Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft Forum

(Personal Statement Examples, Advice, Critique, . . . )
Post Reply
BManCal90

New
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 8:13 pm

Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by BManCal90 » Sun Aug 03, 2014 2:28 pm

Hi all, could I please get some tips on my personal statement? I've read quite a few examples online and am not sure if I should include more info about my desire to attend law school. Any tips would be appreciated. Thanks so much! :)


Walls can serve a number of purposes: they can provide protection and security, they can delineate and divide, or they can offer privacy and seclusion. Yet when one is taught to build their walls from a young age, they can serve as monuments to isolation and exile. Iranian-American writer and journalist Hooman Majd has said, “For millennia, Iranians have built tall walls around their houses to keep the private and public separate. Iranians are known to have a public face and a private face, a public life and a private life....[it is] understood that the walls, literal and figurative...mustn’t be breached.” As a member of the Iranian-American LGBT community, my walls symbolized a lie.

One’s sexual orientation is an odd trait that is inherently both public and private. Understanding this can be a struggle for many. For me, it was a paradox that I had to confront. I had to combat the ignorance in an otherwise rich and educated culture. My own challenges have inspired me to do all that I can to support others in my community who face their own social barriers.

As a Washington, D.C. intern during my junior year of college, I conducted research for the ______ Group, a firm that provides policy development consulting for a number of clients, including non-governmental organizations. One client that was particularly striking was the International Gay & Lesbian Human Rights Commission (IGLHRC). They were seeking to develop a strategy to combat hostile attitudes towards LGBT individuals in Iran by increasing awareness of those communities. We concluded that the best means of achieving this was to promote a discussion among the diaspora in the United States. This first step, for our culture, would be to dismantle the walls that separated so many people--a task that I enthusiastically accepted.

Upon returning to Southern California, I decided to apply what I had learned in Washington to my student organization: the Iranian Student ____ (____) at ______. My executive role allowed me to promote activist causes. Teaming up with Queer Alliance and our cultural counterparts at ____, we hosted an event that was heavily attended by our community. The Hidden: a Discussion of the Queer Iranian Narrative sought to shed light, through personal accounts, on the adversities faced by queer Iranians both in the United States and Iran. My organization also welcomed the Deputy Director of the Iran Office at the U.S Consulate in Dubai. At our event, she discussed the new visa restrictions for Iranians coming to the U.S., as well as information for asylum seekers. Finally, at annual cultural events, I pushed for greater themes of tolerance and acceptance--topics well received by the community.

My post-graduation move to D.C. was strategic. It allowed me the opportunity to further cultivate my knowledge with access to countless lectures, seminars, debates, and discussions. As an analyst at ___________, my primary task has been to conduct research on behalf of Fannie Mae; examining aspects of economic inequality--specifically the barriers to homeownership for minorities and low income individuals. I have also used this opportunity to connect with and learn from a diverse group of people while still facilitating my goals of bridging the LGBT and Iranian-American communities. One friend I connected with in Washington is a journalist writing about the Iranian-American experience, whose crowdfunded project I circulated through my network. After urging her to devote a portion of it to the struggles of sexual minorities, she asked for my help in contributing to it.

While walls can embody separation, mine--or rather the tearing down of mine--signify my victory over the prevailing sentiments of my community. My liberation has additionally provided me with the empathy for the socially marginalized and those less fortunate. I learned that, though adversities can be overcome alone, they are much more tolerable with support. I know my work is not complete. I have therefore concluded that the most effective path for me to continue my efforts to destroy the walls that segregate our society, would be a law school education. I believe that my unique experiences and intellectual drive prove that I will be an exceptional contribution to _____’s community.

HRomanus

Silver
Posts: 1307
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2013 8:45 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by HRomanus » Sun Aug 03, 2014 3:52 pm

You're a good writer and the topic is enjoyable. My only critique: to borrow your own language, mind the walls around your writing. It's formal and dispassionate, which is not wholly suitable for a personal statement. While powerful, the metaphor is cliche and weakens the statement. The whole first paragraph should be eliminated in favor of a more personal introduction, perhaps relaying an incident or perspective that sets up the rest of the statement.

BManCal90

New
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 8:13 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by BManCal90 » Tue Aug 05, 2014 9:56 am

Awesome, thank you! So you would recommend abandoning the quote as well as the walls theme?

HRomanus

Silver
Posts: 1307
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2013 8:45 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by HRomanus » Tue Aug 05, 2014 10:20 am

BManCal90 wrote:Awesome, thank you! So you would recommend abandoning the quote as well as the walls theme?
Yes, and I say that while really enjoying the statement. It would be a phenomenal essay in college, but adcomms would rather hear your voice. Save the space - or make it personal by saying how you were studiously taught by lecture and by example that your public life was to be separate from your personal life.

