Take a look and have a swing (3rd and don't be shy!) Forum

(Personal Statement Examples, Advice, Critique, . . . )
Post Reply
User avatar
lawrencecis

New
Posts: 48
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 3:42 am

Take a look and have a swing (3rd and don't be shy!)

Post by lawrencecis » Wed Jul 14, 2010 10:58 pm

I am particularly worried about discussing the arrest. Don't hold back. All criticism and opinions are welcomed. Thanks in advance.



Living life for the sake of living – or, going through the motions, as we say – proved an inadequate method for success and happiness in my life. Different inflection points, through various experiences, changed my outlook on what living means and how to channel that energy into positive ends. Despite never having many friends in high school, I only earned mediocre grades with the free time this left me. My first turning point came while eating lunch and reading a book in my car by myself senior year. At this moment, after years of disdainful, complacent living, I vowed with every ounce of fight in my soul to change how I lived.

With a fresh start at college, I soon began to enjoy a confidence I always longed to exude. A new-found sense of adventurousness permeated all areas of my life. I engaged different groups on campus and even me, a person who in the past always shied away from speaking up on any issue, led and founded a political organization on campus and won two debate tournaments. I will never forget the day I strolled back from class knowing everyone I crossed, giving high fives and shouting out tentative arrangements for later that evening. During this time, I began to rethink how I related to people and the vast opportunities for personal happiness that could result from these experiences; and indeed, they have done just that for my life. Despite the gains I had been making to improve myself, a more serious experience needed to happen to truly illuminate my current path.

I had the misfortune of being charged with a misdemeanor for hosting a house party. As I was detained, handcuffed to a chair, I felt my personal accomplishments dissipating like the morning dew of that early morning. At my hearing, my public defender immediately advised me to plead guilty after skimming my case for a few minutes. Thankfully, I had the absolute good fortune to call a criminal lawyer my father met only one month before the hearing – the second lawyer I ever spoke to after my public defender. She spoke to my public defender on the phone in the courtroom and told him what to do. To my amazement, the judge reduced the charge to an infraction. While in the courtroom, in awe of the grandeur of the surroundings, I had an epiphany. People, charged with even more serious crimes than mine, have to use under-resourced lawyers and many times are incarcerated as a result. Before this incident my naiveté assumed that all people have equal justice under the law; and I experienced first-hand that this is not the case. I made a commitment to learn and improve a profession that has such a profound impact on the lives of people. Now, looking back at this experience, I understand what “falling forward” really means.

This commitment transformed the ways I approached my intellectual development, which had been nothing short of a complete letdown to this point. In my studies up to this point, I did the work only to complete the assignment – nothing more, nothing less. After weeks of self-reflection, I came to a conclusion: learn all you can and never stop growing. Although this might seem like an obvious principle, standards of this sort were never in high regard growing up. I began to read everything I could get my hands on: newspapers, scholarly magazines and journals, history books, and literature; most especially essays by R.W. Emerson. In my classes I immersed myself in my work, trying to learn the concepts and information as best as I could, which consequently improved my grades. I even voluntarily undertook a yearlong thesis and competed and won a school-wide competition for it. Through this process I developed my mind to critically think about different political and philosophical issues; though, I now generally differ from the ideologies of my entire family. Nevertheless, I highly value my freedom and range of thought.

Indeed, this range of thought led me to become interested in international law. Although I originally became interested criminal law, I grew to be engrossed with international matters through my major and internships by harnessing a voracious curiosity for learning I only recently discovered. My new way of thinking enhanced my studies to a level of gratification I never experienced in school. Currently, I am continuously fascinated as I begin to engage the internationalization of our world and a new epoch of modern history through my studies in Spanish and law and law internship in México. ______school__________ strength in international law will allow me to utilize and enrich the university’s established reputation and working-knowledge in this area of law with my first-hand knowledge of many aspects of Mexican society. If afforded the opportunity, I would undoubtedly take advantage of and contribute to_________int. program________. My liberal arts education and personal experience living in a Spanish-speaking society, combined with a legal education, will provide a solid formula to pursue my academic and professional interests.

Undeniably, I am fortunate to have had the tribulations in my life that, although difficult in the moment, have led me to you, an admissions committee member at one of the most elite academic institutions in the country. My journey of self-transformation beginning in high school and then redirected towards a path in law is probably not the normal route to this profession – but, to each his own. I cannot help but think of what Louis D. Brandeis once said, “Happiness includes…that satisfaction which can only come through the full development and utilization of ones’ faculties,” and pondering it in the context of my life. Though I have made great strides in becoming the man I want to grow to be, I have yet to reach the consummation of this maxim. Accordingly, I wish to continue pursuing my happiness and the development of my faculties at __________school__________.
Revised and reworked:


As I was detained, handcuffed to a chair of the early morning, I felt my personal gains dissipating like the morning dew. I was charged with a misdemeanor for hosting a house party. At my hearing, my public defender immediately advised me to plead guilty after skimming my case for a few minutes. It didn’t even seem like my lawyer was on my side, but rather, only trying to keep the flow of court unimpeded. Thankfully, I had the absolute good fortune to call a criminal lawyer my father met only one month before the hearing – the second lawyer I ever spoke to after my public defender. She spoke to my public defender on the phone in the courtroom and told him what to do. To my amazement, the judge reduced the charge to an infraction. While waiting in the courtroom after receiving my verdict, in awe of the grandeur of the surroundings, I knew something didn’t feel right. My feeling stemmed from a realization that people, charged with even more serious crimes than mine, have to use under-resourced lawyers and many times are incarcerated as a result. Before this incident my naivete assumed that all people have equal justice under the law; and I experienced first-hand that this is not the case. I made a commitment to learn and improve a profession that has such a profound impact on the lives of people.

