Causal Weaken Question
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:32 pm
Test 56 Section 4 Q20
20) Newspaper Article: People who take vitamin C supplements tend to be healthier than average. This was shown by a study investigation the relationship between high doses of vitamin C and heart disease, which show that people who regularly consumed high does of vitamin C supplement have a significantly lower than average risk of heart disease.
My answer choice was B: The reduction in risk of heart disease due to the consumption of vitamin C is no greater than the reduction due to certain other dietary changes.
The correct answer was D: High doses of vitamin C supplements tend to reduce slightly one's resistance to certain common infectious diseases.
Though D was a contender for me I went with B because of the reasoning behind causality (LRB: If a stated cause is said to lead to an effect the author believes that is the only cause that could lead to that effect).
Answer choice B provided another cause that led to the same effect which to me seemed like an effective way to weaken it.
Any help on clarifying why my reasoning was incorrect?
20) Newspaper Article: People who take vitamin C supplements tend to be healthier than average. This was shown by a study investigation the relationship between high doses of vitamin C and heart disease, which show that people who regularly consumed high does of vitamin C supplement have a significantly lower than average risk of heart disease.
My answer choice was B: The reduction in risk of heart disease due to the consumption of vitamin C is no greater than the reduction due to certain other dietary changes.
The correct answer was D: High doses of vitamin C supplements tend to reduce slightly one's resistance to certain common infectious diseases.
Though D was a contender for me I went with B because of the reasoning behind causality (LRB: If a stated cause is said to lead to an effect the author believes that is the only cause that could lead to that effect).
Answer choice B provided another cause that led to the same effect which to me seemed like an effective way to weaken it.
Any help on clarifying why my reasoning was incorrect?