Finding appellate history Forum

[Grad_Student]

Thanks to the one poster who actually helped out

And fuck you to everyone else who didn't.

[Ender Wiggins]

I have a case that just came down from the Supreme Court, Carachuri-Rosendo v. Holder, and I want to find out which district court it was appealed from. Any ideas?

I'm guessing you're not in law school yet, or you'd know to look in the procedural history contained within the case itself.

[Grad_Student]

I have a case that just came down from the Supreme Court, Carachuri-Rosendo v. Holder, and I want to find out which district court it was appealed from. Any ideas?

I'm guessing you're not in law school yet, or you'd know to look in the procedural history contained within the case itself.

I appreciate the rib newbie but the farthest it goes back to is the INS. I guess I'll have to look up the trial court on the database at work. Thanks anyways.

[Renzo]

I have a case that just came down from the Supreme Court, Carachuri-Rosendo v. Holder, and I want to find out which district court it was appealed from. Any ideas?

I'm guessing you're not in law school yet, or you'd know to look in the procedural history contained within the case itself.

I appreciate the rib newbie but the farthest it goes back to is the INS. I guess I'll have to look up the trial court on the database at work. Thanks anyways.

You know the answer to your question, and you're still asking it? From what you said, it was an appeal from an INS administrative decision. Am I missing something?

[vamedic03]

I have a case that just came down from the Supreme Court, Carachuri-Rosendo v. Holder, and I want to find out which district court it was appealed from. Any ideas?

I'm guessing you're not in law school yet, or you'd know to look in the procedural history contained within the case itself.

I appreciate the rib newbie but the farthest it goes back to is the INS. I guess I'll have to look up the trial court on the database at work. Thanks anyways.

There was no Art III trial court - it originated with an Immigration Judge -> Board of Immigration Appeals -> 5th COA [courtesy of the Petition for Cert's Statement of the Case courtesy of SCOTUSBlog]

[nealric]

If you have a lexis account, just hit the "shepardize" button.
If you have a westlaw account, hit the "keycite" button.

[Grad_Student]

I have a case that just came down from the Supreme Court, Carachuri-Rosendo v. Holder, and I want to find out which district court it was appealed from. Any ideas?

I'm guessing you're not in law school yet, or you'd know to look in the procedural history contained within the case itself.

I appreciate the rib newbie but the farthest it goes back to is the INS. I guess I'll have to look up the trial court on the database at work. Thanks anyways.

You know the answer to your question, and you're still asking it? From what you said, it was an appeal from an INS administrative decision. Am I missing something?

I looked so more.

I have a case that just came down from the Supreme Court, Carachuri-Rosendo v. Holder, and I want to find out which district court it was appealed from. Any ideas?

I'm guessing you're not in law school yet, or you'd know to look in the procedural history contained within the case itself.

I appreciate the rib newbie but the farthest it goes back to is the INS. I guess I'll have to look up the trial court on the database at work. Thanks anyways.

There was no Art III trial court - it originated with an Immigration Judge -> Board of Immigration Appeals -> 5th COA [courtesy of the Petition for Cert's Statement of the Case courtesy of SCOTUSBlog]

Yes it what I was looking for. thanks

If you have a lexis account, just hit the "shepardize" button.
If you have a westlaw account, hit the "keycite" button.

not in-depth enough

[nealric]

If you have a lexis account, just hit the "shepardize" button.
If you have a westlaw account, hit the "keycite" button.

not in-depth enough

You should be getting the lower court opinion and any briefs/motions filed in the case. What else are you looking for?

[Anonymous Loser]

If you have a lexis account, just hit the "shepardize" button.
If you have a westlaw account, hit the "keycite" button.

not in-depth enough

You should be getting the lower court opinion and any briefs/motions filed in the case. What else are you looking for?

Key Cite won't show the EOIR decision; you need to take the extra step of clicking on "Direct History" to pull that up.

2007 WL 4624548

edit: Never mind. After looking over the thread, I see that the OP actually found this decision, but does not understand how judicial review of orders of removal works and is therefore confused.

[Grad_Student]

If you have a lexis account, just hit the "shepardize" button.
If you have a westlaw account, hit the "keycite" button.

not in-depth enough

You should be getting the lower court opinion and any briefs/motions filed in the case. What else are you looking for?

Key Cite won't show the EOIR decision; you need to take the extra step of clicking on "Direct History" to pull that up.

2007 WL 4624548

edit: Never mind. After looking over the thread, I see that the OP actually found this decision, but does not understand how judicial review of orders of removal works and is therefore confused.

not so much but thanks for trying to help anyways. Plus can't use westlaw at work, only have lexis so you have been no help.