Stanford Students Taking Qs (2011-12 Edition)
Posted: Sat Dec 24, 2011 4:16 am
Older thread (Sept 09 originally) here: Stanford 1L taking questions
I figured that a new thread might be helpful, since that other one is 16 pages and over the course of 2 years. I know there are a few other SLSers on here, but I'll try to answer questions often.
These questions were from a prospective student and I thought they might be of some use to those in their decision-making process.
How did you decide on Stanford.
It was a relatively easy choice for me. I decided based on two criteria. 1) a school where I would be happy and enjoy my 3 years. 2) a school that would most easily allow me to pursue whatever I ended up wanting to pursue.
I visited ASWs/Admit Days for UChicago, UPenn, Duke, Michigan, Harvard (not ASW, but with a friend who was a 1L while visiting a friend at Harvard undergrad during spring break), Columbia, NYU, and Stanford (twice). It is hard to describe, but the students at SLS were simply much happier than those at other schools. They had more energy, were more excited about what they were doing, and were confident that they were going to be able to do whatever they wanted after graduation. I had the gut feeling of "this is where I need to be," and felt it was easy to connect with the students I met. My first visit was the week before the second quarter exams, and bar review was packed, and people did not seem crazy stressed for exams.
Full disclosure for the second criterion: I was waitlisted at YLS and HLS. So compared to the other schools (CCNMPDetc.), SLS had a big advantage. I looked at their data (there is a spreadsheet available to the SLS community that includes where all the 1Ls/2Ls/3Ls work), and it was outstanding. At that time I really was basing it by TLS standards, and it was pretty much top firms, top PI, top gov't honors programs, and top clerkships across the board. A student at the time told me that 1 or 2 people total in the fall did not have offers coming out of fall OCI. On the other hand, career people at other schools would not go into depth on their placement stats. Plenty of CLS students had V5 jobs, but it was unclear to me what happened to those not in the top half of the class. Lack of clarity to me meant that the outcomes were not what I would want. The SLS grading system makes a difference in this–those I spoke with at the time said even those with straight Ps had solid jobs lined up.
Essentially, I chose the school where I thought I would be most happy and have the best freedom to pursue what I want career-wise. Clearly this was SLS. After one quarter as a 1L, I think the career freedom absolutely feeds into the student happiness. The impact of the realization that you will be able to get a job you want even if you have less Hs than half of the class cannot be understated.
Did you have to choose between Harvard and Stanford?
Regarding SLS v HLS v YLS: I think the only thing you really need to assess is the happiness factor. You can do whatever you want coming from any of the schools, so you might as well go to the one you will enjoy for the next 3 years. Happiness means different things to different people, and only you can know what will make you happy (or unhappy) at these very distinct schools. People at SLS rubbed me the right way, and people at HLS rubbed me the wrong way, but I completely understand perhaps why other people feel the opposite after interacting with the same people.
Tons of people decide specifically between SLS v HLS with plenty coming to SLS and plenty going to HLS. I'd talk to students at both who decided between the two, and they'll be quite helpful.
I am really worried about the egregious level of debt I will be in. Any thoughts on this?
I spoke with a bunch of people (career counselors, parents, friends, etc.), and they all were more supportive of attending another top 10 school on a named full ride instead of SLS. On the contrary, my professor/mentor (HLS alum) then basically told me, "You are going to be at this school for 3 years of your short life, and you are going to be connected to that school's network and resources for the rest of that short life. Money is simply money, and perhaps you stay at a firm job for an extra year to pay it off, but you will benefit from those friendships you make and connections you have for the rest of your life. Go wherever you want, don't make it about the money." His advice prompted me to think in a longer-term perspective.
I also talked to Dean Deal about it, and she was very helpful. She also essentially said, "Follow your gut. Go where you will be happy, and success will follow. You'll be able to pay off your loans with a SLS degree easily, so if you want to come here, I recommend you follow your gut and do so!"
So basically, I'll graduate with debt equivalent to a Ferrari 458 Italia (cars are the only way I can even start to put that amount of money in perspective). I know a ton of my classmates will be in a large amount of debt as well, but they are not that worried about it. The fact that a firm job with a Aston Martin V12 Vantage salary is available makes it much easier. Even if we have to take that job that perhaps we don't love, we won't be saddled with debt for the rest of our lives. Alternatively, I know SLS has an excellent LRAP program (Dean Deal's post on her blog about it is worth reading), so if you want to do PI, you'll be fine as well.
How have you adjusted to the quarter system (I am assuming you had a semester system in undergrad)?
The first quarter is really a semester. We started at the same time as I did in undergrad (3 weeks before 2/3Ls start), and ended at about the same time (Dec 16th). So far it has been fine, most people are excited about it. What it really means is that our Property and Con law classes are shorter (aka not as much depth), and we have an entire quarter to take whatever we want in the spring. I think this will be an advantage in helping decide what we all want to pursue, in that we will have taken 5 electives (including 1 in the winter) before we have to decide where we want to work during OCI.
