Page 103 of 108

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Mon Apr 25, 2016 7:00 pm
by cannibal ox
I'll echo ManoftheHour here. I double deposited and informed both schools. Got a small bump from school A, took it to school B, got a large bump from school B, withdrew from school A in an email, school A replied to that email and asked if more money would get me to attend. Ended up at school B because that was my #1 choice.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Mon Apr 25, 2016 8:03 pm
by PrayFor170
ManoftheHour wrote:
jlaw20161 wrote:Can anyone give me some insight on negotiations after making a seat deposit?

Once I deposit at one school, does this mean my other scholarship offers are effectively off the table for negotiation purposes? Can schools even tell whether or not I've made deposits anywhere else?

Thanks!
I didn't make my final decision until June. I had deposited at two schools, signed a lease for an apartment and found roommates at one of them. Check the school's policy (the paper they make you sign when you make your first deposit). If the language of it doesn't mention that you can't have multiple deposits or it just discourages you from doing so, then go for it.

Schools can't tell whether you made a deposit until after a certain date. I think it was in May or something. I had deposited at 2 schools by then (both first deposits) and as the second deposit dates were looming, one of the schools (Let's call it school A) reached out to me and told me that I had deposited at 2 schools and that I should tell the other school that I'm not going. lol. I then emailed school A and said I was still considering both schools and that a scholly bump would nudge me in one direction. School A called me, answered a few questions, and gave me a $15k bump. I then emailed School B and told them what happened with School A. I told them I was still undecided. School B bumped up their scholly to full ride and then some. I told School A about my other offer. They let me walk.
Technically you can deposit at two schools until June??I'm thinking of doing that since I still haven't decided.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Mon Apr 25, 2016 8:46 pm
by TheKisSquared
PrayFor170 wrote:
ManoftheHour wrote:
jlaw20161 wrote:Can anyone give me some insight on negotiations after making a seat deposit?

Once I deposit at one school, does this mean my other scholarship offers are effectively off the table for negotiation purposes? Can schools even tell whether or not I've made deposits anywhere else?

Thanks!
I didn't make my final decision until June. I had deposited at two schools, signed a lease for an apartment and found roommates at one of them. Check the school's policy (the paper they make you sign when you make your first deposit). If the language of it doesn't mention that you can't have multiple deposits or it just discourages you from doing so, then go for it.

Schools can't tell whether you made a deposit until after a certain date. I think it was in May or something. I had deposited at 2 schools by then (both first deposits) and as the second deposit dates were looming, one of the schools (Let's call it school A) reached out to me and told me that I had deposited at 2 schools and that I should tell the other school that I'm not going. lol. I then emailed school A and said I was still considering both schools and that a scholly bump would nudge me in one direction. School A called me, answered a few questions, and gave me a $15k bump. I then emailed School B and told them what happened with School A. I told them I was still undecided. School B bumped up their scholly to full ride and then some. I told School A about my other offer. They let me walk.
Technically you can deposit at two schools until June??I'm thinking of doing that since I still haven't decided.
Read the specific schools' deposit guidelines carefully. Some schools reserve the right to revoke admission if you do this.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2016 1:21 am
by ManoftheHour
TheKisSquared wrote: Read the specific schools' deposit guidelines carefully. Some schools reserve the right to revoke admission if you do this.
I second this. READ the thing you are signing.

ETA: Also, note that Ox and I both notified both schools. It's not as if we both blindly double deposited (second deposits) and then negotiated.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2016 1:29 am
by ManoftheHour
PrayFor170 wrote: Technically you can deposit at two schools until June??I'm thinking of doing that since I still haven't decided.
To clarify: For me, the 2nd deposit for both schools was looming. This was around May. School A had contacted me, upped my scholly. I DID NOT send a second deposit for School B but I notified them of my offer for School A but told School B that I was still very interested (you know, if they would splash the cash). School B took a while but eventually gave me more. In the meantime, I had sent in a second deposit for School A. It was only until in June that School B contacted me and upped their offer that I ended up there.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 3:39 pm
by marisacb1012
Need some negotiation help!
I deposited at BU and have 30K in scholarship per year (25K merit, 5K need). I asked for more from BU before the deadline and they said no, but I still deposited. After the deposit deadline, I got an unsolicited offer from Tulane. I had denied their acceptance and not deposited there, but they emailed me offering 40K/year and an extension till May 1st to decide.
I sent the offer to BU basically saying I know BU is right for me/a more prestigious school with better outcomes/etc, but I went to Tulane for undergrad and still live in New Orleans so I have a considerable professional network here/cost of living is way lower/the offer is proving quite tempting. BU said they'd contact me if and when funds become available.
Should I email BU again stating that Tulane gave me till May 1 to decide, but I'm coming up on the deadline and need to know? Is this a situation where I should tell BU "if you give me X, I'll deny Tulane now and place my 2nd BU deposit?" or should I just let BU take their time and not press them further?
Thanks!

