Pepperdine--not so hyped on the conservative angle, but I know a lot of alumni who say it's not too bad. Academically, it sounds good. Highest ranked out of the three, but with the rankings at 51, 58 and 67, I don't suppose I should be too concerned about that?
Loyola--large alumni base. Haven't researched much on it, but I am impressed with its 20+ rank rise. There seems to be a growing consensus that Loyola > Pepperdine?
Brooklyn--everyone on TLS seems to hate on Brooklyn. Not so sure why. Looks like they have a reasonably impressive program. I guess they are kind of at the bottom of the list within the NYC law market, but their ranking isn't THAT bad..
I got waitlisted at Southwestern too
So, would love to hear opinions, except from egotistical douches that say "they all suck, you're screwed no matter what".