PT 38 Section 2 Question 12 - INSIGHT WANTED??
Posted: Wed Aug 04, 2010 7:54 pm
Game reads as follows:
Each of six tasks - harvesting, milling, plowing, spinning, threshing, and weaving - will be demonstrated exactly once at a farm exhibition. No two tasks will be demonstrated concurrently. Three volunteers - Frank, Gladys, and Leslie - will each demonstrate exactly two of the tasks. The tasks must be demonstrated in accordance with the following conditions:
Frank demonstrates exactly one task before Gladys demonstrates any of the tasks.
Frank performs neither the first nor the last demonstration.
Gladys demonstrates neither harvesting nor milling.
Leslie demonstrates neither harvesting nor threshing.
Milling is the next task demonstrated after threshing is demonstrated.
12. Which one of the following must be true?
(a) Frank performs the second demonstration.
(b) Gladys performs the fourth demonstration.
(c) Gladys performs the sixth demonstration.
(d) Leslie performs the first demonstration
(e) Leslie performs the second demonstration
I would greatly appreciate it if someone would explain why the answer to question 12 is D and not A. I see why it must be true that Leslie performs the first demonstration (Frank cannot go first and F has to go at least once before G performs any demonstration). However, it seems to me that A must be true as well seeing how the first person must always be Leslie, G cannot perform her first demonstration before F, and not two tasks may be performed concurrently [i.e. - no L-L]. Therefore, F must perform second after Leslie performs first. Right?
Each of six tasks - harvesting, milling, plowing, spinning, threshing, and weaving - will be demonstrated exactly once at a farm exhibition. No two tasks will be demonstrated concurrently. Three volunteers - Frank, Gladys, and Leslie - will each demonstrate exactly two of the tasks. The tasks must be demonstrated in accordance with the following conditions:
Frank demonstrates exactly one task before Gladys demonstrates any of the tasks.
Frank performs neither the first nor the last demonstration.
Gladys demonstrates neither harvesting nor milling.
Leslie demonstrates neither harvesting nor threshing.
Milling is the next task demonstrated after threshing is demonstrated.
12. Which one of the following must be true?
(a) Frank performs the second demonstration.
(b) Gladys performs the fourth demonstration.
(c) Gladys performs the sixth demonstration.
(d) Leslie performs the first demonstration
(e) Leslie performs the second demonstration
I would greatly appreciate it if someone would explain why the answer to question 12 is D and not A. I see why it must be true that Leslie performs the first demonstration (Frank cannot go first and F has to go at least once before G performs any demonstration). However, it seems to me that A must be true as well seeing how the first person must always be Leslie, G cannot perform her first demonstration before F, and not two tasks may be performed concurrently [i.e. - no L-L]. Therefore, F must perform second after Leslie performs first. Right?