Top Law Schools

Seemed like that one clearly had two acceptable answers...

schark1234 wrote:Seemed like that one clearly had two acceptable answers...

elaborate a little, please?

Want to be careful not to risk anything so I'll stay as general as I can. Cardiologists, computers, predicting stuff...

That enough?

schark1234 wrote:Want to be careful not to risk anything so I'll stay as general as I can. Cardiologists, computers, predicting stuff...

That enough?

enough, precessing...

I don't think it had two answers.

schark1234 wrote:Seemed like that one clearly had two acceptable answers...

It seemed to at first, but once you looked back at the stimulus and thought about it, the other "possible" AC became 1000% wrong.

I remember having tons of troubles with this question...can anyone give hints on which choice was correct?

the answer was REALLY subtle and remember that there was explicit info into the experience of such said person.

WonkyPanda wrote:the answer was REALLY subtle and remember that there was explicit info into the experience of such said person.

Exactly.

.

DANGIT

so was the AC about him being an outcast amongst peers not the right one?

or?

sangr wrote:DANGIT

so was the AC about him being an outcast amongst peers not the right one?

or?

Sadly, it was not correct.

[quote="Ragged"]I remembered several questions alot like that one from previous LSATs so the question was quite easy for .

ThreeYears wrote:

Ragged wrote:I remembered several questions alot like that one from previous LSATs so the question was quite easy for .

..

I believe the stimulus mentioned something specific about this particular cardiologist's experience that killed a few of the answer choices.

cowgirl_bebop wrote:

sangr wrote:DANGIT

so was the AC about him being an outcast amongst peers not the right one?

or?

Sadly, it was not correct.

Well, that leaves 3 other wrong options I could have fallen for. I can't even remember what the other answer choices were or what I picked off the top of my head.

WonkyPanda wrote:the answer was REALLY subtle and remember that there was explicit info into the experience of such said person.

I have to disagree. This question had one correct answer and it was quite clear which one it was.

AverageTutoring wrote:

WonkyPanda wrote:the answer was REALLY subtle and remember that there was explicit info into the experience of such said person.

I have to disagree. This question had one correct answer and it was quite clear which one it was.

What he means by "subtle" is that there were only 2 choices that were in the ballpark of being correct, however when you realized that experience couldn't have played a role, there is only one choice left. Of course there was "one correct answer," nobody said there were 2 did they?

mnaqvi wrote:

AverageTutoring wrote:

WonkyPanda wrote:the answer was REALLY subtle and remember that there was explicit info into the experience of such said person.

I have to disagree. This question had one correct answer and it was quite clear which one it was.

What he means by "subtle" is that there were only 2 choices that were in the ballpark of being correct, however when you realized that experience couldn't have played a role, there is only one choice left. Of course there was "one correct answer," nobody said there were 2 did they?

you win e-peen points! +2

WonkyPanda wrote:

mnaqvi wrote:

AverageTutoring wrote:

WonkyPanda wrote:the answer was REALLY subtle and remember that there was explicit info into the experience of such said person.

I have to disagree. This question had one correct answer and it was quite clear which one it was.

What he means by "subtle" is that there were only 2 choices that were in the ballpark of being correct, however when you realized that experience couldn't have played a role, there is only one choice left. Of course there was "one correct answer," nobody said there were 2 did they?

you win e-peen points! +2

Damn, second post and already +2 points? I have a bright future ahead of me.

WonkyPanda wrote:

mnaqvi wrote:

AverageTutoring wrote:

WonkyPanda wrote:the answer was REALLY subtle and remember that there was explicit info into the experience of such said person.

I have to disagree. This question had one correct answer and it was quite clear which one it was.

What he means by "subtle" is that there were only 2 choices that were in the ballpark of being correct, however when you realized that experience couldn't have played a role, there is only one choice left. Of course there was "one correct answer," nobody said there were 2 did they?

you win e-peen points! +2

WonkyPanad's previous post commits which one of the following errors

A) treats a lack of evidence of a particular result as evidence that the result is false
B) incorrectly uses the word subtle
C) relies on an unwarrented assumption that Nazi's flew birds into large buildings
D) supposes what it sets out to establish
E) he had sex with a goat

Your question is clearly missing an 'all of the above' a/c that would correctly define the situation. Thus, your question would more than likely be removed from scoring.

WonkyPanda wrote:Your question is clearly missing an 'all of the above' a/c that would correctly define the situation. Thus, your question would more than likely be removed from scoring.

I had E as the credited response

AverageTutoring wrote:

WonkyPanda wrote:Your question is clearly missing an 'all of the above' a/c that would correctly define the situation. Thus, your question would more than likely be removed from scoring.

I had E as the credited response

If it's any consolation, that would be the one i'd go with after debating between E and C.

I don't remember this one, which means it was probably easy.

[Mod Note: I also remember that I was previously temp-banned for LSAT discussion and will not test the limits of the policy again.]

Dirty mods...