Personal Statement Critique Forum

(Personal Statement Examples, Advice, Critique, . . . )
Post Reply
reena83

New
Posts: 2
Joined: Tue Jul 13, 2010 7:11 pm

Personal Statement Critique

Post by reena83 » Sat Jul 24, 2010 4:41 am

Hey there~ if I could get your feedback on this Personal statement for my apps. I'd really appreciate it.. I have two very different statements this and another. Since I can't send both I have to choose :( This is the more creative me side and the other is more logical rational and objective as to what i was to be a lawyer and go to law school

" The constant tap of a foot keeping beat. Nails cut so short that they can no longer grow past the skin that surrounds them. These are all characteristics of a piano player. I have had a love-hate affair with the piano. I had different suitors of course; the classic American baby grand piano, the modern plastic keys of the electronic keyboard and the exotic, fragile harmonium of India. In Indian classical music, the synonymous terms for beat and scale are taal and raaga respectively. Although both have the same notes, the striking difference between a raaga and a typical scale, is that the creator of the raaga has the ability to improvise. One can create a variety of melodies within the same framework and still be considered a scale. Often in my life, I found similarities between me and the music I desperately tried to master. My life has been one ever-evolving raaga, complete with interludes and conscious wavering from the well known tune.
Coming from a family of doctors, the medical profession was synonymous with success and altruism. I was constantly pushed into the field of medicine. Albeit I had an interest in science, a phrase that often reverberated throughout our home was “----”. In chemistry, I felt like the elemental ore being described by the professor. That when extracted from deep caves there is an immediate need to be made into a metal. The forte of my relatives further insinuated that I needed to be purified and polished like a doctor. But more often than not, I think everyone forgets that a metal ore is the natural state of a metal. Besides containing the obvious metal, the ore contains other important elements. Like a metal ore, law encompasses all parts of our lives, our health, well-being and role in the world, not just one specific thing.
I always felt inclined toward law because skills of rhetoric, logic and knowledge are the only things that can help you win any battle, physically and mentally. I felt no need to be changed from who I naturally was; I fought to keep degree ___. I have always been inclined to help others but with a fair hand. Often what I felt was lacking in medicine was that no amount of pills, surgeries and medical research could help improve, protect or measure the human spirit. Of course medicine improves one’s health and well-being but what I craved for was the more permanent laws of society to govern and provide justice to our ever-changing human wills. The human spirit is something to be treasured from the beginning, just like the metal ore in a lake. Society is rankled in broken justice systems, where the guilty are let free and the innocent are behind bars. More often that not, once an innocent is proven guilty, it’s hard for anyone to see that they are better than a piece of scrap metal. In my experiences at a family violence clinic, I found the women there full of spirit but were broken down in a way that not even a doctor can fix. These women needed justice and as a simple volunteer I wanted to do more than provide a warm hug, stamp papers and listen to the disheartening stories of the calamity in their lives, I wanted to act to change it.
Law is not a concrete, well-defined subject at all times. It is highly complex and intertwined leaving one has to constantly evaluate and justify why something is right and wrong. At any moment one’s view can be declared invalid. Like the notes of a raaga, law seems deceivingly concrete, but there are a multiple ways to interpret the notes. There will be times where society will not like the melody you create or defend. Like the three pianos I’ve encountered in my life, law is a career path that I feel fits my personality as close to as how natural my fingers feel touching keys of ivory. Whether the sounds are created by keys attached to the steel strings of an American grand piano, manifested electronically by the creators of the keyboard, or produced by air flowing through an Indian harmonium, the important thing is that these sounds all create music. So in my own raaga, I create my own interpretation of the purpose of life. As an orchestra conductor directs his audience to the right notes, I want to someday fulfill the conducting position of a lawyer, by becoming a musician of law."

CanadianWolf

Diamond
Posts: 11453
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 4:54 pm

Re: Personal Statement Critique

Post by CanadianWolf » Sat Jul 24, 2010 11:08 am

Not likely to help your law school applications. Too much poetic BS, not enough substance. Creates the impression that you are very young and not ready for law school.