This commitment transformed the direction of my life and how I lived it. After weeks of self-reflection, I came to a conclusion: learn all you can and never stop growing. I knew in order to become an attorney I would have to change myself for the better, and for good. This commitment radically changed my approach to my intellectual development, spurred me to live in another country, and ultimately focused my attention on a specific area of law.

Although this conclusion might seem obvious, I was never held to high standards growing up. In my studies up to this point, throughout high school and the beginning of college, I did the work only to complete the assignment – nothing more, nothing less. I finally shook off a mental-straitjacket of sorts. I began to read everything I could get my hands on: newspapers, scholarly magazines and journals, history books, and literature; most especially essays by R.W. Emerson. In my classes, I immersed myself in my work, trying to learn the concepts and information as best as I could, which consequently improved my grades. I began to intellectually spar on the debate team with a newly developed mind that could critically think about different political and philosophical issues; though, I now generally differ from the ideologies of my entire family. Nevertheless, I highly value my freedom and range of thought. I will never forget while walking across the stage, accepting an award after competing amongst Masters and Ph.D. students for a thesis I voluntarily undertook, knowing my future promise and past letdowns parted for good.

My new way of thinking enhanced my studies to a level of gratification I never experienced in school. Although I originally became interested criminal law, I grew to be engrossed with international matters through my major and internships, one being at a boutique international law firm, by allowing my curiosity go where it may. The strength of this curiosity has led me to continue my studies in Spanish and law and another law internship in Mexico. Specifically, through this internship, which mainly deals with agrarian law – a unique type of law in Mexico –, I am getting a crash course in Mexican law and international comparative law. I am identifying similarities and differences in our different legal systems and observing ways to improve them. I am truly taking advantage of an once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to understand Mexico by speaking with other Mexicans through my studies and tutoring service in addition to my family. I am learning about issues that very few Americans understand: how drug traffickers or “narcos” operate, how and why corruption reigns, and the vast business opportunities awaiting for those willing to take a chance on a wonderful, yet developing country. Indeed, these new and old experiences have led me to become interested in studying international law. I am particularly interested in energy markets, foreign direct investment, and the rule of law in Latin America.

______school__________ strength in international law will allow me to utilize and enrich the university’s established reputation and working-knowledge in this area of law with my first-hand knowledge of many aspects of Mexican society. If afforded the opportunity, I would undoubtedly take advantage of and contribute to_________int. program________. (1 or 2 sentences related to a specific program at a school). My liberal arts education and personal experience living in a Spanish-speaking society, combined with a legal education, will provide a solid formula to pursue my academic and professional interests.

Undeniably, I am fortunate to have had certain experiences in my life that, although difficult in the moment, have led me to you, an admissions committee member at one of the most elite academic institutions in the country. My journey of self-transformation is probably not the normal route to this profession – but, to each his own. I cannot help but think of what Louis D. Brandeis once said, “Happiness includes…that satisfaction which can only come through the full development and utilization of ones’ faculties,” and pondering it in the context of my life. Though I have made great strides in becoming the man I want to grow to be, I have yet to reach the consummation of this maxim. Accordingly, I wish to continue pursuing my happiness and the development of my faculties at __________school__________.
Thanks again for the help everyone has given.


I will never forget while walking across the stage to accept an award after competing amongst graduate students for a thesis I voluntarily undertook, knowing my future promise and past letdowns parted for good. After an incident with the law*, I made a commitment to change the direction of my life and how I lived it. After weeks of self-reflection, I came to a conclusion: learn all you can and never stop growing. This commitment transformed my approach to my intellectual development and ultimately focused my attention on a specific area of law.

Although this conclusion might seem obvious, I was never held to high standards growing up, nor did I hold myself to them. In my studies up to this realization, throughout high school and the beginning of college, I did the work only to complete assignments – nothing more, nothing less. I finally shook off a mental-straitjacket of sorts. With my newfound curiosity about the world I began to read everything I could get my hands on: newspapers, scholarly magazines and journals, history books, and literature; most especially essays by R.W. Emerson. In my classes, I immersed myself in my work, trying to learn the concepts and information as best as I could, which consequently improved my grades. I began to intellectually spar on the debate team with a newly developed mind that could critically think about different political and philosophical issues; though, I now generally differ from the ideologies of my entire family. Nevertheless, I highly value my freedom and range of thought.

