Agreed. But let's criticize his reasoning. I honestly don't think it's all that different from people wanting to go to lower ranked schools for family/personal reasons. Is his reason legitimate? I don't think that's up for anyone in this thread to decide. All OP asked was whether admission to Pepperdine was likely. And yes, the applicant in your scenario would be a bit ridiculous, but I think you are still being a tad facetious as well as continuing to interject your personal opinion into the discussion. Objectivity is the goal here.Case2L wrote:Fair enough, and maybe I went about it the wrong way. However, I don't think the OP's reason for attending an inferior school in relation to his LSAT should be immune from criticism simply because it's a religious belief. If the OP said he wanted to attend the Univ. of New Mexico because it is closer to Roswell, and that would please his alien masters, and he was 100% sincere in his belief, people would jump all over him and/or assume he is insane. But when he insists his reasons are because of a personal god, which is no more believable than aliens, he gets a free pass. I'm not the first TLS'er to criticize a stupid decision on where to attend law school. I've seen criticisms on this board that are far more virulent than anything I've said in this thread.cartercl wrote:My initial response simply implied that it was wrong of you to criticize OP's beliefs.
I think it's a bit more understandable for one to attend law school based on religious beliefs that a large number of Americans share, than one as ridiculous as wanting to be close to E.T. Yeah, that guy would be a total idiot. It may not be believable to you, but it's clearly a view that is believable enough to have survived for thousands of years and still have followers in droves.