If you own, Official LSAT Superprep book... Forum

[secondshot]

This is a question about an answer on page 7 of this book. If you have the book and can help, I'd really appreciate it.

Page 7. In regards to, "any one of which", I keep coming up with B as the answer, not D as the book suggests is correct. Simply because "Sharon visits a different city than Paul", so how can D be the answer when they are both present? B seems to satisfy all of the conditions.

I just started studying for the LSAT today, so I'm in freak out mode. Thanks for your patience.

[Daily_Double]

.

[secondshot]

Got it, thanks for your help. I was being a little facetious there, I'm not really in panic mode, just frustrated with this particular question because I can't figure out why I'm wrong and don't want to move on until I can see where I'm tripping up.

So if anyone can peek in their book and point out my error, that would be awesome.

Thanks again.

[CardozoLaw09]

Got it, thanks for your help. I was being a little facetious there, I'm not really in panic mode, just frustrated with this particular question because I can't figure out why I'm wrong and don't want to move on until I can see where I'm tripping up.

So if anyone can peek in their book and point out my error, that would be awesome.

Thanks again.

I don't have the actual book, but I do have the SuperPrep's - if you could point out which test it was, the section, and the number, I may be able to help you out!

[Cambridge LSAT]

The question is asking for all the people who could visit Vancouver under any scenario, not in one particular scenario. The subtle difference in wording can be tricky to spot.

Here's an another example:

• Which one of the following is a complete and accurate list of people, any one of which could see the movie on Friday?
• Which one of the following could be a complete and accurate list of people who see the movie on Friday?

In the first case, we're looking for an exhaustive list of variables which can be placed in the Friday slots in any acceptable scenario. In the second case, we're looking for a group of variables which could be tied to Friday in one acceptable scenario. Notice the placement of the word "could."