Indeed, this new way of thinking enhanced my studies to a level of gratification I never experienced in school. By acting on my curiosity I grew to be engrossed with international matters through my major and internships, one being at a boutique international law firm. By sheer luck, the Chair of the International Law section of the San Diego Bar responded to a general inquiry for a law internship I made in Hispanic magazine. Through my daily seminars on international law at the office, ranging from discussions of the “ins-and-outs” of the business to theoretical topics and participating in high-level meetings, I found a career that truly interests me and one I know I can do well. The strength of this curiosity led me to continue my studies in Spanish and law and another law internship in Mexico. Through this internship, which mainly deals with agrarian law – a unique type of law in Mexico –, I am receiving a crash course in Mexican and international comparative law. I see underlying threads that connect common problems of the two law firms and relate them to public policy and laws in the U.S. and Mexico. I specifically remember at the San Diego office when a Mexican attorney solved a problem in a project that only he – a person on the Mexican side of the project – could handle. I realized from my first day at the office in Mexico that I would be learning about how to solve the same type of problem that the Mexican lawyer did. Although the lawyer at the San Diego office is an expert in this area of law, he didn’t know exactly what was happening with this problem involving Mexican law. It is exciting to think I understand a problem better than my mentor, a recognized expert in the field, because I am acting on my desire to learn. Instances like this, where I observe the interaction of distinct legal systems operating together and how they can complement one another, enhance my already-started legal education to a level that brings a unique perspective to my studies and classes at your school.

I am truly taking advantage of an once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to grow by speaking with other Mexicans through my studies and tutoring service in addition to my family about Mexico. I am learning about topics that very few Americans understand: how drug traffickers or “narcos” operate, how and why corruption reigns, and the vast business opportunities awaiting for those willing to take a chance on a wonderful, yet still developing country. Indeed, these new and old experiences have led me to become interested in studying international law. I am particularly interested in energy markets, foreign direct investment, and the rule of law in Latin America – a main source of problems in this region. I want to utilize my unique type of understanding for the continual development of this area of the world. If accepted, I would definitely take advantage of and enrich ___X program________ to further my knowledge and help enrich the school's scholarship on these issues. (1 more specific sentence about a school). My liberal arts education and personal experience living in a Spanish-speaking society, combined with a legal education, will provide a solid formula to pursue (specific degree program)/my academic and professional interests.

My journey of self-transformation is probably not the normal route to this profession – but, to each his own. I cannot help but think of what Louis D. Brandeis once said, “Happiness includes…that satisfaction which can only come through the full development and utilization of ones’ faculties,” and pondering it in the context of my life. Though I have made great strides in becoming the man I want to grow to be, I have yet to reach the consummation of this maxim. Accordingly, I wish to continue pursuing my happiness and the development of my faculties at __________school__________.



*A footnote will be added here noting that a description of what occurred is in the a conduct addendum, which is:

The last incident was when the police charged me with a misdemeanor for serving alcohol to minors at a party a few days after my 19th birthday. I paid a fine for the final charge of an infraction.
At my hearing, my public defender immediately advised me to plead guilty after skimming my case for a few minutes. Thankfully, I had the absolute good fortune to call a criminal lawyer my father met only one month before the hearing – the second lawyer I ever spoke to after my public defender. She spoke to my public defender on the phone in the courtroom and told him what to do. To my amazement, the judge reduced the charge to an infraction. While waiting in the courtroom after receiving my verdict, I knew something didn’t feel right. My feeling stemmed from a realization that people, charged with even more serious crimes than mine, have to use under-resourced lawyers and many times are incarcerated as a result. Before this incident my naiveté assumed that all people have equal justice under the law; and I experienced first-hand that this is not the case. I made a commitment to become and attorney and to learn and improve a profession that has such a profound impact on the lives of people. This commitment enabled me to turn the page on this part of my life and to pursue a career in a type of law in which I am truly interested.
Last edited by lawrencecis on Tue Jul 20, 2010 1:32 am, edited 3 times in total.

User avatar
Hannibal

Gold
Posts: 2211
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2010 12:00 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by Hannibal » Thu Jul 15, 2010 12:09 am

I think you're dwelling too much on your negative.

Also you don't want to cast academic enthusiasm as something of a "I need to change my life" crisis.

Or at least, I wouldn't.

chymali

New
Posts: 17
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2010 3:55 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by chymali » Thu Jul 15, 2010 12:35 am

Honest opinion is I stopped reading. It is boring.

Start the story with the party and tell it like a personal experience instead of an essay.

User avatar
lawrencecis

New
Posts: 48
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 3:42 am

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by lawrencecis » Thu Jul 15, 2010 1:29 am

Ok, wasn't expecting these comments. Thanks for the heads up, though.

Yeah, probably the idea of getting arrested is probably a little more intriguing than being uncool in high school 6 years ago. The whole part about high school I think can be reworked into the rest of the essay.

User avatar
sternc

Bronze
Posts: 204
Joined: Mon Oct 12, 2009 1:07 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by sternc » Thu Jul 15, 2010 1:46 am

Ehhh, it is kind of boring. The idea that you did not work hard but now you will work hard is probably used pretty often. I know the arrest is not necessarily the basis of your PS, but usually a simple addendum is better suited for information about those sorts of things. Is there anything else about you that is unique? This little essay is supposed to be their chance to see you as someone different from the countless other applicants (in a good way). Also, "had the misfortune of..." sounds terrible. It sounds like you are not taking blame for your actions. Whether or not you were really at fault, the committee members will not know this and you need to take responsibility. Lastly, I hope you only have one school in mind for this PS. If so, add more details about the exact program. If not, schools will see right through it.

