Law Review Write Ons Forum
-
- Posts: 242
- Joined: Mon Feb 21, 2011 8:28 pm
Law Review Write Ons
I am a 1L and understand that this is a LONG way off, but what goes into the law review write on? I'm just curious since we're starting to go more in depth on citations and things like that, which is making my head spin, and I'm told that is a lot of what it takes to write on to law review.
Understand grades are a very large component, but I'm just curious about the write on competition.
Was kind of surprised there wasn't more info on the site about this. There are 100 "how to get good grades" articles (most of which are fantastic help, btw) but no "how to write on to law review" posts. Is it just editing? I assume it varies from school to school, but any overall info would be great!
Understand grades are a very large component, but I'm just curious about the write on competition.
Was kind of surprised there wasn't more info on the site about this. There are 100 "how to get good grades" articles (most of which are fantastic help, btw) but no "how to write on to law review" posts. Is it just editing? I assume it varies from school to school, but any overall info would be great!
-
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Sat Sep 21, 2013 5:39 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
gobosox wrote:I am a 1L and understand that this is a LONG way off, but what goes into the law review write on? I'm just curious since we're starting to go more in depth on citations and things like that, which is making my head spin, and I'm told that is a lot of what it takes to write on to law review.
Understand grades are a very large component, but I'm just curious about the write on competition.
Was kind of surprised there wasn't more info on the site about this. There are 100 "how to get good grades" articles (most of which are fantastic help, btw) but no "how to write on to law review" posts. Is it just editing? I assume it varies from school to school, but any overall info would be great!
Law review write on is just writing a paper. Read a few law review articles to get a handle on academic writing. Legal methods class will help you learn "legal writing."
- BVest
- Posts: 7887
- Joined: Tue Mar 20, 2012 1:51 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
Unless your school's competition also includes cite checking and/or editing, and I believe your school does have something more than the written product.WHJTMG178 wrote: Law review write on is just writing a paper.
If it involves cite check, that will probably be 12-20 different sources where you're given a copy of the source and you have to provide a proper bluebook citation. It won't be all cases like in LRW. It will include some domestic cases and statutes, maybe some foreign material, maybe some pop culture, some secondary sources of various types (LR, treatise, etc.), books, speeches/interviews, etc. Basically, if there's a bluebook entry about citing to it, it's fair game.
If it involves editing, there will likely be between 7 and 20 pages from one or more draft law review articles and you will be given a copy of the LR's proper editing marks. Using that, you will be required to edit the article.
As far as grades: All schools use grades in some way. Here are some of the ways they can do that (you need to look into what your school does and doesn't use... it can be a combination of these, and this is not meant to be exhaustive):
Automatic Admission Floor: LR takes everyone top X% (5 or 10) who applies. Alternately, some schools require that you not only apply, but also put faith some minimum quality effort.
Weighting: They give a raw score to the application and then add in or multiply in some bonus for grades.
Eligibility Floor: You must be in top Y% to qualify for LR (e.g. 50%). Among those who are in top Y% (occasionally applied only to those who are not also in top X% if there's an Automatic Floor), the best scores on the application get in.
Last edited by BVest on Sat Jan 27, 2018 5:59 am, edited 1 time in total.
- jbagelboy
- Posts: 10361
- Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2012 7:57 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
our school doesn't produce exact rubrics, but they award 15 spots for write-on exclusively, which has a citation portion (but its not anything you could try to "learn" fall of 1L), and the remaining 30 based on *roughly* 1/3 grades, 1/3 write-on, 1/3 diversity
-
- Posts: 242
- Joined: Mon Feb 21, 2011 8:28 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
This doesn't sound especially time-consuming. Why is it a 2-3 day marathon event? Is there also a paper as a previous poster noted?BVest wrote:
Unless your school's competition also includes cite checking and/or editing, and I believe your school does have something more than the written product.
