If the conditional is:
A->B->C
Can that also be seen as:
A->~C->~B
Are you allowed to flip and negate within a conditional. It seems that those 2 statements are equivocal.
I personally do not believe that it is valid.
I know the contrapositive is to fully reverse and negate, but I just was curious.
Conditional question concerning A->B->C Forum
-
- Posts: 121
- Joined: Wed Mar 15, 2006 5:12 pm
Re: Conditional question concerning A->B->C
CREATION,
You answer your own question with the statements you wrote. Writing a partial contrapositive yields A leading to both B and ~B, as well as C and ~C.
A=study hard
B=high LSAT
C=attend a top law school
Try substituting these in and see what happens.
You answer your own question with the statements you wrote. Writing a partial contrapositive yields A leading to both B and ~B, as well as C and ~C.
A=study hard
B=high LSAT
C=attend a top law school
Try substituting these in and see what happens.
- LexLeon
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 11:03 pm
Re: Conditional question concerning A->B->C
*equivalent.
From the conditional chain
A -> B -> C
the following list exhausts all possible inferences, I think:
A -> B -> C
A -> B
A -> C
~C -> ~B -> ~A
~C -> ~B
~C -> ~A
From the conditional chain
A -> B -> C
the following list exhausts all possible inferences, I think:
A -> B -> C
A -> B
A -> C
~C -> ~B -> ~A
~C -> ~B
~C -> ~A