Want to continue reading?

Register now to search topics and post comments!

Absolutely FREE!


User avatar
Tanicius

Gold
Posts: 2984
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:54 am

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by Tanicius » Thu Jul 15, 2010 1:52 am

Although I believe you are sincere when you write about it, I also wouldn't say something that essentially amounts to, "I realized that public defenders are unfairly bad at the practice of law."

User avatar
billyez

Silver
Posts: 865
Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2009 6:19 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by billyez » Thu Jul 15, 2010 2:00 am

At first, I was pretty certain that you should keep the paragraph regarding the infraction because it connected to what interested you in law. But then...wait, no it isn't. You don't want to be a PD or work in these "under-sourced environments" - you want to work in international law. That feeling I got after recognizing this is a pretty good assessment about how I felt about reading your PS - it meanders, touching on one issue after another but not really going in depth about any one of them..

"The journey of self-discovery" is kind-of-sort-of the theme I used for my PS and while it might be common it can be effective. The problem here is that your journey isn't tightly defined. Your paragraphs read like disparate episodes of an ongoing series, when it might be wholly more effective to just focus on one or two interrelated episodes of your life and use that to define who you are.
A new-found sense of adventurousness permeated all areas of my life.


Bad sentence and also unnecessary. Your campus involvement demonstrates your "adventurousness". We don't need to be told about it, you need to show it to us; the following sentences do so well enough without a sentence telegraphing it to us.
Indeed, this range of thought led me to become interested in international law. Although I originally became interested criminal law, I grew to be engrossed with international matters through my major and internships by harnessing a voracious curiosity for learning I only recently discovered. My new way of thinking enhanced my studies to a level of gratification I never experienced in school. Currently, I am continuously fascinated as I begin to engage the internationalization of our world and a new epoch of modern history through my studies in Spanish and law and law internship in México. ______school__________ strength in international law will allow me to utilize and enrich the university’s established reputation and working-knowledge in this area of law with my first-hand knowledge of many aspects of Mexican society. If afforded the opportunity, I would undoubtedly take advantage of and contribute to_________int. program________. My liberal arts education and personal experience living in a Spanish-speaking society, combined with a legal education, will provide a solid formula to pursue my academic and professional interests.
International law is your interest and this paragraph is designed to make the admissions officer aware of that. But note that nowhere within this paragraph do you explain what you want to do in this area. Sure, I know what your fascinated by and I know how you came to be interested in it, but when I finished reading this paragraph I didn't have a particular vision of what you wanted to do. What are you going to use the university's "reputation and working-knowledge" for? It feels like a passing fancy of the moment more than anything else. You need to make us aware of what your goals are in international law. Do you want to be an immigration attorney or something like that? Do international business in Mexico?

If this is your objective...if this was the destination of your journey of self-discovery, then not only do you need to flesh it out you need to give us hints earlier in the PS that this wher eyou're going. I had no idea that you lived in a Spanish-speaking society until this point in your essay and it's the last sentence of the penultimate paragraph. Can you talk about your experiences in this Spanish-speaking society and how it contributed to your interest and dedication to international law? I think such a story could be engaging and just as important, personal. I feel disconnected from you when I read this and that needs to be fixed.

Also, I really didn't like the bolded sentence. What is the "new epoch of modern history"? What is the "internationalization of our world"? What do you mean by them? How were you made aware of them through your internship experience? Put some meat on this bone.

User avatar
OhOkay

New
Posts: 65
Joined: Thu Jul 15, 2010 8:14 am

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by OhOkay » Thu Jul 15, 2010 10:08 am

Hi there.

I definitely agree with the poster above that your PS is too meandering. Think about every incident you've mentioned and ask yourself the following:

1) Have I explained how incident X resulted in change Y?

For instance, you mentioned that reading a book while sitting in your car in high school led to you changing how you lived. Neither X nor why Y is clear here. What does reading the book and sitting in a car have to do with coming to Y conclusion? And what exactly was your conclusion? To make more friends? To improve your grades? Saying "I vowed with every ounce of fight in my soul to change how I lived" seems incredibly over dramatic. Honestly, I would just cut out this whole paragraph. Why are you mentioning high school? Lots of people were all kind of different weird in high school. We were 14-18. Only mention if you can answer yes to the next question...

2) Does this incident contribute to the overarching point of my essay?

Well, this depends a lot on the overarching point of your essay. Right now it's something like, "I've had ups and downs and it's made me develop positively." That pretty much sums up everyone's life, even my cat's. I think a stronger one would be why you want to study International Law and why you'd be good at it. If you choose that as your main point, then talking about having now friends in high school, making friends in college, getting arrested, noticing weak public defenders, all of that has nothing to do with showing why you want to study IL or why you'd be good at it, and the paragraph on international internship experiences is way too vague right now to contribute to that main point.

