Poll: MN or NYU? Forum

[Anonymous User]

Currently top 10%, Law Review at Minnesota. 12k a year scholarship.

Want to clerk, want Biglaw.

[derfs]

NYU without a doubt.

[skrzypce]

Where do you want to practice?

[Anonymous User]

OP here.

I'd like to practice outside of the midwest and I'm concerned I'll be limited in that regard at MN.

[MonsterTRM]

MN does not place into Biglaw well outside of MN and Wisconsin. I think your chances are better going to NYU. And the $12k per year isn't worth staying.

Feel free to PM me too.

[atwardow]

If you have no connections in the markets you'd like to practice in, transferring to NYU would probably be a better idea. But top 10% + Law Review would go a long ways in OCI.

[Nebby]

NYU

[randomstudent]

For BigLaw outside the Midwest: I'd go with NYU.
For clerking: That's a tougher call. Would you be able to get on law review at NYU?

[Anonymous User]

NYU does a write-on competition for transfers during the fall semester, but I believe there are only one or two spots available.

[Jchance]

want BigLaw: NYU
want clerk: stay

which one do u want more?

[Tanicius]

want BigLaw: NYU
want clerk: stay

which one do u want more?

Why would staying at UMN help get a clerkship?

[Jchance]

Why would staying at UMN help get a clerkship?

given the current number+LR, and assuming the same trend, OP would be competitive for clerkship if staying.
if transferring to NYU, no one knows where OP will rank and there's possibly no LR. Given the death of Clerkship hiring plan, transfers are in a tough spot for rec letters + new grades/ranking while a lot of clerkships (read circuit gigs) start filling up.
UMN for clerking is a clear winner here.

[heavoldgotjuice]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

[johnnyquest]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Hmmmm....not even close to being the same argument.

[ymmv]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Shut up shut up shut up shut up SHUT UP.

[johnnyquest]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Shut up shut up shut up shut up SHUT UP.

+1

[NYSprague]

If you have no connections in the markets you'd like to practice in, transferring to NYU would probably be a better idea. But top 10% + Law Review would go a long ways in OCI.

Please go to NYU if you want big law.

[jbagelboy]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Why do transfer candidates say the most retarded stuff? Minnesota is not your SoFla shithole, fyi.

This decision comes down to whether or not you want to work in Minneapolis/St Paul. If so, the clear answer is to stay: $12k/yr + in-state tuition and very low CoL will still save you a ton of money over sticker living in manhattan. Moreover, local firms won't even show up to NYU OCI so all your networking & applications would be targeted to your UMN record anyway.

If you want biglaw anywhere other than Minnesota and its surrounding states, NYU is the clear choice.

[heavoldgotjuice]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Shut up shut up shut up shut up SHUT UP.

+1

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Why do transfer candidates say the most retarded stuff? Minnesota is not your SoFla shithole, fyi.

This decision comes down to whether or not you want to work in Minneapolis/St Paul. If so, the clear answer is to stay: $12k/yr + in-state tuition and very low CoL will still save you a ton of money over sticker living in manhattan. Moreover, local firms won't even show up to NYU OCI so all your networking & applications would be targeted to your UMN record anyway.

If you want biglaw anywhere other than Minnesota and its surrounding states, NYU is the clear choice.

Well obviously you all are in the minority with 1/3 of the votes. If OP wants to live and work in Minnesota, then have at it... but he doesn't, so why would he stay?

[jbagelboy]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Shut up shut up shut up shut up SHUT UP.

+1

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Why do transfer candidates say the most retarded stuff? Minnesota is not your SoFla shithole, fyi.

This decision comes down to whether or not you want to work in Minneapolis/St Paul. If so, the clear answer is to stay: $12k/yr + in-state tuition and very low CoL will still save you a ton of money over sticker living in manhattan. Moreover, local firms won't even show up to NYU OCI so all your networking & applications would be targeted to your UMN record anyway.

If you want biglaw anywhere other than Minnesota and its surrounding states, NYU is the clear choice.

Well obviously you all are in the minority with 1/3 of the votes. If OP wants to live and work in Minnesota, then have at it... but he doesn't, so why would he stay?

That's exactly what I said.

[heavoldgotjuice]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Shut up shut up shut up shut up SHUT UP.

and fuck you, you never add substance either but always have you head up your ass.

[ymmv]

why is this a thread?


would you attend the university of puerto rico school of law over yale?

Shut up shut up shut up shut up SHUT UP.

and fuck you, you never add substance either but always have you head up your ass.

At some point I guess I realized my time could be better spent than in writing substantive rebuttals to your dumb shit.