It is also awesome because we are in line with the rest of the university. Stanford is ranked in something like the top 5 in 18 graduate programs, and top 3 in 10 of those programs. The rest of the university has a ton of exciting opportunities, and I'm really looking forward to taking classes in other schools. SLS truly is interdisciplinary in that I will be able to take up to 10 classes outside the law school (some schools pay it lip service...Duke told me I could take a total of 2 classes outside the law school). Additionally, it means that the clinics are full-time, which is superb because you treat them like a job and don't have any other distractions during that quarter.
Ask me this question again when I am in class in May and June and I may respond otherwise...
Are you involved in student organizations this year?
I'm not sure about other law schools, but we can get involved in journals as 1Ls. Almost everyone does. I'm on the tech law review, and did blue-booking and editing last quarter. Next quarter I'll be on the board to help decide what articles we publish for next year (while doing more blue-booking and editing). I'm also on the exec board of the SLS Documentary Film Project, which is essentially a journal in the form of a documentary.
The first week of school I got involved in a joint program between the law school and the computer science department that works on legal technology (not to be confused on the law of technology, heh). I sat in on all the meetings for a project that has built an automated IP clearinghouse that saves students 25-80% on coursepacks and enables professors to more easily access new material for classes. I'll be doing projects for them next semester. Pretty much everyone gets involved in student orgs, there are a ton to choose from.
Do you live in Munger? How do you like your living accommodations?
Munger is ridiculous. I live in a 4 bedroom, and we have 4 and 1/2 bathrooms. We have 2 refrigerators for 4 people. I'll post some pics to give you a better idea. It is rather expensive, but is 2 minutes from the law school, and surrounded by palm trees (and next to the 4 story underground heated parking garage).
The best part of Munger is that it really builds the SLS community. 70% of 1Ls live there, and there are always parties/dinners/pre-bar-review-parties happening. My only complaint is that about half-way through the quarter I was desperate for a car to escape from the dreamworld for a bit. It is a wonderful bubble, but it is a bubble and sometimes you need to get out for a night to get a breath of fresh air from the world of law school.
Are you from California? I've never lived anywhere except Texas for longer than three months.
I'm from the midwest and lived in DC for 3 months and the UK for 3 months. At the beginning of the quarter, one of my professors said, "Once you see what living in California is like, you realize that you have been missing the good life." I’d say that is a fair assessment (but people are terrible at driving here, for no apparent reason).
I imagine Texas is pretty sunny all the time, so it won't be as exciting to you as it was for me, but having it sunny virtually every day helps keep me positive between reading/working/etc. Coming back to the midwest for break reminds me of how spoiled we are at SLS because the grey of the midwest is quite oppressive this time of the year. At SLS, after a long day of class in November, you can go outside into the bright sunshine in your light jacket and jeans, and go grab a pitcher of beer at the bar on campus and sit outside and relax with your friends. The fall comes in late November, and it goes from 75 every day to 60 every day. All the leaves turn beautiful colors (like in the midwest), and the air gets crisp. The smell is wonderful.
Another big thing about the geography is that SLS is in the middle of silicon valley. So far I've been to Tesla (5 min away) and Google (15 min away). Facebook/HP/eBay/Apple etc. are all within a 15-20 minute drive. The west border of campus houses all the top venture capital firms, and all the top firms have offices right around the corner from Stanford. It is really energizing, you feel as though you are surrounded by people who are changing the world.
How was your finals experience?
Really weird. SLS has 4 doctrinal classes (Torts, Contracts, Crim, Civ Pro) and legal research and writing. 18 credits total, where the normal max is 14 (with 9 being minimum). SLS has an ABA waiver to make us take so many classes. From what I understand, other law schools have 3 doctrinal classes + research/writing. The upperclassmen and administration essentially tell you that you can't do 100 percent in all the classes. Almost everyone believes this, but there are a handful of people who tried. Not sure if this paid off for them or not.
This means you really need to strategize in how you prepare for exams. Because top 1/3 get Hs and everyone else gets Ps, you could potentially split your time equally and only get a P in every class (and perhaps you are the top P in every class). You'd have the same grade as someone who prepared very very little (or not at all), but the same grade. So the idea is that you "punt" one or two classes, and max out in other classes, giving yourself the best chance at an H in those, knowing that you'll be at the bottom of the Ps in the punted class.
Everyone has done the reading for all their classes and has attended class, since we are 1Ls and work like crazy anyway. So even if you punt a class (Crim for me), you can still barely study at all, and be able to write a 15 page exam paper. It might not be pretty, and it won't be H-worthy, but it should get you a P.
As I mentioned, I planned on punting crim, and trying legitimately for Torts/Contracts/CivPro. I made my own outline for Torts (first exam) and Contracts (third), but by the time I got to CivPro I really was wiped out and only had 36 hours to prepare. So I effectively punted CivPro as well. The CivPro exam actually felt great, but we will see to what that actually translates.
Overall, it was really weird not working for a class (or two). In undergrad I gave pretty much everything 100%, but here it more of a "work smarter" mentality. Looking back, it was a really liberating feeling. I was less stressed during exam week than I had been during the first week of school. I think pretty much every other SLS 1L will say that it sucked, but was not as bad as expected. One night we had a wine party in the library to take a break. Fun stuff. I can't imagine being at a school with real grades, I'm confident that I would have been freaking the heck out. I’m looking forward to getting my exams back not for the grades but for the comments, so I can start to figure out what I was actually doing right or wrong during this last quarter.
