UVA, UMich, or Northwestern? Forum
- tea_drinker
- Posts: 781
- Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 11:44 am
UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Happy Wednesday everyone,
The subject kinda says it all. Because these three schools are somewhat similar in terms of ranking, I want to know which school you would attend if admitted to all three? Given the same amount of $.
The subject kinda says it all. Because these three schools are somewhat similar in terms of ranking, I want to know which school you would attend if admitted to all three? Given the same amount of $.
- flyingpanda
- Posts: 824
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:32 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Need more info. Where do you want to work? What kind of evironment would you like to go to school in? What type of personality do you have? How old are you... etc....tbldc2009 wrote:Happy Wednesday everyone,
The subject kinda says it all. Because these three schools are somewhat similar in terms of ranking, I want to know which school you would attend if admitted to all three? Given the same amount of $.
- BruceWayne
- Posts: 2034
- Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 9:36 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Want to work in Chicago? NU
Want to work in Chicago or possibly California? Michigan
Want to work in DC or the South? UVA
Want to work in NYC but like the cold? Michigan
Want to work in NYC but don't like the cold? UVA
Want to work in Chicago or possibly California? Michigan
Want to work in DC or the South? UVA
Want to work in NYC but like the cold? Michigan
Want to work in NYC but don't like the cold? UVA
-
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2008 6:41 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
I disagree with the above poster - if you want to work in DC, I'd say go to Michigan or Northwestern - you'd be competing against fewer classmates. Tons of UVA students want to go to DC, and if you've been reading their OCI threads on this site, seems like it was super tough last yr (even with the economy, it seemed more so for them since there were so many going for one city).
As for the other cities the poster listed, for similar reasons of trying to have less classmates to compete against - I'd say:
Chicago - Michigan or UVA
CA - Michigan
South - UVA
NYC - any of the 3 schools
To be upfront - I go to Michigan. Still, the great thing about Michigan is, is that since it really isn't tied to one big city, the students spread all over, so you never have the feeling that you're competing against a majority of your classmates.
As for the other cities the poster listed, for similar reasons of trying to have less classmates to compete against - I'd say:
Chicago - Michigan or UVA
CA - Michigan
South - UVA
NYC - any of the 3 schools
To be upfront - I go to Michigan. Still, the great thing about Michigan is, is that since it really isn't tied to one big city, the students spread all over, so you never have the feeling that you're competing against a majority of your classmates.
Last edited by tingles on Wed Sep 08, 2010 11:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- rayiner
- Posts: 6145
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2008 11:43 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
If you want to work in Chicago -> You don't want to work in Chicago, there are no jobs here.
If you want to work anywhere else -> UVA.
How good is your work experience?
If you want to work anywhere else -> UVA.
How good is your work experience?
Want to continue reading?
Register now to search topics and post comments!
Absolutely FREE!
Already a member? Login
- tea_drinker
- Posts: 781
- Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 11:44 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
I grew up in a small city, but spent most of my adult life (including undergrad) in big city. So, either environment is okay with me. I would love to know what people think of these schools in terms of academic reputation and career opportunity.
- tea_drinker
- Posts: 781
- Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 11:44 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
I have 3+ year of work experience. But how does it relate to which law school I want to attend?rayiner wrote:If you want to work in Chicago -> You don't want to work in Chicago, there are no jobs here.
If you want to work anywhere else -> UVA.
How good is your work experience?
- rayiner
- Posts: 6145
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2008 11:43 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Just that come OCI you don't want to be in the minority of people at NU without solid WE. Preferably something professional.tbldc2009 wrote:I have 3+ year of work experience. But how does it relate to which law school I want to attend?rayiner wrote:If you want to work in Chicago -> You don't want to work in Chicago, there are no jobs here.
If you want to work anywhere else -> UVA.
How good is your work experience?
- BruceWayne
- Posts: 2034
- Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 9:36 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
I'm not sure what you mean by academic reputation. In terms of reputation in the legal community, Michigan and UVA have the edge. It's not a blowout or anything but they do have the edge.tbldc2009 wrote:I grew up in a small city, but spent most of my adult life (including undergrad) in big city. So, either environment is okay with me. I would love to know what people think of these schools in terms of academic reputation and career opportunity.
