Is this a good start to my ps Forum

[Sesi329]

edit

[thederangedwang]

I changed my introduction up a bit. My first introduction is a few posts down. Is this a better way to catch your attention? or can i not start this way? thank you!

Suddenly, there was, first, a flash. The light came before the sound. It was July 3rd 2005, I had just finished driving three hours away to go to my friend’s cabin in northern Michigan. We were celebrating Independence Day. As soon as I got out of the car my friend rushed me over to some empty fields. He wanted to show me something. It was a 10 pound firework. The largest I had ever seen.

you almost had more punctuation in that sentence than actual words.

[TommyK]

Suddenly, there was, first,a flash. The light came before the sound.

Removing unnecessary punctuation and obviously the flash will arrive before the sound... because y'know... the whole speed of light thing being pretty quick.

It was a 10 pound firework., The the largest I had ever seen.

changing sentence fragment to part of original sentence.

Could be a fine opening. Could be a horrible one. Too hard to tell at this point. So far, my attention isn't really grabbed just because something loud popped. You have to give me a bigger hook than that.

[JoeMo]

Sorry, just no.

[MachineLemon]

Could you give us an idea of where this is heading? Right now, it seems headed toward horrific injury or arrest for possessing illegal fireworks. I hope neither, but your intense intro makes me expect a dramatic outcome. If I am wrong, you may be overselling it.

[CanadianWolf]

Although it's difficult to judge only a small portion of one's PS, this doesn't work because it is not interesting.

[JasonR]

It was July 3rd 2005, I had just finished driving three hours away to go to my friend’s cabin in northern Michigan.

Among the other issues with this intro, you need to fix this comma splice. These are two separate sentences.

Could you give us an idea of where this is heading? Right now, it seems headed toward horrific injury or arrest for possessing illegal fireworks. I hope neither, but your intense intro makes me expect a dramatic outcome. If I am wrong, you may be overselling it.

Horrific injury. See other posts.

[Dany]

It is not.

[Haymarket]

Your, first sentence, sounds like, the acting, of, William, Shatner.

[thelawschoolproject]

Nope.

Try again.

Also, you don't have to begin your PS with some short overly-dramatic sentence for it to be effective.

[062914123]

.

[Sesi329]

Thanks everyone!