Cradle6

Bronze
Posts: 168
Joined: Sun Jun 01, 2014 10:02 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by Cradle6 » Tue Aug 05, 2014 4:55 pm

I agree to cut the quote. Too impersonal.

Want to continue reading?

Register now to search topics and post comments!

Absolutely FREE!


BManCal90

New
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 8:13 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by BManCal90 » Wed Aug 06, 2014 1:33 pm

Thanks for the tips! I've retooled the first two paragraphs. I bring up more personal inspiration in this draft. Though it's all true, I'm afraid that it will sound a bit melodramatic. I don't want the admissions committee to dismiss it as another statement evoking too much pathos.


From a young age, I always had wondered why there were certain things reserved for the closed doors of our home and other things welcome in public. “No, don’t say that”, “don’t talk about it with them”, “don’t bring that up” were common orders to my family as we prepared to depart for family gatherings. Even during the most trying of circumstances for our household--the Great Recession, business troubles, home foreclosure--we were instructed to conceal these emotions; cover them up and present ourselves as if nothing were wrong. Our culture stresses this separation of our public and private lives, thus a member of the Iranian-American LGBT community, my life would symbolize a lie.

It took me until that one ominous day--the day I was forced to come out--to fully realize the gravity of this public-private division. The concerns I’d heard since a young age were re-tooled: “what if they find out?!”, “what will they think?!”, “how will they treat us?!”. One’s sexual orientation is an odd trait that is inherently both public and private. For me, it was a paradox that I had to confront. I had to combat the ignorance in an otherwise rich and educated culture. It has been these challenges that have inspired me to do all that I can to support others in my community who face their own social barriers.

HRomanus

Silver
Posts: 1307
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2013 8:45 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by HRomanus » Wed Aug 06, 2014 3:27 pm

I really like this opening. However, I would condense the two paragraphs into one and eliminate redundancy.

From a young age, I always had wondered why there were certain things reserved for the closed doors of our home and other things welcome in public. “No, don’t say that”, “don’t talk about it with them”, “don’t bring that up” were common orders to my family as we prepared to depart for family gatherings. The Iranian-American culture stresses a separation of our public and private lives. Coming out as an LGBT in this community strained that dichotomy. The challenges I faced fostered a determination to support others in my community who faced their own social barriers.

BManCal90

New
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 8:13 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by BManCal90 » Mon Aug 11, 2014 11:08 am

Awesome, thank you! I've modified my paper.

I've received feedback from a relative who is a former dean (at a technical institute, not law school) and he gave some recommendations, some of which I'm not sure if they're relevant for a law school PS.

He says:

1. The PS depicts only one dimension. Emphasizing that you are a gay Iranian-American and what you have done to help your community is critically important. You have recognized this. But, you are a multi-faceted person. You should also discuss your other capabilities, skills and experiences.

2. As this document is to be a part of an application for law school, MUCH more needs to be written about how all you have mentioned (and will add to) bear on the fact that you now have decided to study law. Why you think study of law is the best way for you to attain your objectives (by the way, a much more explicit portrayal of what those objectives are would help).
--

What I'm not sure about is that this is a 2 page statement--there is not that much more room to talk about other attributes, right?

Also, after perusing other PS posts, I've gathered that the "why X law" model is not recommended for the PS. Therefore, my uncle's 2nd recommendation would not be helpful.

Ideas?

HRomanus

Silver
Posts: 1307
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2013 8:45 pm

Re: Tips, ideas, etc. on my PS first draft

Post by HRomanus » Mon Aug 11, 2014 12:39 pm

With respect to your friend, don't listen to that. You have to understand your PS as one part of a limited application package. Everything the adcomms know about you are contained in your LSAT score, GPA, resume, personal information (race, sex, location, etc), and personal statement. Because the package is limited, every part needs to fully accomplish its purpose.

The goal of a personal statement is to reveal some positive attributes of your character, with the implicit assumption that they will make you successful in law school and the legal field. You do not need to write why you want to study law. Don't shoehorn it into a narrative or choose "Why Law" over a better narrative.

Your statement isn't (or shouldn't be) about you being a gay Iranian-American. What matters is how circumstances have acted on you and - in particular - what you've done with your circumstances. The real thrust of your statement isn't about being a gay Iranian-American, it's about what you did as a gay Iranian-American (stand up for yourself and proactively help others in similar circumstances). That narrative reveals leadership, determination, empathy, vision, and more. Law schools don't care as much about haing a gay Iranian-American attend their school as they do about having someone with those attributes.

I think your topic and narrative are great. You only have two pages, so stick with one powerful, developed narrative.

Want to continue reading?

Register for access!

Did I mention it was FREE ?


Post Reply

Return to “Law School Personal Statements”