Unfortunately, I don't have a specific test question as an example -- so I'll have to explain a hypothetical. If you have a parallel reasoning question in which the reasoning structure of the question stem and one of the answer choice matches up, but the only difference is one makes a positive conclusion, while the other makes a negative conclusion, do you think the answer choice would still be correct?
Ex: Question stem has cause + effect reasoning and has a conclusion that something is true; answer choice has cause + effect reasoning and has a conclusion that something is NOT true.
Could the reasoning in this question stem/answer-choice be considered parallel?
Can negative and positive reasoning be parallel? Forum
-
ihaslsats
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2011 12:59 pm
-
suspicious android
- Posts: 919
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 4:54 pm
Re: Can negative and positive reasoning be parallel?
Postive and negative terms are just facts, they don't necessarily change the logical structure of a passage.
A --> B ---> C, therefore A --> C
~X --> Y ---> ~Z, therefore ~X --> ~Z
Those two arguments are parallel, they arrive at their conclusion via the same method of reasoning.
However, in the particular instance you mention, I don't think the argument would be parallel, though I'd have to see the actual argument to be sure. Since the crucial part of one of the arguments is that a causal connection exists, but the other argument concludes a causal connection doesn't exist, those are different argument methods.
A --> B ---> C, therefore A --> C
~X --> Y ---> ~Z, therefore ~X --> ~Z
Those two arguments are parallel, they arrive at their conclusion via the same method of reasoning.
However, in the particular instance you mention, I don't think the argument would be parallel, though I'd have to see the actual argument to be sure. Since the crucial part of one of the arguments is that a causal connection exists, but the other argument concludes a causal connection doesn't exist, those are different argument methods.
-
vanwinkle
- Posts: 8953
- Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2008 3:02 am
Re: Can negative and positive reasoning be parallel?
Banned for alting.ihaslsats wrote:Unfortunately, I don't have a specific test question as an example -- so I'll have to explain a hypothetical. If you have a parallel reasoning question in which the reasoning structure of the question stem and one of the answer choice matches up, but the only difference is one makes a positive conclusion, while the other makes a negative conclusion, do you think the answer choice would still be correct?
Ex: Question stem has cause + effect reasoning and has a conclusion that something is true; answer choice has cause + effect reasoning and has a conclusion that something is NOT true.
Could the reasoning in this question stem/answer-choice be considered parallel?