- sundance95
- Posts: 2123
- Joined: Wed Jun 09, 2010 7:44 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Full disclosure: I'll be attending UVA this fall.
I'd say either Michigan or UVA. The cost of living in Charlottesville or Ann Arbor is far less than downtown Chicago, meaning you'll have less overall debt to deal with, even assuming your tuition is the same at all three schools. (I think this is what you meant when you said, "Given the same amount of $.")
As far as markets, if you want Chicago, Michigan can certainly take you there, as well as the other major markets. UVA can get you to DC, NY, or to a lesser extent, the West Coast. Both of these schools outperform Northwestern in clerkship placement, if that is a path you are interested in.
Really though, these schools are so different culturally that you should be able to find some preference. Do you prefer urban settings? Then NU is for you. The South? UVA. If you can't decide then visit-I certainly found them all to be very different and it helped my decision process.
FWIW, Bruce Wayne is correct; Michigan and UVA are generally regarded as within a higher 'subtier' of the T14 than NU.
I'd say either Michigan or UVA. The cost of living in Charlottesville or Ann Arbor is far less than downtown Chicago, meaning you'll have less overall debt to deal with, even assuming your tuition is the same at all three schools. (I think this is what you meant when you said, "Given the same amount of $.")
As far as markets, if you want Chicago, Michigan can certainly take you there, as well as the other major markets. UVA can get you to DC, NY, or to a lesser extent, the West Coast. Both of these schools outperform Northwestern in clerkship placement, if that is a path you are interested in.
Really though, these schools are so different culturally that you should be able to find some preference. Do you prefer urban settings? Then NU is for you. The South? UVA. If you can't decide then visit-I certainly found them all to be very different and it helped my decision process.
FWIW, Bruce Wayne is correct; Michigan and UVA are generally regarded as within a higher 'subtier' of the T14 than NU.
-
- Posts: 2577
- Joined: Thu May 06, 2010 10:56 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
So first off ill say that i will be going to UVA next year.
What are your numbers? Are you sure you will get into all 3? Do you have work experience? Or is this one of those "i think ill get into all 3 so i want to decide now?"
I mean with good enough numbers to be sure why not wait to see what kind of scholarships you get.
If you get none then go where you feel you will be happiest. I went with Virginia because of the QOL and hating chicago. If you had your choice your in a very good spot because all 3 have great job prospects.
Can anyone say that any one has much better job prospects then the other? I have heard great things about northwestern because everyone has prior work experience so their resume is boosted already when looking for a job. If you hAvent been out of school for 2 or more years i would cut out northwestern as you probably wouldnt fit in as well.
This is all just my biased 2 cents of course
What are your numbers? Are you sure you will get into all 3? Do you have work experience? Or is this one of those "i think ill get into all 3 so i want to decide now?"
I mean with good enough numbers to be sure why not wait to see what kind of scholarships you get.
If you get none then go where you feel you will be happiest. I went with Virginia because of the QOL and hating chicago. If you had your choice your in a very good spot because all 3 have great job prospects.
Can anyone say that any one has much better job prospects then the other? I have heard great things about northwestern because everyone has prior work experience so their resume is boosted already when looking for a job. If you hAvent been out of school for 2 or more years i would cut out northwestern as you probably wouldnt fit in as well.
This is all just my biased 2 cents of course
- PDaddy
- Posts: 2063
- Joined: Sat Jan 16, 2010 4:40 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
UVA and UMich are located in college towns, whereas NU is an urban school. All three have great career prospects, but, for corporate law I would choose NU - if only by a smidge. If you want a clerkship, the other two might be better, although it is possible to get one from NU. I haven't really researched the clerkship issues. If you want to work in NY or on the east coast, pick UVA. If you want to go west or midwest, pick NU or UMich. If you want to go south, go to UVA or pull a name out of a hat. It is true that NU is biased towards candidates with work experience, but that doesn't mean you can't get in if you don't have it. Remember Suff v. Nec conditions? At NU, W.E. is a Sufficient condition for having a good shot at admission, not a Necessary one. My personal preference would be NU, but that's my preference. Do you...tbldc2009 wrote:Happy Wednesday everyone,
The subject kinda says it all. Because these three schools are somewhat similar in terms of ranking, I want to know which school you would attend if admitted to all three? Given the same amount of $.
