NYU EIW Madness 2014 Forum

[Anonymous User]

Just got a Milbank email (JH) as well. Good luck, everybody!

[Anonymous User]

Olshan Frome - Ding (JH)
Schulte - Ding (GS)

[Anonymous User]

CB:
Fried Frank NY - BR
Chadbourne NY - MS
Clifford Chance NY - GB (no clue how this happened, thought we were both bored out of our minds)
Milbank NY - MM

Dings:
Cooley PA - CD (This fool rick rolled me. As I was walking out of the suite he said "you're just the type of candidate we recruit for. You'll be hearing from us very soon")

You weren't the only one - what the hell, Cooley interviewer offered me a callback on the spot then recruiting e-mail dings me. I'd be more pissed if I thought I'd actually go there, but I'm still kinda irked that they'd be that unprofessional.

Orig Anon ... Did you get your ding today? It was weird because the ding went to my personal email, not my school email listed on my resume. Not sure how they got my personal email.

[Anonymous User]

CB:
Fried Frank NY - BR
Chadbourne NY - MS
Clifford Chance NY - GB (no clue how this happened, thought we were both bored out of our minds)
Milbank NY - MM

Dings:
Cooley PA - CD (This fool rick rolled me. As I was walking out of the suite he said "you're just the type of candidate we recruit for. You'll be hearing from us very soon")

You weren't the only one - what the hell, Cooley interviewer offered me a callback on the spot then recruiting e-mail dings me. I'd be more pissed if I thought I'd actually go there, but I'm still kinda irked that they'd be that unprofessional.

Orig Anon ... Did you get your ding today? It was weird because the ding went to my personal email, not my school email listed on my resume. Not sure how they got my personal email.

did you use your personal email to register for symplicity?

[Anonymous User]

CB:
Fried Frank NY - BR
Chadbourne NY - MS
Clifford Chance NY - GB (no clue how this happened, thought we were both bored out of our minds)
Milbank NY - MM

Dings:
Cooley PA - CD (This fool rick rolled me. As I was walking out of the suite he said "you're just the type of candidate we recruit for. You'll be hearing from us very soon")

You weren't the only one - what the hell, Cooley interviewer offered me a callback on the spot then recruiting e-mail dings me. I'd be more pissed if I thought I'd actually go there, but I'm still kinda irked that they'd be that unprofessional.

Orig Anon ... Did you get your ding today? It was weird because the ding went to my personal email, not my school email listed on my resume. Not sure how they got my personal email.

did you use your personal email to register for symplicity?

I don't recall, but yeah probably.

[beautyistruth]

You weren't the only one - what the hell, Cooley interviewer offered me a callback on the spot then recruiting e-mail dings me. I'd be more pissed if I thought I'd actually go there, but I'm still kinda irked that they'd be that unprofessional.

Any chance it might be a genuine recruiting mistake, such as your name getting mixed into the wrong list? I imagine they send out a batch of emails at once and I could see it maybe being an error.

Anybody know if there's any way OP could tactfully contact the interviewer to confirm whether that ding was supposed to happen?

[Anonymous User]

Anyone hear from LA?

Specifically: Paul Hastings, Manatt, Sheppard Mullin (Downtown), Pillsbury, Milbank, Winston?

I heard someone got Milbank LA

[Anonymous User]

Anyone hear from Cadwalader NYC (TF)?

[Anonymous User]

Anyone hear from Cadwalader NYC (TF)?

Cadwalader (TF) callback ten minutes ago.

[Anonymous User]

You weren't the only one - what the hell, Cooley interviewer offered me a callback on the spot then recruiting e-mail dings me. I'd be more pissed if I thought I'd actually go there, but I'm still kinda irked that they'd be that unprofessional.

Any chance it might be a genuine recruiting mistake, such as your name getting mixed into the wrong list? I imagine they send out a batch of emails at once and I could see it maybe being an error.

Anybody know if there's any way OP could tactfully contact the interviewer to confirm whether that ding was supposed to happen?

OP here - thanks for the thoughts. I've been trying to figure out a tactful way to do this... I really can't imagine what went wrong and where. My grades are definitely high enough for them, and unless the interviewer was saying one thing and writing down another thing it seemed like the interview went by with flying colors and he literally said i am going to tell recruiting to schedule a callback with you. But I have no idea how to bring these things up to recruiting without seeming arrogant / argumentative about them rejecting me.

