Notre Dame vs. University of Illinois help please Forum

[StephHall]

So, I'm trying to decide between U of I and ND and I have to decide soon. I really like both schools and they're both ranked very closely. I have $30,000 at U of I and $18,000 at ND. I'm just interested to hear any thoughts because I'm really torn right now. Thanks!

[Thirteen]

Where do you want to work (which market)? Have you visited both schools? What are your career goals (biglaw, clerking, etc)? If we had more information, it would be easier to offer opinions. Also, consider adding a poll to the post.

Congrats on the great offers, btw!

[CanadianWolf]

Different environments. Corn fields, bars & darts, plus softball versus big time athletics & religion.
Depends partially upon where you want to practice law; Notre Dame's reputation is national so the degree has more portability.

[thebookcollector]

So, I'm trying to decide between U of I and ND and I have to decide soon. I really like both schools and they're both ranked very closely. I have $30,000 at U of I and $18,000 at ND. I'm just interested to hear any thoughts because I'm really torn right now. Thanks!

First, I'd put up a poll if I were you... some people won't leave comments, but you'll get a good turnout from a vote.

Illinois was one of my top four, and ND is in the top two (and is my tentative choice).

I'd recommend ND, but more specifics might help people on this site.

They are ranked very similarly... ND is slightly lower, but it has much better facilities, a better alumni network, better Big Law placement, better clerkship placement, and is slightly cheaper (although your scholarship would make up for it).

Illinois (arguably) places better in Chicago, but I bet worse elsewhere. Illinois does have a pretty cool program for getting into academia if you look on their site, and the administration there has been great on these boards (which says something about their involvement with students).

[td6624]

South Bend is an absolute shithole.

fwiw

[ndirish2010]

Same offers and I just chose ND...then again, I'm an ND undergrad currently, so that could make me biased, but I very seriously considered U of I.

South Bend shouldn't be the deciding factor of where you go to school...and it is not all horrible, honestly what do you need from the town where you go to school? SB has everything I might want as a student, and I'm from a NYC bedroom community so I am used to better areas...plus low COL is always a benefit (not that it's expensive in Champaign).

[td6624]

Same offers and I just chose ND...then again, I'm an ND undergrad currently, so that could make me biased, but I very seriously considered U of I.

South Bend shouldn't be the deciding factor of where you go to school...and it is not all horrible, honestly what do you need from the town where you go to school? SB has everything I might want as a student, and I'm from a NYC bedroom community so I am used to better areas...plus low COL is always a benefit (not that it's expensive in Champaign).

The post below mine is TCR.

[romothesavior]

If you're an Illinois resident and you want Chicago, take UIUC. 30k is almost a full ride for in-state residents.

If you want to go elsewhere, take ND.

[solrac84]

I'm from the west coast. I'm not sure ND is more well known than Illinois back west. However, it might be different in other parts of the country. I would pick the school that offered more money. Easy decision. Both are the same. The end.

[09042014]

I went to Illinois and when I visited Notre Dame to see some friends, the undergrads did the same shit they did at Illinois. I think location is a wash.

Job placement is a big tie as well. ND does better in clerkships, they both tie in terms of placement in big law, and Illinois is better in Chicago.

I think it comes down to money. If you are getting 30K over 3 years vs 18 K over three years, the cost isn't that big of a difference. If you were completely unsure, I'd go with Illinois just for the money. But if you really like ND, 12K isn't that big of a deal over three years. But if those totals are per year, you really should go to Illinois.

Job prospects out of both are really poor right now. Debt minimization is key.

[itsmytime10]

I went to Illinois and when I visited Notre Dame to see some friends, the undergrads did the same shit they did at Illinois. I think location is a wash.

Job placement is a big tie as well. ND does better in clerkships, they both tie in terms of placement in big law, and Illinois is better in Chicago.

I think it comes down to money. If you are getting 30K over 3 years vs 18 K over three years, the cost isn't that big of a difference. If you were completely unsure, I'd go with Illinois just for the money. But if you really like ND, 12K isn't that big of a deal over three years. But if those totals are per year, you really should go to Illinois.

Job prospects out of both are really poor right now. Debt minimization is key.

Desert Fox, you keep saying that job prospects are poor coming out of these schools. Do you have any proof of this? From what i have heard and seen in terms of stats these schools are still doing very well.

[StephHall]

Thanks so much for all the responses! I'm interested in international law and constitutional law and am hoping to eventually work in DC, although I'm not sure yet whether or not I want to work in the public or private sector. The scholarships I posted are annual (18,000/30,000 per year). I've visited both schools and I really like both of them, which makes it a lot harder. The facilities at ND are second to none, but I prefer Champaign to South Bend.

[Mary4404]

It's been six years since this post but I am currently choosing between these schools. Would you still say they are peer schools? Would you say the scandal UIUC in 2013 has hurt graduates trying to work in Chicago? I am hoping to work in the Midwest region. Originally from Michigan but fine not going back.
I received 30k from ND and 96k from UIUC. However ND has always been a dream school for me. I'm still wait listed at NU.
Not sure if anyone will read this but figured I would give it a shot. My fiancé wants me to go with UIUC because of the low debt. But I think I could get better internships and a better job from ND. Opinions please!

[jlk411]

It's been six years since this post but I am currently choosing between these schools. Would you still say they are peer schools? Would you say the scandal UIUC in 2013 has hurt graduates trying to work in Chicago? I am hoping to work in the Midwest region. Originally from Michigan but fine not going back.
I received 30k from ND and 96k from UIUC. However ND has always been a dream school for me. I'm still wait listed at NU.
Not sure if anyone will read this but figured I would give it a shot. My fiancé wants me to go with UIUC because of the low debt. But I think I could get better internships and a better job from ND. Opinions please!

My vote is ND, higher ranking and more well known. Also, had a great experience with their administration fwiw.

[emkay625]

Consider making a new thread and a poll—lots of people probably pull this up and don't bother to respond because the OP is six years old

[Pomeranian]

They are essentially peer schools, with UIUC having an edge in Chicago and ND a little more national portability.

Also, your fiancé is right to be wary about ND... 30k From ND would mean having to pay back 200K+ (including COL) in loans for Notre Dame Law, which makes it NOT worth it.

[cron1834]

It's been six years since this post but I am currently choosing between these schools. Would you still say they are peer schools? Would you say the scandal UIUC in 2013 has hurt graduates trying to work in Chicago? I am hoping to work in the Midwest region. Originally from Michigan but fine not going back.
I received 30k from ND and 96k from UIUC. However ND has always been a dream school for me. I'm still wait listed at NU.
Not sure if anyone will read this but figured I would give it a shot. My fiancé wants me to go with UIUC because of the low debt. But I think I could get better internships and a better job from ND. Opinions please!

Post total/bottom-line COAs including interest, tuition increases, and not-conservative cost of living... not just scholarship amounts.

[ndirish2010]

Ha, that's funny to see that I posted on this thread as a 0L.

[Rigo]

It's been six years since this post but I am currently choosing between these schools. Would you still say they are peer schools? Would you say the scandal UIUC in 2013 has hurt graduates trying to work in Chicago? I am hoping to work in the Midwest region. Originally from Michigan but fine not going back.
I received 30k from ND and 96k from UIUC. However ND has always been a dream school for me. I'm still wait listed at NU.
Not sure if anyone will read this but figured I would give it a shot. My fiancé wants me to go with UIUC because of the low debt. But I think I could get better internships and a better job from ND. Opinions please!

Your fiancé is right. Make your own thread for more personalized answers though.