Last edited by PDaddy on Wed Sep 08, 2010 11:52 pm, edited 3 times in total.
-
- Posts: 11453
- Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 4:54 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Northwestern because of its location & #1 National Law Journal placement ranking for the top 250 law firms in the country. Otherwise Michigan if you prefer cold weather, Virginia if you prefer warmer weather. All three are equal academically but offer different school cultures & settings.
Although NU is referred to as an urban school, it also has one of the most beautiful & upscale settings in the nation. The library looks out over Lake Michigan & the most upscale dining & shopping in Chicago is within walking distance. But, if you prefer a college town & campus setting, then Michigan & Virginia are better options.
Although NU is referred to as an urban school, it also has one of the most beautiful & upscale settings in the nation. The library looks out over Lake Michigan & the most upscale dining & shopping in Chicago is within walking distance. But, if you prefer a college town & campus setting, then Michigan & Virginia are better options.
Register now!
Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.
It's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
- tea_drinker
- Posts: 781
- Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 11:44 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Good point.Just that come OCI you don't want to be in the minority of people at NU without solid WE. Preferably something professional.
Definitely not. I will be extremely happy to get into one of these fine schools.Or is this one of those "i think ill get into all 3 so i want to decide now?"
Good analogy!Remember Suff v. Nec conditions? At NU, W.E. is a Sufficient condition for having a good shot at admission, not a Necessary one.
- Mickey Quicknumbers
- Posts: 2168
- Joined: Tue Apr 28, 2009 1:22 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
What do you like more:
Softball
Building asthetics
or the cast of BP
Softball
Building asthetics
or the cast of BP
-
- Posts: 11453
- Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 4:54 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Northwestern places a very high value on work experience after graduating college. Not certain, but I recall reading that last year's entering class had about 94% with work experience, while the remaining 6% directly from college were rumored to have very high numbers.
As you may have read, Northwestern's well known law dean resigned to become a university president in New York City. Not sure if the emphasis will change. NU law students can take graduate business courses at the Kellogg School which is currently the third or fourth top MBA school in USNews.
Northwestern law students tend to be about 2 years older than the other two law schools. NU's law school is located near the medical school so the atmosphere is different than being on an undergraduate campus.
As you may have read, Northwestern's well known law dean resigned to become a university president in New York City. Not sure if the emphasis will change. NU law students can take graduate business courses at the Kellogg School which is currently the third or fourth top MBA school in USNews.
Northwestern law students tend to be about 2 years older than the other two law schools. NU's law school is located near the medical school so the atmosphere is different than being on an undergraduate campus.
- RVP11
- Posts: 2774
- Joined: Tue Nov 06, 2007 6:32 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
Please don't listen to 0L/1Ls and this "if you want DC, go to UVA, if you want California, go to Michigan, etc." business.
What matters when it comes to OCI are A) your grades and B) your connection to the market. Firms in DC aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into UVA than they are into Michigan or NU, Chicago firms aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into NU or Michigan than they are into UVA.
UVA is not a great place to go if you want to practice at a big firm in DC, unless you can somehow guarantee that you will both be in the top 25% of the class and a good interviewer at OGI and at least a little bit lucky.
Good grades plus decent interviewing can probably get you NYC BigLaw from any of these schools.
And you're not going to have much success in California coming from ANY of the above schools if you don't have a legitimate California (or at least west coast) tie.
The point is this decision should not be significantly influenced by the regional placement strength of these schools as perceived by people who are year(s) away from even interviewing. Seriously - how much you like/dislike the cold, like/dislike softball, or like/dislike living in a major city, are all MUCH more important in the decision among NU/UM/UVA than whatever hairs you can split when it comes to job placement.
What matters when it comes to OCI are A) your grades and B) your connection to the market. Firms in DC aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into UVA than they are into Michigan or NU, Chicago firms aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into NU or Michigan than they are into UVA.
