are looking for that in an answer choice.
I eliminated answer choice (B), which is the correct answer, because pluralist democracies (the term the question was asking about) does not have anything that is incapable of captured by anything.
The correct analysis, which I found on the Manhattan forum, is that the range of tonality (or the thing that cannot be captured) = the principle of equality and that all the instruments incapable of matching its tonality = pluralist democracies.
This analysis involves switching what the question is talking about.
Do you see what I'm saying? The question asked which one of the following is most analogous to PLURALIST DEMOCRACIES as they are described IN RELATION TO the democratic principle of equality.
So for (B) to be correct, it SHOULD say something like: "A musical score that cannot completely capture the tonal range of a musical instrument" because pluralist democracies cannot fully capture the range of political equality.
Instead the correct answer switches the terms around. Should I take this to be OK for these types of questions?
RC analogous situation question- general and specific Forum
Prepare for the LSAT or discuss it with others in this forum.
Return to “LSAT Prep and Discussion Forum”
Jump to
- Law School Admissions
- ↳ Law School Admissions Forum
- ↳ Law School Personal Statements
- ↳ LSAT Prep and Discussion Forum
- ↳ Law School Acceptances, Denials, and Waitlists
- ↳ Law School Visits
- ↳ Choosing a Law School
- ↳ What are my chances?
- ↳ Financial Aid
- ↳ Ask a Law Student / Graduate
- ↳ Transfers
- Law School
- ↳ Forum for Law School Students
- ↳ Ask a Law Student
- ↳ Non-US Law Schools Forum
- ↳ Bar Exam Prep and Discussion Forum
- ↳ Law School Courses
- Law School Class Forums
- ↳ TLS Class of 2025 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2024 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2023 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2022 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2021 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2020 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2019 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2018 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2017 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2016 Forum
- Legal Employment/Careers
- ↳ Legal Employment
- ↳ Judicial Clerkships
- ↳ OCI
- ↳ In-House
- ↳ Small & Midsized Firms
- ↳ 1st Year and 2nd Year Summer
- ↳ Big Law/Private Practice Jobs
- ↳ Public Interest & Government
- ↳ Alternative Careers
- ↳ Lateral Moves
- ↳ Interview Tips
- ↳ Resume Tips
- Underrepresented Lawyers and Students
- ↳ Black Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Hispanic and Latino Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Asian Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ American Indian Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Women Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ LGBTQ+ Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Disabled Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ First Generation Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Veteran Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Single Parent Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Underrepresented Law Students
- Legal Practice
- ↳ Forum for Law School Graduates Only
- ↳ Discussion of Practice Areas
- ↳ Legal News/Law Firm Gossip
- ↳ Firm Q&A by Region
- Legal Advice
- ↳ Free Help and Advice from Professionals
- Off-Topic
- ↳ Buy - Exchange - Giveaway - Sell
- ↳ TLS Content Competitions
- ↳ Other forums not on the main forum index page
- ↳ TLS Class of 2015 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2014 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2013 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2012 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2011 Forum
- ↳ TLS wiki forum
- ↳ TLS Web Logs (Blogs)