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 3:42 pm
by TheKisSquared
marisacb1012 wrote:Need some negotiation help!
I deposited at BU and have 30K in scholarship per year (25K merit, 5K need). I asked for more from BU before the deadline and they said no, but I still deposited. After the deposit deadline, I got an unsolicited offer from Tulane. I had denied their acceptance and not deposited there, but they emailed me offering 40K/year and an extension till May 1st to decide.
I sent the offer to BU basically saying I know BU is right for me/a more prestigious school with better outcomes/etc, but I went to Tulane for undergrad and still live in New Orleans so I have a considerable professional network here/cost of living is way lower/the offer is proving quite tempting. BU said they'd contact me if and when funds become available.
Should I email BU again stating that Tulane gave me till May 1 to decide, but I'm coming up on the deadline and need to know? Is this a situation where I should tell BU "if you give me X, I'll deny Tulane now and place my 2nd BU deposit?" or should I just let BU take their time and not press them further?
Thanks!
if they are not already aware of the deadline, you should absolutely politely let them know. I think if it's been >week it would be fine to follow up and remind them of the deadline.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 4:06 pm
by marisacb1012
TheKisSquared wrote:
marisacb1012 wrote:Need some negotiation help!
I deposited at BU and have 30K in scholarship per year (25K merit, 5K need). I asked for more from BU before the deadline and they said no, but I still deposited. After the deposit deadline, I got an unsolicited offer from Tulane. I had denied their acceptance and not deposited there, but they emailed me offering 40K/year and an extension till May 1st to decide.
I sent the offer to BU basically saying I know BU is right for me/a more prestigious school with better outcomes/etc, but I went to Tulane for undergrad and still live in New Orleans so I have a considerable professional network here/cost of living is way lower/the offer is proving quite tempting. BU said they'd contact me if and when funds become available.
Should I email BU again stating that Tulane gave me till May 1 to decide, but I'm coming up on the deadline and need to know? Is this a situation where I should tell BU "if you give me X, I'll deny Tulane now and place my 2nd BU deposit?" or should I just let BU take their time and not press them further?
Thanks!
if they are not already aware of the deadline, you should absolutely politely let them know. I think if it's been >week it would be fine to follow up and remind them of the deadline.
They don't know about the deadline, and it's been 6 days since my original ask. Should I follow up stating the deadline and ask for a specific amount to seal the deal? Or just gently state the deadline.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 4:19 pm
by wilt
.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 4:37 pm
by Stardust84
For anyone who on this thread and is wondering about negotiating a scholarship on the basis of an LSAT retake after already being admitted, you can add my success to the anecdotes. Raised my LSAT 5 points in Feb after getting admitted in December. Emailed the school in March and went from half to full scholarship.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 4:50 pm
by TheKisSquared
marisacb1012 wrote:
TheKisSquared wrote:
marisacb1012 wrote:Need some negotiation help!
I deposited at BU and have 30K in scholarship per year (25K merit, 5K need). I asked for more from BU before the deadline and they said no, but I still deposited. After the deposit deadline, I got an unsolicited offer from Tulane. I had denied their acceptance and not deposited there, but they emailed me offering 40K/year and an extension till May 1st to decide.
I sent the offer to BU basically saying I know BU is right for me/a more prestigious school with better outcomes/etc, but I went to Tulane for undergrad and still live in New Orleans so I have a considerable professional network here/cost of living is way lower/the offer is proving quite tempting. BU said they'd contact me if and when funds become available.
Should I email BU again stating that Tulane gave me till May 1 to decide, but I'm coming up on the deadline and need to know? Is this a situation where I should tell BU "if you give me X, I'll deny Tulane now and place my 2nd BU deposit?" or should I just let BU take their time and not press them further?
Thanks!
if they are not already aware of the deadline, you should absolutely politely let them know. I think if it's been >week it would be fine to follow up and remind them of the deadline.
They don't know about the deadline, and it's been 6 days since my original ask. Should I follow up stating the deadline and ask for a specific amount to seal the deal? Or just gently state the deadline.
tell them the deadline and that $x would cause you to commit immediately. You can be polite but firm.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jun 01, 2016 2:42 pm
by hunt godlink
Anyone have suggestions on how one should go about asking for a second scholarship increase after the school approves the first request? Examples via PM would be much appreciated! :D