[Anonymous User]

You weren't the only one - what the hell, Cooley interviewer offered me a callback on the spot then recruiting e-mail dings me. I'd be more pissed if I thought I'd actually go there, but I'm still kinda irked that they'd be that unprofessional.

Any chance it might be a genuine recruiting mistake, such as your name getting mixed into the wrong list? I imagine they send out a batch of emails at once and I could see it maybe being an error.

Anybody know if there's any way OP could tactfully contact the interviewer to confirm whether that ding was supposed to happen?

OP here - thanks for the thoughts. I've been trying to figure out a tactful way to do this... I really can't imagine what went wrong and where. My grades are definitely high enough for them, and unless the interviewer was saying one thing and writing down another thing it seemed like the interview went by with flying colors and he literally said i am going to tell recruiting to schedule a callback with you. But I have no idea how to bring these things up to recruiting without seeming arrogant / argumentative about them rejecting me.

Maybe you can ask Irene?

[Anonymous User]

Wachtell ding (DS). At least this one doesn't hurt since I knew there was no conceivable way they would ever hire me, haha.

[Anonymous User]

3L Weil CB (HC)

[Anonymous User]

Debevoise ding AP

[Anonymous User]

Anyone hear from Cadwalader NYC (TF)?

Cadwalader (TF) callback ten minutes ago.

Hope he's not done for the day...

[Anonymous User]

WilmerHale NY ding (DC) just now.

[Anonymous User]

Have people been dinged from Cleary NY (BO), S&C NY (JF), or Debevoise (MCT)? Trying to figure out if I am in the maybe pile, or if I have already been dinged and just don't know it yet. You would think all the dings from all the different interviewers would come out at once, right?

[Anonymous User]

Have people been dinged from Cleary NY (BO), S&C NY (JF), or Debevoise (MCT)? Trying to figure out if I am in the maybe pile, or if I have already been dinged and just don't know it yet. You would think all the dings from all the different interviewers would come out at once, right?

Well just a couple data points: I was dinged at other firms at different times than people with different interviewers.

[Anonymous User]

Have people been dinged from Cleary NY (BO), S&C NY (JF), or Debevoise (MCT)? Trying to figure out if I am in the maybe pile, or if I have already been dinged and just don't know it yet. You would think all the dings from all the different interviewers would come out at once, right?

Well just a couple data points: I was dinged at other firms at different times than people with different interviewers.

Thanks, that's really helpful to know.

[Anonymous User]

You weren't the only one - what the hell, Cooley interviewer offered me a callback on the spot then recruiting e-mail dings me. I'd be more pissed if I thought I'd actually go there, but I'm still kinda irked that they'd be that unprofessional.

Any chance it might be a genuine recruiting mistake, such as your name getting mixed into the wrong list? I imagine they send out a batch of emails at once and I could see it maybe being an error.

Anybody know if there's any way OP could tactfully contact the interviewer to confirm whether that ding was supposed to happen?

OP here - thanks for the thoughts. I've been trying to figure out a tactful way to do this... I really can't imagine what went wrong and where. My grades are definitely high enough for them, and unless the interviewer was saying one thing and writing down another thing it seemed like the interview went by with flying colors and he literally said i am going to tell recruiting to schedule a callback with you. But I have no idea how to bring these things up to recruiting without seeming arrogant / argumentative about them rejecting me.

I don't know what the exact wording of what the recruiter said to you was. That being said once or twice when I have been offered a callback at the end of the screener by a recruiter it has often been something along the lines of "I will recommend you are give a callback but to needs to be confirmed by the recruiting/hiring committee." At the end of the day the interviewer isn't the only one deciding or even making the final decision. And a lot of silly things can come into play in those decisions. Unfortunately even if an interviewer goes to bat for you they might be overruled. However, I do agree that the recruiter probably shouldn't tell you like a call back is a done deal.

[Anonymous User]

McDermott Will & Emery ding (GK)

[Anonymous User]

Anyone hear anything from Mayer?

[Anonymous User]

Has anybody gotten an email ding from Proskauer Rose, or does it seem like they're going for snail mail?

[Anonymous User]

Any Cadwalader CBs from BF/RA?

[Anonymous User]

Has anybody gotten an email ding from Proskauer Rose, or does it seem like they're going for snail mail?

Expecting a ding since other people have received CBs from my interviewer. Guessing it's snail mail since I haven't received an email yet. That, or they're just slow sending out the email dings.