Also, I would be very careful with word choice. For instance, you say in the first paragraph that you had a "disdainful" way of living. What do you mean by that? Disdainful implies you were scornful, not exactly something you want to say in your PS. Also, in your last paragraph, you say you had "tribulations" in your life. Perhaps your DS explains other harder aspects of your life, but in the context of this PS, I would not call getting arrested for throwing a house party or having now friends in high school serious life tribulations.

In any case, please take this is constructive criticism, not personally! Good luck with everything, I hope all goes well for you.

User avatar
dominkay

Bronze
Posts: 354
Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2010 4:41 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by dominkay » Thu Jul 15, 2010 10:25 am

lawrencecis wrote:I am particularly worried about discussing the arrest. Don't hold back. All criticism and opinions are welcomed. Thanks in advance.



Living life for the sake of living – or, going through the motions, as we say – proved an inadequate method for success and happiness in my life. Different inflection points, through various experiences, changed my outlook on what living means and how to channel that energy into positive ends. Despite never having many friends in high school, I only earned mediocre grades with the free time this left me. My first turning point came while eating lunch and reading a book in my car by myself senior year. At this moment, after years of disdainful, complacent living, I vowed with every ounce of fight in my soul to change how I lived.

With a fresh start at college, I soon began to enjoy a confidence I always longed to exude. A new-found sense of adventurousness permeated all areas of my life. I engaged different groups on campus and even me, a person who in the past always shied away from speaking up on any issue, led and founded a political organization on campus and won two debate tournaments. I will never forget the day I strolled back from class knowing everyone I crossed, giving high fives and shouting out tentative arrangements for later that evening. During this time, I began to rethink how I related to people and the vast opportunities for personal happiness that could result from these experiences; and indeed, they have done just that for my life. Despite the gains I had been making to improve myself, a more serious experience needed to happen to truly illuminate my current path.

I had the misfortune of being charged with a misdemeanor for hosting a house party. As I was detained, handcuffed to a chair, I felt my personal accomplishments dissipating like the morning dew of that early morning. At my hearing, my public defender immediately advised me to plead guilty after skimming my case for a few minutes. Thankfully, I had the absolute good fortune to call a criminal lawyer my father met only one month before the hearing – the second lawyer I ever spoke to after my public defender. She spoke to my public defender on the phone in the courtroom and told him what to do. To my amazement, the judge reduced the charge to an infraction. While in the courtroom, in awe of the grandeur of the surroundings, I had an epiphany. People, charged with even more serious crimes than mine, have to use under-resourced lawyers and many times are incarcerated as a result. Before this incident my naiveté assumed that all people have equal justice under the law; and I experienced first-hand that this is not the case. I made a commitment to learn and improve a profession that has such a profound impact on the lives of people. Now, looking back at this experience, I understand what “falling forward” really means.

This commitment transformed the ways I approached my intellectual development, which had been nothing short of a complete letdown to this point. In my studies up to this point, I did the work only to complete the assignment – nothing more, nothing less. After weeks of self-reflection, I came to a conclusion: learn all you can and never stop growing. Although this might seem like an obvious principle, standards of this sort were never in high regard growing up. I began to read everything I could get my hands on: newspapers, scholarly magazines and journals, history books, and literature; most especially essays by R.W. Emerson. In my classes I immersed myself in my work, trying to learn the concepts and information as best as I could, which consequently improved my grades. I even voluntarily undertook a yearlong thesis and competed and won a school-wide competition for it. Through this process I developed my mind to critically think about different political and philosophical issues; though, I now generally differ from the ideologies of my entire family. Nevertheless, I highly value my freedom and range of thought.

Indeed, this range of thought led me to become interested in international law. Although I originally became interested criminal law, I grew to be engrossed with international matters through my major and internships by harnessing a voracious curiosity for learning I only recently discovered. My new way of thinking enhanced my studies to a level of gratification I never experienced in school. Currently, I am continuously fascinated as I begin to engage the internationalization of our world and a new epoch of modern history through my studies in Spanish and law and law internship in México. ______school__________ strength in international law will allow me to utilize and enrich the university’s established reputation and working-knowledge in this area of law with my first-hand knowledge of many aspects of Mexican society. If afforded the opportunity, I would undoubtedly take advantage of and contribute to_________int. program________. My liberal arts education and personal experience living in a Spanish-speaking society, combined with a legal education, will provide a solid formula to pursue my academic and professional interests.

Undeniably, I am fortunate to have had the tribulations in my life that, although difficult in the moment, have led me to you, an admissions committee member at one of the most elite academic institutions in the country. My journey of self-transformation beginning in high school and then redirected towards a path in law is probably not the normal route to this profession – but, to each his own. I cannot help but think of what Louis D. Brandeis once said, “Happiness includes…that satisfaction which can only come through the full development and utilization of ones’ faculties,” and pondering it in the context of my life. Though I have made great strides in becoming the man I want to grow to be, I have yet to reach the consummation of this maxim. Accordingly, I wish to continue pursuing my happiness and the development of my faculties at __________school__________.



(P.S. I also have a D.S. that I think makes it obvious that my dad didn't meet the lawyer at the country club.)
You really need to not use the phrase "inflection points." You can write ABOUT inflection points, but calling them that makes you sound really coached. The inflection points you do have are kind of lame. You were reading a book (you don't even name or describe the book!) and you VOWED IN YOUR SOUL to change things? And then continued to fuck up? Dude.