UVA is not a great place to go if you want to practice at a big firm in DC, unless you can somehow guarantee that you will both be in the top 25% of the class and a good interviewer at OGI and at least a little bit lucky.
Good grades plus decent interviewing can probably get you NYC BigLaw from any of these schools.
And you're not going to have much success in California coming from ANY of the above schools if you don't have a legitimate California (or at least west coast) tie.
The point is this decision should not be significantly influenced by the regional placement strength of these schools as perceived by people who are year(s) away from even interviewing. Seriously - how much you like/dislike the cold, like/dislike softball, or like/dislike living in a major city, are all MUCH more important in the decision among NU/UM/UVA than whatever hairs you can split when it comes to job placement.
Last edited by RVP11 on Thu Sep 09, 2010 12:25 am, edited 1 time in total.
Get unlimited access to all forums and topics
Register now!
I'm pretty sure I told you it's FREE...
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 240
- Joined: Tue Jul 15, 2008 2:12 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
what do you mean by west coast tie? some ppl say that having family there is enough...true?RVP11 wrote:Please don't listen to 0L/1Ls and this "if you want DC, go to UVA, if you want California, go to Michigan, etc." business.
What matters when it comes to OCI are A) your grades and B) your connection to the market. Firms in DC aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into UVA than they are into Michigan or NU, Chicago firms aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into NU or Michigan than they are into UVA. And you're not going to have much success in California coming from ANY of the above schools if you don't have a legitimate California (or at least west coast) tie. UVA is not a great place to go if you want to practice at a big firm in DC, unless you can somehow guarantee that you will both be in the top 25% of the class and a good interviewer at OGI and at least a little bit lucky. Good grades plus decent interviewing can probably get you NYC BigLaw from any of these schools.
The point is this decision should not be significantly influenced by the regional placement strength of these schools as perceived by people who are year(s) away from even interviewing.
also-i guess if i threw penn into the mix you would categorize it as the same?-grades/connection to market
- RVP11
- Posts: 2774
- Joined: Tue Nov 06, 2007 6:32 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
"Having family there" - that would depend on the family. Cousin? No. Brother/sister? Probably not. Parents or significant other? Now we're talking, but still not as good as having grown up there.silly101 wrote:what do you mean by west coast tie? some ppl say that having family there is enough...true?RVP11 wrote:Please don't listen to 0L/1Ls and this "if you want DC, go to UVA, if you want California, go to Michigan, etc." business.
What matters when it comes to OCI are A) your grades and B) your connection to the market. Firms in DC aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into UVA than they are into Michigan or NU, Chicago firms aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into NU or Michigan than they are into UVA. And you're not going to have much success in California coming from ANY of the above schools if you don't have a legitimate California (or at least west coast) tie. UVA is not a great place to go if you want to practice at a big firm in DC, unless you can somehow guarantee that you will both be in the top 25% of the class and a good interviewer at OGI and at least a little bit lucky. Good grades plus decent interviewing can probably get you NYC BigLaw from any of these schools.
The point is this decision should not be significantly influenced by the regional placement strength of these schools as perceived by people who are year(s) away from even interviewing.
also-i guess if i threw penn into the mix you would categorize it as the same?-grades/connection to market
And yes, Penn would be in the same category.
- ArchRoark
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 2:53 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
As a clueless 0L, why do firms care about your connections to a market?RVP11 wrote:
"Having family there" - that would depend on the family. Cousin? No. Brother/sister? Probably not. Parents or significant other? Now we're talking, but still not as good as having grown up there.
And yes, Penn would be in the same category.
-
- Posts: 240
- Joined: Tue Jul 15, 2008 2:12 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
okay yeah i grew up in cali and am going to undergrad here as wellRVP11 wrote:"Having family there" - that would depend on the family. Cousin? No. Brother/sister? Probably not. Parents or significant other? Now we're talking, but still not as good as having grown up there.silly101 wrote:what do you mean by west coast tie? some ppl say that having family there is enough...true?RVP11 wrote:Please don't listen to 0L/1Ls and this "if you want DC, go to UVA, if you want California, go to Michigan, etc." business.
