Page 1 of 1
Weaken Questions
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2016 4:03 pm
by WeightliftingThinker
I am noticing a pattern where choices that refer to the majority ("most," "majority," etc.) are wrong, but not always.
Is this because those choices tend to overlook the minority, which can strengthen/stay neutral instead of weaken the argument?
Re: Weaken Questions
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2016 5:22 pm
by Deardevil
Not sure if relevant...
For weaken questions, you just need to ask yourself if each choice weakens;
either it does weaken, instead strengthens, or brings absolutely nothing to the stimulus.
Re: Weaken Questions
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2016 10:35 pm
by WeightliftingThinker
Deardevil wrote:Not sure if relevant...
For weaken questions, you just need to ask yourself if each choice weakens;
either it does weaken, instead strengthens, or brings absolutely nothing to the stimulus.
I recognize that. I was wondering if there is a pattern comparable to Assumption questions, where choices that have "most" or "majority" are usually irrelevant. For instance, some correct Assumption choices have the phrase "at least." I believe this is the case because you do not need "most" of whatever it is in the argument to make the point.
Re: Weaken Questions
Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2016 3:24 pm
by Deardevil
Well, if we're talking about assumptions, that's not entirely true.
For NA, "most" may seem extreme. However, for SA, "majority" or "all" can often lead to the right answer;
the same can be said for strengthen and weaken questions, as noticed from my recent drilling.
Conversely, "some" in the aforementioned does not tend to indicate strong strengtheners or weakeners.