BEST 1L HORNBOOKS?
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 5:25 pm
Could anyone share their opinions on best hornbooks for a 1L student - civ pro, criminal, tort, property, etc?
Law School Discussion Forums
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=113729
thanks, what about criminal, property, constitutional?MeTalkPrettyOneDay wrote:Civ Pro - Glannon (the Examples & Explanations series)
Torts - Glannon (the Examples & Explanations series). If you don't like E&E, try Abraham's "The Forms and Functions of Tort Law"
Contracts - Chirelstein. (Don't bother with the E&E for Ks. I think I derived negative utility from the Ks E&E. It was more a waste of time than anything. But Chirelstein is awesome.)
You'll only use the first 300 in ConLaw I. You save money by not needing to buy another hornbook when you take ConLaw II (or III, if your school offers it)MeTalkPrettyOneDay wrote:Dressler and Chemerinsky are both good suggestions. Yes, the Chemerinsky book is nearly 1,200 pages, but it's very, very good.
Haha, I wish... we've covered way more than that...Leeroy Jenkins wrote:You'll only use the first 300 in ConLaw I. You save money by not needing to buy another hornbook when you take ConLaw II (or III, if your school offers it)MeTalkPrettyOneDay wrote:Dressler and Chemerinsky are both good suggestions. Yes, the Chemerinsky book is nearly 1,200 pages, but it's very, very good.
Fair point. I assumed OP meant E&Es and other supplements, but I may have misinterpreted his question. OP, if you're looking for textbook-style policy discussions, the books we've suggested aren't what you want (except Chemerinsky, maybe). If you're looking for supplements that will save you time and fill in broad gaps in your casebook, then the above suggestions are spot-on.Renzo wrote:I wouldn't call any of the things suggested thus far "hornbooks."
You're an evil person.T14_Scholly wrote:In order to succeed as a 1L, you should read all of the above-mentioned books during your 0L summer.
All law schools only assign casebooks, but that's because they are trying to make it hard on you to figure out what's going on.APHill wrote:i am looking for a supplement that will save me time and fill broad gaps...what is the difference between hornbook and textbook? is a casebook considered a textbook?
In my ls they only assign required casebooks, but thats it.
Hornbooks are one volume treatises written primarily for law students on subjects typically covered by law school courses. Unlike casebooks, which are collections of cases (or parts of cases) chosen to help illustrate and stimulate discussion about legal issues, hornbooks attempt to summarize and explain the law in a specific area. Perhaps the best-known hornbooks are those published by West in "West's Hornbook Series," which are easily identifiable by their distinctive green bindings and include titles such as Civil Procedure by Professors Friedenthal, Kane and Miller, and Uniform Commercial Code by Professors White and Summers.
Study guides such as West's Nutshell Series and Black Letter Series, and Aspen Publisher's Examples and Explanations Series, also try to explain the law in a much more straightforward manner than casebooks. Study guides, though, are written in a less scholarly manner than hornbooks and tend to focus on the basic issues without providing detailed analysis. For example, hornbooks are often heavily footnoted, whereas many study guides do not contain any footnotes at all.
i am actually planning to....a guy from Loyola U Chicago did this and he says he was top 1% during 1L.T14_Scholly wrote:In order to succeed as a 1L, you should read all of the above-mentioned books during your 0L summer.
APHill wrote:i am actually planning to....a guy from Loyola U Chicago did this and he says he was top 1% during 1L.T14_Scholly wrote:In order to succeed as a 1L, you should read all of the above-mentioned books during your 0L summer.
--ImageRemoved--DallasCowboy wrote:GUNNER
thats like the exact image of me, t-shirt and all, wow, how did you know.kissy wrote:--ImageRemoved--DallasCowboy wrote:GUNNER
I'll take his word for it.APHill wrote:i am actually planning to....a guy from Loyola U Chicago did this and he says he was top 1% during 1L.T14_Scholly wrote:In order to succeed as a 1L, you should read all of the above-mentioned books during your 0L summer.
which exact one for property? he has several...vanwinkle wrote:Civ Pro - Glannon (E&E)
Contracts - Chirelstein
Torts - Abraham
Con Law - Chemerinsky
Property - Singer
I don't have a favorite study guide for Crim Law because I ended up using a commercial outline written by my prof, and I think it was useful more because it was written by my prof than anything. I liked it but I'm not sure it'd be useful for anyone else.