The person who said that the word "misfortune" means you're not taking responsibility for your actions is dead on.

You felt your dreams dissipating like the "morning dew of that early morning?" What else could it have been? The morning dew of the evening? The evening dew of the morning? Cut the cliches.

Also, referring to your experiences as "tribulations" is overwrought. It doesn't sound like you had it that bad, kid. I could tell you about some effing tribulations, but it would probably make you cry.

You don't seem comfortable with any of the big words you're using. It's like you're writing with a thesaurus in your lap. The whole thing rings false.

Want to continue reading?

Register for access!

Did I mention it was FREE ?


User avatar
ShuckingNotJiving

Bronze
Posts: 266
Joined: Wed Jun 30, 2010 11:24 am

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by ShuckingNotJiving » Thu Jul 15, 2010 11:07 am

My thoughts -- the ideas aren't terrible (albeit cliche), and you have a decent command of the english language. However, this essay has what we call a "wtf" quality to it. That's a technical term, to be sure, used among most literary critics. It means that I read your essay, and then thought: "WTF is this person trying to say about himself?" and then "WTF did I read this essay if I"m more confused about who the person is now than before?" Note: the w's in the wtf's mean "what" and "why" respectively. You need to pay more attention to the details you leave in, and the details you take out. I can tell you have so much you want to add to your essay, because you feel that you've gone through this journey and accomplished a lot in the process. But, you do your accomplishments a disservice if you haphazardly throw them into paragraphs without fleshing them out. I would just pick no more than three things that you believe show your newfound sense of adventurousness (whatever that means to you), and explain those. Make those the center of your essay, and take out the nonsense about that insignificant arrest.
lawrencecis wrote:I am particularly worried about discussing the arrest. Don't hold back. All criticism and opinions are welcomed. Thanks in advance.



Living life for the sake of living – or, going through the motions, as we say who is we? – proved an inadequate method for success and happiness in my life.too abstract. Different inflection points, through various experiences, changed my outlook on what living means and how to channel that energy into positive ends. Despite never having many friends in high school, I only earned mediocre grades with the free time this left me.Haha, I like how you imply that students without many friends should at least have good grades. Well if that's the case, the question is begged: what on earth were you doing since you obviously weren't partying or studying? My first turning point came while eating lunch and reading a book in my car by myself senior year Oh. I see. This is what you were doing. In all seriousness though, this is an irrelevant detail. What does the fact that you were were eating lunch in your car add to your epiphanic moment?. At this moment, after years of disdainful, complacent living, I vowed with every ounce of fight in my soul to change how I lived. THIS is where you should be more specific. What did you decide to change? Why did you make this decision?

With a fresh start at college, I soon began to enjoy a confidence I always longed to exude. A new-found sense of adventurousness permeated all areas of my life. Be more specific here. How did this adventurousness permeate? I engaged different groups on campus and even me, a person who in the past always shied away from speaking up on any issue, led and founded a political organization on campus and won two debate tournaments.More details here. I will never forget the day I strolled back from class knowing everyone I crossed, giving high fives and shouting out tentative arrangements for later that evening.This makes it seem like you cared more about your newfound social life, than your newfound academic success During this time, I began to rethink how I related to people and the vast opportunities for personal happiness that could result from these experiences; and indeed, they have done just that for my life. I have no idea what this means. Do you? Despite the gains I had been making to improve myself, a more serious experience needed to happen to truly illuminate my current path.

I had the misfortune of being charged with a misdemeanor for hosting a house party. As I was detained, handcuffed to a chair, I felt my personal accomplishments dissipating like the morning dew of that early morning.Absolutely not. And even if this was something you should keep in your essay, it should be "the early morning," not "that early morning." At my hearing, my public defender immediately advised me to plead guilty after skimming my case for a few minutes. Thankfully, I had the absolute good fortune to call a criminal lawyer my father met only one month before the hearing – the second lawyer I ever spoke to after my public defender. She spoke to my public defender on the phone in the courtroom and told him what to do. To my amazement, the judge reduced the charge to an infraction. While in the courtroom, in awe of the grandeur of the surroundings, I had an epiphany. People, charged with even more serious crimes than mine, have to use under-resourced lawyers and many times are incarcerated as a result. Before this incident my naiveté assumed that all people have equal justice under the law; and I experienced first-hand that this is not the case. I made a commitment to learn and improve a profession that has such a profound impact on the lives of people. Now, looking back at this experience, I understand what “falling forward” really means.This shouldn't be in your Personal Statement. Unless it's the focal point on which your entire essay is based. As it stands right now you have two epiphanies within three paragraphs. Epiphanies are supposed to be unique, or else they lose their importance.