If it involves cite check, that will probably be 12-20 different sources where you're given a copy of the source and you have to provide a proper bluebook citation. It won't be all cases like in LRW. It will include some domestic cases and statutes, maybe some foreign material, maybe some pop culture, some secondary sources of various types (LR, treatise, etc.), books, speeches/interviews, etc. Basically, if there's a bluebook entry about citing to it, it's fair game.
If it involves editing, there will likely be between 7 and 20 pages from one or more draft law review articles and you will be given a copy of the LR's proper editing marks. Using that, you will be required to edit the article.
Want to continue reading?
Register now to search topics and post comments!
Absolutely FREE!
Already a member? Login
- A. Nony Mouse
- Posts: 29293
- Joined: Tue Sep 25, 2012 11:51 am
Re: Law Review Write Ons
There is usually also a paper, yes - the above is on top of the paper.
And there are schools where grades are a really really minimal factor (but my sense is that grades are huge at most T-14s).
And there are schools where grades are a really really minimal factor (but my sense is that grades are huge at most T-14s).
- FuturePanhandler
- Posts: 907
- Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2014 9:31 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
1/3 diversity? Do the handouts ever end?jbagelboy wrote:our school doesn't produce exact rubrics, but they award 15 spots for write-on exclusively, which has a citation portion (but its not anything you could try to "learn" fall of 1L), and the remaining 30 based on *roughly* 1/3 grades, 1/3 write-on, 1/3 diversity
- sesto elemento
- Posts: 1549
- Joined: Wed Aug 20, 2014 7:29 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
Yes. At UChicago, the law review journal doesn't reserve any spots based on diversity.FuturePanhandler wrote:1/3 diversity? Do the handouts ever end?jbagelboy wrote:our school doesn't produce exact rubrics, but they award 15 spots for write-on exclusively, which has a citation portion (but its not anything you could try to "learn" fall of 1L), and the remaining 30 based on *roughly* 1/3 grades, 1/3 write-on, 1/3 diversity
- jbagelboy
- Posts: 10361
- Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2012 7:57 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
Just fyi mods this wasn't what I was trying to communicate/startFuturePanhandler wrote:1/3 diversity? Do the handouts ever end?jbagelboy wrote:our school doesn't produce exact rubrics, but they award 15 spots for write-on exclusively, which has a citation portion (but its not anything you could try to "learn" fall of 1L), and the remaining 30 based on *roughly* 1/3 grades, 1/3 write-on, 1/3 diversity
- patogordo
- Posts: 4826
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2014 3:33 am
Re: Law Review Write Ons
nope, you can go from birth to president without doing any workFuturePanhandler wrote:1/3 diversity? Do the handouts ever end?jbagelboy wrote:our school doesn't produce exact rubrics, but they award 15 spots for write-on exclusively, which has a citation portion (but its not anything you could try to "learn" fall of 1L), and the remaining 30 based on *roughly* 1/3 grades, 1/3 write-on, 1/3 diversity
- BVest
- Posts: 7887
- Joined: Tue Mar 20, 2012 1:51 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
How does GWB qualify as "diversity"?patogordo wrote:you can go from birth to president without doing any work
Last edited by BVest on Sat Jan 27, 2018 5:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
- patogordo
- Posts: 4826
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2014 3:33 am
Re: Law Review Write Ons
He's in the 1 percent. How much more diverse can you be?BVest wrote:How does GWB qualify as "diversity"?patogordo wrote:you can go from birth to president without doing any work
- SilverE2
- Posts: 929
- Joined: Wed Aug 20, 2008 10:04 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
You have to write a paper too. My competition was a week, and I spent every waking hour not eating or sleeping on the application for a week straight. It was extremely stressful, and probably the most stressful part of law school. The competition at my school started the day of my last final. I ended up writing on to LR, but the process certainly wasn't fun.gobosox wrote:This doesn't sound especially time-consuming. Why is it a 2-3 day marathon event? Is there also a paper as a previous poster noted?BVest wrote:
Unless your school's competition also includes cite checking and/or editing, and I believe your school does have something more than the written product.
