fewer LR notes than spots available Forum

[Anonymous User]

theoretically speaking there should be 15 spots for student notes in our school's LR every year. that's what our LR administrator told us too. but due to some obscure reason only about 12-13 notes ended up appearing in this year and last year's LRs.


why so? are there so few good ones sto fill the spots? even among the top-achievers?



what about your school?

[CanadianWolf]

Sometimes there is a very poor match of editor & a particular writer resulting in a non-published work product.

[Anonymous User]

what do you mean by poor match?
you mean 3L editor and 2L writer?

[CanadianWolf]

Yes.

[Anonymous User]

but it is hard to imagine not being able to pick 15 notes from, say, 35 notes by top achievers.

[CanadianWolf]

Not every article researched, written & edited is publishable even though the topic is current.
Law professors have been known to "shop" around for a law review or law journal willing to publish their work.
Maybe your law review has high standards.
P.S. Just be very careful about citing law review articles in a trial court; best to do this only when the trial judge authored the article.

[Anonymous User]

what makes a note, otherwise well researched, edited ... etc ... still unpublishable?

[CanadianWolf]

Maybe the executive editor didn't agree that the article was done well.
Even J.K. Rowling had her manuscript rejected by many publishers before getting a contract.
Without knowing specifics it is too difficult to guess at all the reasons only 40% of the finished articles were published by a particular law review. Law review politics, disagreement among editors over the author's conclusions, etc.

[Anonymous Loser]

what makes a note, otherwise well researched, edited ... etc ... still unpublishable?

If the note's claim has been preempted by another recent publication(s), then it is unlikely to be published.

[Anonymous User]

but a note does not have to be pre-empted unless another article makes exactly the same claim.

as for court rulings, the note should not be pre-empted, unless it was a supreme court decision.

[270910]

Pretty big difference between publishable note and note that will be published. A lot of people put in the work to get over the first bar and fulfill the requirement of the journal without trying to go for the substantially more difficult task of fulfilling the second hurdle.

[YCrevolution]

..