This commitment transformed the ways I approached my intellectual development, which had been nothing short of a complete letdown to this point. In my studies up to this point, I did the work only to complete the assignment – nothing more, nothing less. After weeks of self-reflection, I came to a conclusion: learn all you can and never stop growing. Although this might seem like an obvious principle, standards of this sort were never in high regard growing up. Just say - I never was held to such high standards growing up. Don't make things that are so easy to say so confusing. I began to read everything I could get my hands on: newspapers, scholarly magazines and journals, history books, and literature; most especially essays by R.W. Emerson. In my classes I immersed myself in my work, trying to learn the concepts and information as best as I could, which consequently improved my grades. I even voluntarily undertook a yearlong thesis and competed and won a school-wide competition for it. Through this process I developed my mind to critically think about different political and philosophical issues; though, I now generally differ from the ideologies of my entire family. Nevertheless, I highly value my freedom and range of thought. This paragraph isn't bad, but I wonder if you could flesh out some of the details more. You speak of this competition you won -- which seems promising as a point of further description --then you jump to another abstract idea. Your thesis in this paragraph is: I learned the importance of learning. So pick a few details that support that, then explain those further.

Indeed, this range of thought led me to become interested in international law. Although I originally became interested criminal law, I grew to be engrossed with international matters through my major and internships by harnessing a voracious curiosity for learning I only recently discovered. My new way of thinking enhanced my studies to a level of gratification I never experienced in school. Currently, I am continuously fascinated as I begin to engage the internationalization of our world and a new epoch of modern history through my studies in Spanish and law and law internship in México.How can you NOT add more details about this internship, but you can detail eating a sandwich in a car in high school?? Please write a couple sentences about your experiences in Mexico. That could enrich this essay so much. ______school__________ strength in international law will allow me to utilize and enrich the university’s established reputation and working-knowledge in this area of law with my first-hand knowledge of many aspects of Mexican society. If afforded the opportunity, I would undoubtedly take advantage of and contribute to_________int. program________. My liberal arts education and personal experience living in a Spanish-speaking society, combined with a legal education, will provide a solid formula to pursue my academic and professional interests. This sentence is the core of you essay? Correct? It's what you've been trying to prove in the past 2-3 pages. So why do I not see anything about your experience living in a Spanish-speaking society? Why do I remember more about your misdemeanor and public defender than I do about your interest in law?

Undeniably, I am fortunate to have had the tribulations in my life that, although difficult in the moment, have led me to you, an admissions committee member at one of the most elite academic institutions in the country. Okay, nevermind, THIS is supposed to be the core of your essay. Or is it? I really don't know, and now it's becoming frustrating. It's generally not a good sign, if one has an underlying feeling of frustration when reading your essay. My journey of self-transformation beginning in high school and then redirected towards a path in law is probably not the normal route to this profession – but, to each his own. I cannot help but think of what Louis D. Brandeis once said, “Happiness includes…that satisfaction which can only come through the full development and utilization of ones’ faculties,” and pondering it in the context of my life. Though I have made great strides in becoming the man I want to grow to be, I have yet to reach the consummation of this maxim.There is a simpler way to say this that doesn't make it look like you just consulted a thesaurus. The same could be said about a lot of your more verbose phrases. It's very easy to tell when someone uses vocabulary in writing that isn't natural for them. Accordingly, I wish to continue pursuing my happiness and the development of my faculties at __________school__________.



(P.S. I also have a D.S. that I think makes it obvious that my dad didn't meet the lawyer at the country club.)

User avatar
lawrencecis

New
Posts: 48
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 3:42 am

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by lawrencecis » Thu Jul 15, 2010 11:22 am

Great, thanks for all the replies. It seems they all have a few overarching themes.

I think I'm going to cut the first two paragraphs. And rather focus on the incident, development, then interest in int. law (then talk about this more). I think it would be a tighter, more compact paper. I think my biggest problem with the essay is I want to talk about my whole life instead of picking parts to talk about.

I'll post a revised one soon.


Thanks for the line-by-line criticism ShuckingNotJiving

shoop

Bronze
Posts: 326
Joined: Mon Feb 15, 2010 1:52 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing

Post by shoop » Thu Jul 15, 2010 11:42 am

Please don't use the word "epiphany" unless you're Jesus and you have three magi adoring your naked, chubby baby self in a food trough. For one, it's a cliched way to describe the transformative experience you claim to have had, assuming it actually went down that way. Two, what you took from that particular moment probably didn't actually hit you IN THAT MOMENT. As you sat in that courtroom, you were probably not "in awe of your surroundings" because face it... most courtrooms aren't like what we see on TV, and you were probably more concerned with the outcome of your own case than with the plight of serious offenders who get stuck with under-resourced PDs. Maybe you thought about the experience later and gained some insight about why you want to attend law school, but I doubt it really hit you right in that moment.

User avatar
billyez

Silver
Posts: 865
Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2009 6:19 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing (2nd Round)

Post by billyez » Thu Jul 15, 2010 3:01 pm

You cut the paragraphs, but you didn't edit the new opening accordingly - actually, it apepars that you didn't edit it at all. As a result, I don't know what "personal gains" you're talking about in the first sentence. You need to strengthen that paragraph now. Also:
As I was detained, handcuffed to a chair of the early morning, I felt my personal gains dissipating like the morning dew.
- "a chair of the early morning?" You have to fix that.

I still believe that the infraction shouldn't be in the PS. Actually, that first pargraph could be construed into an addendum regarding the incident - if you have to acknowledge it in your application at all, which I believe you might. I think it would be a rather solid addendum, expalining how this incident was a catalyst for your interest in law.