If it involves cite check, that will probably be 12-20 different sources where you're given a copy of the source and you have to provide a proper bluebook citation. It won't be all cases like in LRW. It will include some domestic cases and statutes, maybe some foreign material, maybe some pop culture, some secondary sources of various types (LR, treatise, etc.), books, speeches/interviews, etc. Basically, if there's a bluebook entry about citing to it, it's fair game.
If it involves editing, there will likely be between 7 and 20 pages from one or more draft law review articles and you will be given a copy of the LR's proper editing marks. Using that, you will be required to edit the article.
*Edit*
Oh, I got the lowest possible graded score in legal writing both semesters of 1L year. So I don't believe that success in the competition amounts to anything more than just putting more work in than others. Or maybe my legal writing professor and I just weren't on the same wavelength. Who knows, because other than those terrible grades, there's nothing that makes me believe I'm a bad writer, legal or otherwise.
Register now!
Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.
It's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 242
- Joined: Mon Feb 21, 2011 8:28 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
Yeah that's kinda what I'm interested in. Do others have the same experience? Are these truly just brute strength after being drained during finals, or is it more of an overall understanding of the 1L year/legal writing class?SilverE2 wrote:Oh, I got the lowest possible graded score in legal writing both semesters of 1L year. So I don't believe that success in the competition amounts to anything more than just putting more work in than others. Or maybe my legal writing professor and I just weren't on the same wavelength. Who knows, because other than those terrible grades, there's nothing that makes me believe I'm a bad writer, legal or otherwise.
- A. Nony Mouse
- Posts: 29293
- Joined: Tue Sep 25, 2012 11:51 am
Re: Law Review Write Ons
My experience (going through and then grading write-ons) is that it's mostly brute strength - willingness to grind through all the materials and actually put the work in to do a thorough job right after finals. Doing the work and following all the directions to the letter is a huge part of success. Also, at least at my school (and I think most, though not all, schools), for LR write-on you write a mini/pseudo law review article, not a brief or memo. So you're not really even trying to write the way you were taught to write in LRW.gobosox wrote:Yeah that's kinda what I'm interested in. Do others have the same experience? Are these truly just brute strength after being drained during finals, or is it more of an overall understanding of the 1L year/legal writing class?SilverE2 wrote:Oh, I got the lowest possible graded score in legal writing both semesters of 1L year. So I don't believe that success in the competition amounts to anything more than just putting more work in than others. Or maybe my legal writing professor and I just weren't on the same wavelength. Who knows, because other than those terrible grades, there's nothing that makes me believe I'm a bad writer, legal or otherwise.
-
- Posts: 150
- Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 9:39 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
OP, first you're correct its going to very across schools
At my school it was a combination of class rank and score on the write on (you were graded on the content and the citations/structure with a rubric)
I ended up getting the highest scoring write on for my class--I just read prior LR articles written by students (particularly those who had gotten the highest score in previous years). Honestly, having graded write ons and writing the "best" one I can say, in my experience, the biggest issues were following instructions (students didnt follow page limits for instance)/making grammar/citation errors. In other words, students didn't really differentiate themselves based on substance.
At my school it was a combination of class rank and score on the write on (you were graded on the content and the citations/structure with a rubric)
I ended up getting the highest scoring write on for my class--I just read prior LR articles written by students (particularly those who had gotten the highest score in previous years). Honestly, having graded write ons and writing the "best" one I can say, in my experience, the biggest issues were following instructions (students didnt follow page limits for instance)/making grammar/citation errors. In other words, students didn't really differentiate themselves based on substance.
- salix
- Posts: 93
- Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:13 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
http://www.amazon.com/Making-Law-Review ... law+review
This was a very helpful little book. Read it in the weeks before your competition. It offers good tips on organizing your time and approach.
This was a very helpful little book. Read it in the weeks before your competition. It offers good tips on organizing your time and approach.
