Dynamic Reviews on LSAT Material: Trainer, Manhattan, Cambridge, Powerscore
Posted: Thu Jul 16, 2015 6:25 am
So I've got other threads where I've confessed to maniacal investments in all this study material. You can judge, but it's my own cross to bear.
LSAT Trainer: I started with this book first since it's all the rave everywhere (Amazon, TLS, 7Sage, etc.). I got to about Ch. 13 before work burned me out and I had to pause. I felt I was learning with the Trainer, but at the slowest pace. The reviews insinuate that you will instantly understand every single concept, but it's not the case. It does have you thinking differently...it just takes a while for you to realize what you will end up doing with those new thoughts. The Trainer is very verbose.
Who needs it: The student who needs this book cannot just take a "do this problem" concept. He needs to know the Five Ws, along with the Three Blind Mice, and the History of Cats. In that order. The Trainer provides all those answers and then some.
Who doesn't need it: 1) Someone with "forest" mindset. This person might get a bit tired of the constant problem drills inside the Trainer. 2) Someone testing "any day now". The drills might make a student feel as if he's not learning much (even though he is!).
Powerscore Bibles/Logic Games: I transitioned to this book after getting to about Ch. 15 of the Trainer. First thing I loved was how quick I went through the chapters. Thanks to the Trainer of course! The LG Bible has less words, and more "real world" drills, so finishing a chapter was a short order. It took me a week to get through the LG Bible...still haven't finished the Trainer.
Who Needs It: Did you go +5 on your diagnostic? Not a puzzles person? Feel that the LG section was made only for smart people? Go ahead and grab this book. I felt the LG Bible made the games less scary, where the Trainer doesn't. I think the Trainer even references wax on-wax off from "The Karate Kid". That's my point. Wax for what? I'm tired of waxing!!!
Who doesn't need it: Folks whom have a more than elementary skill level for the Games need a different book. Getting the Bible will (IMO) just delay your advancement to what you truly need.
Cambridge Drills LG & LR by Type, 1-38: Problem sets sectioned by types and difficulty levels. Sold via PDF to allow ample printing and drilling opportunities. I got these drills because 180 or bust, right? I printed it off and put a blank cover over the sheets. I can do these problems anywhere without someone asking me what it is. Working these problems this way let me focus specifically on the types of games and sections. I wasn't worried about difficulty level as much as just doing the same types of problems over and over. Cambridge allows that. And it also lets you save your real games for the tests.
Who Needs It: Anyone who's scoring in the 150s or lower during diagnostics. How do you get into Carnegie Hall? Practice, practice, practice.
Who Doesn't Need It: Those already advanced in their studying that could either use a refresher bootcamp such as the Trainer, or straight Prep Tests such as 52 - 74.
Manhattan Prep LSAT LR: I didn't feel confident after completing the LG Bible and LR Bible was...boring. I purchased both the Manhattan and Cambridge Drills at about the same time since it's highly recommended in the threads. I DEFINITELY should have purchased Manhattan first and foremost! I can't believe I'm actually excited about working in this book. It gives the Five Ws immediately and tests you and your new skills right away. It's also less verbose than the Trainer, while still keeping some of the personable conversation and humor within the book.
Who Needs It: Everybody does. If you feel you were always a good student, and yet the LSAT kind of stumps you, this book will clear up any confusion. Again, this is for the student beginning his studies.
Who Doesn't Need It: The advanced student. If you've already gone through the Bibles or other materials, and need to push your levels from 170 and up, you would probably need the trainer to fine tune what it is you're missing.
These are just my opinions, which hopefully I'll come back to update periodically. If you're just starting your studies for the December LSAT, go ahead and get the Manhattan Prep, along with drills and newer tests. In my opinion, that will be all you need.
LSAT Trainer: I started with this book first since it's all the rave everywhere (Amazon, TLS, 7Sage, etc.). I got to about Ch. 13 before work burned me out and I had to pause. I felt I was learning with the Trainer, but at the slowest pace. The reviews insinuate that you will instantly understand every single concept, but it's not the case. It does have you thinking differently...it just takes a while for you to realize what you will end up doing with those new thoughts. The Trainer is very verbose.
Who needs it: The student who needs this book cannot just take a "do this problem" concept. He needs to know the Five Ws, along with the Three Blind Mice, and the History of Cats. In that order. The Trainer provides all those answers and then some.
Who doesn't need it: 1) Someone with "forest" mindset. This person might get a bit tired of the constant problem drills inside the Trainer. 2) Someone testing "any day now". The drills might make a student feel as if he's not learning much (even though he is!).
Powerscore Bibles/Logic Games: I transitioned to this book after getting to about Ch. 15 of the Trainer. First thing I loved was how quick I went through the chapters. Thanks to the Trainer of course! The LG Bible has less words, and more "real world" drills, so finishing a chapter was a short order. It took me a week to get through the LG Bible...still haven't finished the Trainer.
Who Needs It: Did you go +5 on your diagnostic? Not a puzzles person? Feel that the LG section was made only for smart people? Go ahead and grab this book. I felt the LG Bible made the games less scary, where the Trainer doesn't. I think the Trainer even references wax on-wax off from "The Karate Kid". That's my point. Wax for what? I'm tired of waxing!!!
Who doesn't need it: Folks whom have a more than elementary skill level for the Games need a different book. Getting the Bible will (IMO) just delay your advancement to what you truly need.
Cambridge Drills LG & LR by Type, 1-38: Problem sets sectioned by types and difficulty levels. Sold via PDF to allow ample printing and drilling opportunities. I got these drills because 180 or bust, right? I printed it off and put a blank cover over the sheets. I can do these problems anywhere without someone asking me what it is. Working these problems this way let me focus specifically on the types of games and sections. I wasn't worried about difficulty level as much as just doing the same types of problems over and over. Cambridge allows that. And it also lets you save your real games for the tests.
Who Needs It: Anyone who's scoring in the 150s or lower during diagnostics. How do you get into Carnegie Hall? Practice, practice, practice.
Who Doesn't Need It: Those already advanced in their studying that could either use a refresher bootcamp such as the Trainer, or straight Prep Tests such as 52 - 74.
Manhattan Prep LSAT LR: I didn't feel confident after completing the LG Bible and LR Bible was...boring. I purchased both the Manhattan and Cambridge Drills at about the same time since it's highly recommended in the threads. I DEFINITELY should have purchased Manhattan first and foremost! I can't believe I'm actually excited about working in this book. It gives the Five Ws immediately and tests you and your new skills right away. It's also less verbose than the Trainer, while still keeping some of the personable conversation and humor within the book.
Who Needs It: Everybody does. If you feel you were always a good student, and yet the LSAT kind of stumps you, this book will clear up any confusion. Again, this is for the student beginning his studies.
Who Doesn't Need It: The advanced student. If you've already gone through the Bibles or other materials, and need to push your levels from 170 and up, you would probably need the trainer to fine tune what it is you're missing.
These are just my opinions, which hopefully I'll come back to update periodically. If you're just starting your studies for the December LSAT, go ahead and get the Manhattan Prep, along with drills and newer tests. In my opinion, that will be all you need.