I swear, these questions are just huge mind f*cks. I'm simply not understand why the other answers are even wrong and why the right one is even right. I've done 100 of them for drilling and there hasn't been any progress. I keep getting only 50% of them correct, and most of the time, I'm not even sure why I'm getting them right.
Any advice? I keep re-reading the Bibles, but it doesn't seem to be helping that much...
Also, I'm using Manhattan Explanations and not even the explanations are making much sense to me. Geez...
Notaznguy - Strengthen and Assumption questions used to be two of my weakest LR question types as well, until I re-read the PowerScore chapters on the two - now I consider them two of my strengths. A HUGE part, and what I think of lot of the responses above may be missing, of understanding Assumption questions is understanding its difference from a Justify the Conclusion question, so I'll try to chime in on that as well. Understanding the following helped me:
Strengthen - simply put, your focus is on the actual conclusion, that's it. One of the answers is going to strengthen the actual conclusion, and the other four will either weaken the conclusion or
do nothing at all.
Justify the Conclusion - in Justify questions, the argument is going to be missing something (invalid). Lets say that the premise is A, and the conclusion is C. The correct answer in the answer choices will be the bridge (premise B) that links the two and makes the argument valid. This is why it is almost impossible to truly prephrase a Justify question with 100% certainty because this leaves a myriad of choices. Take the following for example (I'm making this question up so hopefully I don't miss something):
"All 300 pound football players are linemen. Therefore, Chris must be a lineman."
All the correct answer has to do is add ANY premise that makes this conclusion valid. All the following are correct answer choices:
"Chris is a 300 pound football player from Kentucky"
"Chris loves to play badminton and is a 300 pound football player"
"Chris has never played rugby, loves number 2's from McDonalds, does yoga, is getting married on Saturday, has a ridiculous bellyflop, is a world champion Mario Kart player, and oh by the way - he's a 300 pound football player"
Believe it or not, these ALL are correct because they contain one key thing "Chris is a 300 pound football player".
This brings us to the HUGE difference between this and Assumptions.
Assumption - the way I understand assumption questions is that what I am looking for is the absolute
bare minimum that will make the conclusion valid - nothing else. Notaznguy this is the subtle, but absolutely HUGE, difference between this and Justify questions that I believe will truly help you out. Let's take the example from above:
"All 300 pound football players are linemen. Therefore, Chris must be a lineman."
The difference between this and Justify questions is that as far as Assumptions go there is only ONE answer to this question. There is one thing that can make the conclusion valid and all other things are wrong. The correct answer here is:
"Chris is a 300 pound football player"
The
incorrect answers are (and these are the exact type of answers the LSAT will try to throw you off with):
"Chris is a 300 pound football player from Kentucky"
"Chris loves to play badminton and is a 300 pound football player"
"Chris has never played rugby, loves number 2's from McDonald's, does yoga, is getting married on Saturday, has a ridiculous bellyflop, is a world champion Mario Kart player, and oh by the way - he's a 300 pound football player"
The difference is that for "Chris to be a lineman" it's not
assumed Chris is from Kentucky, loves badminton, number 2 from McDonald's or any of that other stuff. The only thing that is assumed is that "Chris is a 300 pound football player". That is the
bare minimum needed to make the conclusion valid.
I apologize for being long-winded, but I truly hope this helps because understanding this resulted in a huge breakthrough for me.