User avatar
scott82

Bronze
Posts: 124
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2008 1:26 pm

Re: Personal Statement Critique

Post by scott82 » Sun Jul 25, 2010 10:58 am

My life has been one ever-evolving raaga, complete with interludes and conscious wavering from the well known tune.
I question the value of this metaphor. It's a lot of explanation and comes off like a needlessly complicated way of saying something that is true for pretty much everyone. Everyone evolves.
Coming from a family of doctors, the medical profession was synonymous with success and altruism.
Subject? I know what you meant, but this reads like the medical profession comes from a family of doctors.
Albeit I had an interest in science, a phrase that often reverberated throughout our home was “----”
Incorrect use of "albeit." What was the phrase?
In chemistry, I felt like the elemental ore being described by the professor. That when extracted from deep caves there is an immediate need to be made into a metal.
You felt like you needed to be made into a metal? This simile is forced and unclear. Second sentence is a fragment.
The forte of my relatives further insinuated that I needed to be purified and polished like a doctor.
Yeah, I don't get it. You're really grasping at this elemental ore metaphor and it's not working. "Purified" is not something I'd apply to doctors.
But more often than not, I think everyone forgets that a metal ore is the natural state of a metal.
"More often than not" is a cliche, and I don't think people forget that; they just don't know.
Besides containing the obvious metal, the ore contains other important elements. Like a metal ore, law encompasses all parts of our lives, our health, well-being and role in the world, not just one specific thing.
This is an awful simile. Metal ore does not "encompass all parts of our lives." Neither does law. Both are tangentially related, arguably, but definitely not "encompassing."
I always felt inclined toward law because skills of rhetoric, logic and knowledge are the only things that can help you win any battle, physically and mentally.
Wrong, and foolishly idealistic. A thorough grasp of rhetoric, logic, and knowledge (redundant, btw) does not make you any less likely to get your ass kicked in a fight.
I have always been inclined to help others but with a fair hand. Often what I felt was lacking in medicine was that no amount of pills, surgeries and medical research could help improve, protect or measure the human spirit.
"Help others" is a phrase that should be avoided. And law is probably equally as likely as medicine to "improve, protect or measure the human spirit." And, really, what qualifies you to make this assessment? Do you have a degree in medicine?
Of course medicine improves one’s health and well-being but what I craved for was the more permanent laws of society to govern and provide justice to our ever-changing human wills.
You "craved for laws?" "Justice to our ever-changing human wills?" WTF does that mean?
The human spirit is something to be treasured from the beginning, just like the metal ore in a lake.
Meaningless touchy-feely crap. Remove.
Society is rankled in broken justice systems, where the guilty are let free and the innocent are behind bars.
First, incorrect use of "rankled." Second, this is a ridiculous oversimplification. Third, vague condemnations of society and the justice system are cliche, and potentially insulting to people who have actually worked in the justice system (like those who may be reading your PS).
More often that not, once an innocent is proven guilty, it’s hard for anyone to see that they are better than a piece of scrap metal.
Um, how would an innocent be "proven guilty?" Second, how the hell would you know this is true? Third, why scrap metal? Fourth, there are plenty of people and groups who serve the interests of prisoners, even the ones who are unquestionably guilty. So this statement kind of falls flat.
In my experiences at a family violence clinic,
How does this have anything to do with your preceding rant about the criminal justice system?
I found the women there full of spirit but were broken down in a way that not even a doctor can fix.
Full of spirit but broken? This doesn't make much sense.
These women needed justice
Vague.
as a simple volunteer I wanted to do more than provide a warm hug, stamp papers and listen to the disheartening stories of the calamity in their lives, I wanted to act to change it.
Sounds like a great reason to become a social worker. Don't say you want to "act to change" something if you aren't going to provide any insight into how you are going to effect said change. The "I want to be a lawyer to change things and help people" PS is waaaaay overdone.
Law is not a concrete, well-defined subject at all times. It is highly complex and intertwined leaving one has to constantly evaluate and justify why something is right and wrong. At any moment one’s view can be declared invalid.
Another oversimplification.

And then you suddenly and vaguely revisit the music metaphor. I promise you, adcoms will have seen several hundred PS's screaming "OMG, check out my awesome metaphor for what the law is!!! Super original and insightful, amirite?!"

No, it isn't.

I don't know if your other PS is any good, but it's probably better than this.

Post Reply

Return to “Law School Personal Statements”