Get unlimited access to all forums and topics
Register now!
I'm pretty sure I told you it's FREE...
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2014 5:30 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
I can attest that this book was golden for my preparation for the Write-On Competition. I got accepted into every Journal at my school. I would also recommend looking over the BlueBook at least 2-3 weeks prior to the competition. This may be difficult because in most schools the write-on is right after finals. I was lucky in that regard because as a Transfer I participated right before classes started in the Fall.salix wrote:http://www.amazon.com/Making-Law-Review ... law+review
This was a very helpful little book. Read it in the weeks before your competition. It offers good tips on organizing your time and approach.
Hope this Helps
- Desert Fox
- Posts: 18283
- Joined: Thu Sep 04, 2014 4:34 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
Writing onto law review is a waste of effort. It's not valuable because everyone knows you didn't have the grades for it.
Last edited by Desert Fox on Sat Jan 27, 2018 6:03 am, edited 1 time in total.
- ScottRiqui
- Posts: 3633
- Joined: Mon Nov 29, 2010 8:09 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
Do employers necessarily know whether you wrote on or graded on? I don't know enough about the timeline to know whether the GPA you have when you're considered for grade-on is the same GPA the employers see at OCI.Desert Fox wrote:Writing onto law review is a waste of effort. It's not valuable because everyone knows you didn't have the grades for it.
- Desert Fox
- Posts: 18283
- Joined: Thu Sep 04, 2014 4:34 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
At 2L OCI, it's the same grades.ScottRiqui wrote:Do employers necessarily know whether you wrote on or graded on? I don't know enough about the timeline to know whether the GPA you have when you're considered for grade-on is the same GPA the employers see at OCI.Desert Fox wrote:Writing onto law review is a waste of effort. It's not valuable because everyone knows you didn't have the grades for it.
The only time it really helps is if you are on the fringes on "grade on" and people will just assume you graded on.
Last edited by Desert Fox on Sat Jan 27, 2018 6:03 am, edited 1 time in total.
Communicate now with those who not only know what a legal education is, but can offer you worthy advice and commentary as you complete the three most educational, yet challenging years of your law related post graduate life.
Register now, it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
- ScottRiqui
- Posts: 3633
- Joined: Mon Nov 29, 2010 8:09 pm
Re: Law Review Write Ons
Gotcha, thanks.Desert Fox wrote:At 2L OCI, it's the same grades.ScottRiqui wrote:Do employers necessarily know whether you wrote on or graded on? I don't know enough about the timeline to know whether the GPA you have when you're considered for grade-on is the same GPA the employers see at OCI.Desert Fox wrote:Writing onto law review is a waste of effort. It's not valuable because everyone knows you didn't have the grades for it.
The only time it really helps is if you are on the fringes on "grade on" and people will just assume you graded on.
- Lexaholik
- Posts: 233
- Joined: Fri May 31, 2013 10:44 am
Re: Law Review Write Ons
I always struggled in my legal writing classes, but by sheer effort managed OK grades. I ended up writing on to LR. (So don't appraise your own legal writing ability based on your LRW grades)gobosox wrote:Yeah that's kinda what I'm interested in. Do others have the same experience? Are these truly just brute strength after being drained during finals, or is it more of an overall understanding of the 1L year/legal writing class?SilverE2 wrote:Oh, I got the lowest possible graded score in legal writing both semesters of 1L year. So I don't believe that success in the competition amounts to anything more than just putting more work in than others. Or maybe my legal writing professor and I just weren't on the same wavelength. Who knows, because other than those terrible grades, there's nothing that makes me believe I'm a bad writer, legal or otherwise.
And yes, it is largely brute strength and willpower to press on when others are tired (similar to much of law practice). But all that brute strength won't matter if you don't understand the fundamentals of how to read and interpret cases and statutes. Make sure you know how to do that.
Seriously? What are you waiting for?
Now there's a charge.
Just kidding ... it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login