PT 46, Section II, #23
My approach:
Kind ---> loved by somebody
love anyone ---> happy
Conclusion: kind ---> happy
Hmmm... just don't know how to tie this one together.
conclusions follows logically if the following is assumed... Forum
-
Massimiliano
- Posts: 36
- Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 3:19 am
-
tomwatts
- Posts: 1710
- Joined: Wed Sep 16, 2009 12:01 am
Re: conclusions follows logically if the following is assumed...
The missing piece is:
loved by somebody -> love anyone
If you had that, you could do:
Kind ---> loved by somebody -> love anyone ---> happy
which is what you're trying to do. IIRC, the credited response is the contrapositive of the missing piece (i.e. ~love anyone -> ~loved by somebody, something like "Whoever loves no one is loved by no one").
loved by somebody -> love anyone
If you had that, you could do:
Kind ---> loved by somebody -> love anyone ---> happy
which is what you're trying to do. IIRC, the credited response is the contrapositive of the missing piece (i.e. ~love anyone -> ~loved by somebody, something like "Whoever loves no one is loved by no one").