What matters when it comes to OCI are A) your grades and B) your connection to the market. Firms in DC aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into UVA than they are into Michigan or NU, Chicago firms aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into NU or Michigan than they are into UVA. And you're not going to have much success in California coming from ANY of the above schools if you don't have a legitimate California (or at least west coast) tie. UVA is not a great place to go if you want to practice at a big firm in DC, unless you can somehow guarantee that you will both be in the top 25% of the class and a good interviewer at OGI and at least a little bit lucky. Good grades plus decent interviewing can probably get you NYC BigLaw from any of these schools.
The point is this decision should not be significantly influenced by the regional placement strength of these schools as perceived by people who are year(s) away from even interviewing.
also-i guess if i threw penn into the mix you would categorize it as the same?-grades/connection to market
And yes, Penn would be in the same category.
Communicate now with those who not only know what a legal education is, but can offer you worthy advice and commentary as you complete the three most educational, yet challenging years of your law related post graduate life.
Register now, it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
- im_blue
- Posts: 3272
- Joined: Sun Apr 12, 2009 3:53 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
to make sure you like living in the area, need or want to stay for a long time, and won't leave for greener pastures elsewhereTiva wrote:As a clueless 0L, why do firms care about your connections to a market?RVP11 wrote:
"Having family there" - that would depend on the family. Cousin? No. Brother/sister? Probably not. Parents or significant other? Now we're talking, but still not as good as having grown up there.
And yes, Penn would be in the same category.
- BruceWayne
- Posts: 2034
- Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 9:36 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
RVP11 wrote:Please don't listen to 0L/1Ls and this "if you want DC, go to UVA, if you want California, go to Michigan, etc." business.
What matters when it comes to OCI are A) your grades and B) your connection to the market. Firms in DC aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into UVA than they are into Michigan or NU, Chicago firms aren't digging significantly deeper (if at all) into NU or Michigan than they are into UVA.
UVA is not a great place to go if you want to practice at a big firm in DC, unless you can somehow guarantee that you will both be in the top 25% of the class and a good interviewer at OGI and at least a little bit lucky.
Good grades plus decent interviewing can probably get you NYC BigLaw from any of these schools.
And you're not going to have much success in California coming from ANY of the above schools if you don't have a legitimate California (or at least west coast) tie.
The point is this decision should not be significantly influenced by the regional placement strength of these schools as perceived by people who are year(s) away from even interviewing. Seriously - how much you like/dislike the cold, like/dislike softball, or like/dislike living in a major city, are all MUCH more important in the decision among NU/UM/UVA than whatever hairs you can split when it comes to job placement.
If by the bolded you mean "not the best law school in the entire nation for DC" then yes. But unless you've been accepted to HYS or arguably CC UVA is about as good as it's going to get. It's not like going to Michigan or NU will give you a better shot. Numerous 3L's have told me (who've gone through OGI and cemented where they are going to work upon graduation) that although DC is tough, our alumni base there is very strong and definitely helps us. It's no different than NYU having a strong alumni base in NYC and that helping them, or Berkeley's alumni base in San Francisco helping them.
The other thing to take into account is that a lot more DC firms come to UVA's OGI than they do to NU or Michigan's OCI. That's not the end all be all but it certainly helps if the firm is coming right to your campus to interview.
- rayiner
- Posts: 6145
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2008 11:43 am
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
I've heard its very difficult to get interview slots for DC at UVA. I picked up the prominent DC office of a national firm with a #21 ranked bid at NU. I picked up another prominent DC firm with a 30s ranked bid off the waitlist.BruceWayne wrote:If by the bolded you mean "not the best law school in the entire nation for DC" then yes. But unless you've been accepted to HYS or arguably CC UVA is about as good as it's going to get. It's not like going to Michigan or NU will give you a better shot.
- Grizz
- Posts: 10564
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2010 6:31 pm
Re: UVA, UMich, or Northwestern?
See if you get into these school. Then make this post again.
Seriously? What are you waiting for?
Now there's a charge.
Just kidding ... it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login