question about mailbox rule Forum

[goosey]

does it only apply to offers sent over mail? so for example, if offeror sends offer via telephone convo, would the mailbox rule not apply? what if the offeree accepted via voicemail??

[Baylan]

The mailbox rule operates because it is an objective manifestation of a parties intent. It is the discernible point between having the power of acceptance and when an acceptance occurs. All the time-problems really revolve around when the agreement comes into being.

So, the mailbox really doesn't really operate in conversation. But it all comes back to objective manifestation of mutual assent.

It is really tough to tell specifically if it applies in your question though without a hypothetical...

[Always Credited]

does it only apply to offers sent over mail? so for example, if offeror sends offer via telephone convo, would the mailbox rule not apply? what if the offeree accepted via voicemail??

No clear rule to deal with this, but analogize to the mailbox rule for +50 points. Include the policy behind the mailbox rule, as mentioned above, for an additional +50 points.


Then move on.

[YourCaptain]

does it only apply to offers sent over mail? so for example, if offeror sends offer via telephone convo, would the mailbox rule not apply? what if the offeree accepted via voicemail??

No clear rule to deal with this, but analogize to the mailbox rule for +50 points. Include the policy behind the mailbox rule, as mentioned above, for an additional +50 points.


Then move on.

You're meant to respond in a manner appropriate to the offer.

If in the course of the conversation they make the offer, if you don't accept when you hang up the offeror may state that the offer is dead. I think if the offeror left a voicemail and the offeree left a voicemail back, on an exam you should be able to make a strong argument for the offeree responding appropriately.

Be sure to argue both sides and all that jazz.