I would start over beginning with your involvement in the Spanish-speaking society and focusing on all the stuff you talk about in the fourth paragraph. There's tons of information packed into that paragraph but very little of it is is fully developed becauseyou've spent so much of your PS on other issues. I advise this approach, because as ShuckingNotJiving stated and others have noted, your interest in international law is the core of your PS. If that's the case you should develop your PS with this in mind. It's still not a compact and entirely focused PS yet and I think this would make it so.

Register now!

Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.

It's still FREE!


User avatar
lawrencecis

New
Posts: 48
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 3:42 am

Re: Take a look and have a swing (2nd Round)

Post by lawrencecis » Thu Jul 15, 2010 5:57 pm

billyez wrote:You cut the paragraphs, but you didn't edit the new opening accordingly - actually, it apepars that you didn't edit it at all. As a result, I don't know what "personal gains" you're talking about in the first sentence. You need to strengthen that paragraph now. Also:
As I was detained, handcuffed to a chair of the early morning, I felt my personal gains dissipating like the morning dew.
- "a chair of the early morning?" You have to fix that.

I still believe that the infraction shouldn't be in the PS. Actually, that first pargraph could be construed into an addendum regarding the incident - if you have to acknowledge it in your application at all, which I believe you might. I think it would be a rather solid addendum, expalining how this incident was a catalyst for your interest in law.



I would start over beginning with your involvement in the Spanish-speaking society and focusing on all the stuff you talk about in the fourth paragraph. There's tons of information packed into that paragraph but very little of it is is fully developed becauseyou've spent so much of your PS on other issues. I advise this approach, because as ShuckingNotJiving stated and others have noted, your interest in international law is the core of your PS. If that's the case you should develop your PS with this in mind. It's still not a compact and entirely focused PS yet and I think this would make it so.
Yeah, I definitely need to mention the incident. So, that is actually a good point to put it in an addendum. I never knew you could use that space to write a pargraph or even a little more explaining a problem. I think that is what I´m going to do. I put it in the PS because I thought I need to explain my first reason for wanting to study law. Plus, I can just be straight-forward about it without including lines like the one´s everyone has quoted.

Would it be wise to keep the section on ¨intellectual development¨ and academic related things? I feel that this directly is the cause for my interest in international law. It also shows growth. However, I do feel it does reflect away from my interest in int. law and experiences relating to it.


Thanks for the response.

User avatar
lawrencecis

New
Posts: 48
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 3:42 am

Re: Take a look and have a swing (3rd and don't be shy!)

Post by lawrencecis » Mon Jul 19, 2010 6:45 pm

I think the addendum idea works well with the new essay.

User avatar
billyez

Silver
Posts: 865
Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2009 6:19 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing (3rd and don't be shy!)

Post by billyez » Sat Jul 24, 2010 2:29 am

A personal statement with a footnote? No, I really don't like this idea. A footnote draws someone out of the story that is being told in order to give out more information. I'd advocate just writing an addendum expressing the same ideas that were in the original paragraph. But if you don't want to do that, just keep it in the essay proper instead of trying to weasel it in. Having it as a footnote is worse than the alternative. Also, your essay just flows a heck of a lot better without it. But if you insist in having it in your PS in some capacity...well, hey, as you said in your last paragraph - to each their own, eh?

I have to apologize here, as I didn't read this as carefully as I should have. I initially concluded that your footnote would be the paragraph you have there, instead it's something that makes adcomms aware of the addendum. This is a heck of a lot less awkward and heavy-handed than what I originally thought. Still don't like it, though, since you could just have the addendum without making them aware of it beforehand. I mean, do you want them to be aware of this incident, flip to your addendum to read it first, then flip back to your PS right while their in middle of it?

Besides that, I really like what you did with the third paragraph. The anecdote that you used about the offices and such did what your first draft didn't; it made me feel like your reasons for being interested in international law was tangible - that you had a stable interest in it rather than a passing fancy. I don't think that anecdote is very interesting (no offense) but that's fine, because it doesn't have to be. It successfully indicates that you have a genuine interest in this area of law.

I don't like the quote at the end. It might be fine without the "consummation of this maxim" bit at the end in relation to it. Just say that you strive to live up to that quote or saying. That phrase just seems kind of overwrought to me.

User avatar
ArchRoark

Silver
Posts: 1000
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 2:53 pm

Re: Take a look and have a swing (3rd and don't be shy!)

Post by ArchRoark » Sat Jul 24, 2010 3:03 am

interested criminal law, I grew to be engrossed with international matters through my major and internships, one being at a boutique international law firm, by allowing my curiosity go where it may. The strength of this curiosity has led me to continue my studies in Spanish and law and another law internship in Mexico. Specifically, through this internship, which mainly deals with agrarian law – a unique type of law in Mexico –, I am getting a crash course in Mexican law and international comparative law.
I am about to fall asleep so I didn't give this a thorough read but that group of sentences just made my head hurt. Reword them to not include "law" every other word.

Get unlimited access to all forums and topics

Register now!

I'm pretty sure I told you it's FREE...


Post Reply

Return to “Law School Personal Statements”