UCLA ($$) vs Michigan ($) Forum

[bruinfan10]

Hey all, I'm looking for advice on a decision between UCLA with a full scholarship and Michigan with a half scholarship. My career goal is to work for a DA's office in California, not go into Big Law, and the extra money at UCLA is looking pretty attractive. Any thoughts on whether the significant ranking jump at Michigan is worth foregoing 60k?

<edited for updated $$ figures>

[worldtraveler]

This sounds like an easy decision for UCLA. If you had other goals, Michigan might be worth it, but in your case, take the money and run.

[glewz]

Hey all, I'm looking for advice on a decision between UCLA with a 90k scholarship and Michigan with a 45k scholarship. My career goal is to work for a DA's office in California, not go into Big Law, and the extra money at UCLA is looking pretty attractive. Any thoughts on whether the significant ranking jump at Michigan is worth forgoing 45k?

are you in-state @ CA (useful to know COA)? norcal vs. socal preferences?

[bruinfan10]

I am in-state for UCLA, and my preference is to work in Norcal long term, but for my first job I'd take a Socal position. I was hoping Berkeley would match my Michigan scholarship to be honest, but their matching program is apparently broke.

[glewz]

I am in-state for UCLA, and my preference is to work in Norcal long term, but for my first job I'd take a Socal position. I was hoping Berkeley would match my Michigan scholarship to be honest, but their matching program is apparently broke.

UCLA is a strong choice. In any case, it wouldn't be a bad idea to visit Mich & see how you like it. The reason for this is of course - Mich gives you market portability, so if you aren't dead set on CA...

[dpk711]

For your case UCLA -- easy choice.

[JamMasterJ]

yeah the price difference with instate and higher scholly and a clear pref for Cali is golden. Congrats, Bruin

[bruinfan10]

I appreciate the input! I figured there'd be at least one rankings lover out there who'd say a jump from a school just shy of the T14 to a top-10 school would be worth it, but I guess not.

With that in mind, does anyone know if UCLA's made statements recently about increasing their tuition? One reason Michigan appeals to me is because their state isn't going through the economic downturn of a lifetime.

[drdolittle]

I appreciate the input! I figured there'd be at least one rankings lover out there who'd say a jump from a school just shy of the T14 to a top-10 school would be worth it, but I guess you can't beat the almighty dollar. =)

With that in mind, does anyone know if UCLA's made statements recently about increasing their tuition? One reason Michigan appeals to me is because their state isn't going through the economic downturn of a lifetime.

You might want to check on this. Ever heard of Detroit?

The recent UC tuition increases are bad but the schools have a need for $ and they've figured out that for now students are willing to pay more to attend in CA. Not sure how long the increases will continue without significant effects on student quality, but I'm pretty sure it's not forever, especially with a depressed CA legal market.

[glewz]

With that in mind, does anyone know if UCLA's made statements recently about increasing their tuition? One reason Michigan appeals to me is because their state isn't going through the economic downturn of a lifetime.

Duno about your question, but I just wana clarify on your reason for finding Mich an attractive option - Michigan might very well be going to an economic turmoil similar to CA (Detroit, as another poster mentioned); however, Mich does open up the midwest and gives you a much better shot at anywhere else in the US.

[worldtraveler]

With that in mind, does anyone know if UCLA's made statements recently about increasing their tuition? One reason Michigan appeals to me is because their state isn't going through the economic downturn of a lifetime.

Duno about your question, but I just wana clarify on your reason for finding Mich an attractive option - Michigan might very well be going to an economic turmoil similar to CA (Detroit, as another poster mentioned); however, Mich does open up the midwest and gives you a much better shot at anywhere else in the US.

What exactly is there to open up in the Midwest?

[FlanAl]

with in-state isn't berk at sticker about the same as out of state at mich with your scholly? dude berk's lrap is super legit and working for a DA should qualify. I know its not an option in the OP and not to d-rail your thread, but for what you want to do you should definitely go to berkeley.

[bruinfan10]

I ran the COA numbers and factoring in my savings, I'm left with a 20k debt at UCLA and a 65k debt at Michigan. Given those numbers, and the fact that most California DA's office are still under a hiring freeze, the idea of going to the top-10 school and then working off the loans at a firm before heading into PI is starting to look a lot more attractive.

Does anyone think taking on 45k more in debt for Michigan over UCLA is insane? Because the more I think about it, the more I think Michigan keeps my career path and choice of legal market open.

[83947368]

.

[glewz]

UCLA - no CA DA office means socal biglaw is the best possible.

Mich - national prestige. DA office in other large cities, biglaw in all major cities in the US

[bruinfan10]

UCLA - no CA DA office means socal biglaw is the best possible.

Mich - national prestige. DA office in other large cities, biglaw in all major cities in the US

I'm heading out to Ann Arbor this week to visit the campus - I think the added career security at Michigan might be worth the additional investment. Thanks for all the advice!

[CanadianWolf]

No wrong choice--just two great options.

[fingersxd]

It looks like you've become more open to other (i.e. non-CA) markets. If so, that's great and Michigan should be your choice. But if you really are set on CA, Michigan's ability to open doors in Chicago, DC, NY and so forth is not really all that valuable to you as far as I can tell. Also, if there is a serious hiring freeze in the DA's offices in CA, not sure it will matter if you are from LA or Michigan, you'll eb stuck either way.

I will admit that I am a big believer in minimizing debt - 60k is reasonable to pay off if you are doing BigLaw. If not, that's A LOT of money doing anything else.
Also, if the scholly difference is 45k, are you considering the actual COA (given you can have CA in-state)...seems like that would make UCLA relatively cheaper. (And don't forget compounding interest as you repay)

I don't see CA schools increasing tuition much more given that at a certain point students simply won't go as other great optiosn remain available for less.

All of that aside, Michigan is the beter school so if you love it, are fine with the weather, ann arbor, etc. def. go.