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jun 01, 2016 4:27 pm
by Nachoo2019
hunt godlink wrote:Anyone have suggestions on how one should go about asking for a second scholarship increase after the school approves the first request? Examples via PM would be much appreciated! :D

What schools do you have offers from? What are those offers? We will need more info to give you the right advice

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Tue Jun 07, 2016 5:25 am
by wilt
.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Mon Jan 16, 2017 4:13 pm
by bmathers
Can anyone post an example letter, or describe the format that you used in a successful negotiation? I have a few different schools that I need to start negotiating between. Thanks!

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Mon Jan 16, 2017 5:02 pm
by airwrecka
Stardust84 wrote:For anyone who on this thread and is wondering about negotiating a scholarship on the basis of an LSAT retake after already being admitted, you can add my success to the anecdotes. Raised my LSAT 5 points in Feb after getting admitted in December. Emailed the school in March and went from half to full scholarship.
this makes me SO happy I registered for the Feb LSAT!! hoping I can get some good news like this :D

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2017 11:06 am
by taxman14
airwrecka wrote:
Stardust84 wrote:For anyone who on this thread and is wondering about negotiating a scholarship on the basis of an LSAT retake after already being admitted, you can add my success to the anecdotes. Raised my LSAT 5 points in Feb after getting admitted in December. Emailed the school in March and went from half to full scholarship.
this makes me SO happy I registered for the Feb LSAT!! hoping I can get some good news like this :D
you got this ;)

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Tue Jan 24, 2017 7:15 pm
by Ashleighjarm
How many spots can you go for "similarly ranked?" I.E. I have a full ride offer at a school ranked 4-5 spots lower than a half-tuition offer at my top choice. The higher school said they will reconsider offers in comparison to "similarly ranked." Do you think this is close enough to get anything more?

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 2:43 pm
by waldorf
To those who received responses, how long did it take after your initial email to receive a response?

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 2:50 pm
by waldorf
Also - did you guys email admissions office or financial aid office?

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 2:56 pm
by glockov
Is trying to get an increase in scholarship from a school that I got into ED an exercise in futility?

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 4:34 pm
by JordanLaw15
So I need some advice por favor... I have been accepted to 3 schools so far. A school in the 50-60 range that gave me a full scholarship, a school in the 15-20 range that gave me over half tuition scholarship, and a t14 school that I've been accepted to but haven't heard received scholarship info yet. Could I ask the top 20 school for an increase or should I wait to see what the t14 school gives me first before I start negotiating?

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 4:50 pm
by Charlie802
sjs12 wrote:Also - did you guys email admissions office or financial aid office?

Admissions office. They will get it to who it needs to go to. If you have an email for the person who signed your scholarship letter, I would send it to them and cc the general admissions email. I've gotten replies on every negotiation email I've sent using this method.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 4:52 pm
by Charlie802
sjs12 wrote:To those who received responses, how long did it take after your initial email to receive a response?
Two schools replied within 12 hours, one wrote back within a week. All indicated I would be waiting until feb/March for a decision.

Re: Negotiating scholarships works!!!!!

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 5:41 pm
by mrtux45
Is it more effective to wait until you receive an initial scholarship offer before notifying schools about competing scholarships from peer schools?

I'm guessing I'll know where I stand across the board by March, but I've already received good offers from some schools. My gut tells me to wait for an initial offer before reaching out, what's consensus?