(There technically are low passes, but they say you have to write less than a page or show active contempt for the professor to not pass a class.)
Are you job hunting for summer? Are you PI?
Definitely. I want to do tech-related stuff, so I sent in resume/cover letters to firms that have that type of practice in early December. My strategy was to make personal connections with SLS alumni at the firms. 1L firm hiring is often more informal, and I hope that my connecting with partners will have been time well spent. I learned a lot and had a great time connecting with them, so even if a job doesn't come up with them for this summer, I will still have some insight next fall for OCI and knowledge of the practice area. I have an interview at a firm in the valley after break, but we will see if it actually results in an offer.
I'm also in the midst of applying to tech places generally, so I suppose this is just the beginning of the application season. I have friends who have already interviewed at firms or for honors government programs. My friends who have had the interviews at firm have had them through diversity programs, which are more formal and early on the schedule. Honors gov’t programs also are on an early schedule. I'd say maybe 50 percent of people didn't apply for jobs before exams, but I'm not really sure!
I figured that a new thread might be helpful, since that other one is 16 pages and over the course of 2 years. I know there are a few other SLSers on here, but I'll try to answer questions often.
These questions were from a prospective student and I thought they might be of some use to those in their decision-making process.
How did you decide on Stanford.
It was a relatively easy choice for me. I decided based on two criteria. 1) a school where I would be happy and enjoy my 3 years. 2) a school that would most easily allow me to pursue whatever I ended up wanting to pursue.
I visited ASWs/Admit Days for UChicago, UPenn, Duke, Michigan, Harvard (not ASW, but with a friend who was a 1L while visiting a friend at Harvard undergrad during spring break), Columbia, NYU, and Stanford (twice). It is hard to describe, but the students at SLS were simply much happier than those at other schools. They had more energy, were more excited about what they were doing, and were confident that they were going to be able to do whatever they wanted after graduation. I had the gut feeling of "this is where I need to be," and felt it was easy to connect with the students I met. My first visit was the week before the second quarter exams, and bar review was packed, and people did not seem crazy stressed for exams.
Full disclosure for the second criterion: I was waitlisted at YLS and HLS. So compared to the other schools (CCNMPDetc.), SLS had a big advantage. I looked at their data (there is a spreadsheet available to the SLS community that includes where all the 1Ls/2Ls/3Ls work), and it was outstanding. At that time I really was basing it by TLS standards, and it was pretty much top firms, top PI, top gov't honors programs, and top clerkships across the board. A student at the time told me that 1 or 2 people total in the fall did not have offers coming out of fall OCI. On the other hand, career people at other schools would not go into depth on their placement stats. Plenty of CLS students had V5 jobs, but it was unclear to me what happened to those not in the top half of the class. Lack of clarity to me meant that the outcomes were not what I would want. The SLS grading system makes a difference in this–those I spoke with at the time said even those with straight Ps had solid jobs lined up.
Essentially, I chose the school where I thought I would be most happy and have the best freedom to pursue what I want career-wise. Clearly this was SLS. After one quarter as a 1L, I think the career freedom absolutely feeds into the student happiness. The impact of the realization that you will be able to get a job you want even if you have less Hs than half of the class cannot be understated.
Did you have to choose between Harvard and Stanford?
Regarding SLS v HLS v YLS: I think the only thing you really need to assess is the happiness factor. You can do whatever you want coming from any of the schools, so you might as well go to the one you will enjoy for the next 3 years. Happiness means different things to different people, and only you can know what will make you happy (or unhappy) at these very distinct schools. People at SLS rubbed me the right way, and people at HLS rubbed me the wrong way, but I completely understand perhaps why other people feel the opposite after interacting with the same people.
Tons of people decide specifically between SLS v HLS with plenty coming to SLS and plenty going to HLS. I'd talk to students at both who decided between the two, and they'll be quite helpful.
I am really worried about the egregious level of debt I will be in. Any thoughts on this?
I spoke with a bunch of people (career counselors, parents, friends, etc.), and they all were more supportive of attending another top 10 school on a named full ride instead of SLS. On the contrary, my professor/mentor (HLS alum) then basically told me, "You are going to be at this school for 3 years of your short life, and you are going to be connected to that school's network and resources for the rest of that short life. Money is simply money, and perhaps you stay at a firm job for an extra year to pay it off, but you will benefit from those friendships you make and connections you have for the rest of your life. Go wherever you want, don't make it about the money." His advice prompted me to think in a longer-term perspective.
I also talked to Dean Deal about it, and she was very helpful. She also essentially said, "Follow your gut. Go where you will be happy, and success will follow. You'll be able to pay off your loans with a SLS degree easily, so if you want to come here, I recommend you follow your gut and do so!"
So basically, I'll graduate with debt equivalent to a Ferrari 458 Italia (cars are the only way I can even start to put that amount of money in perspective). I know a ton of my classmates will be in a large amount of debt as well, but they are not that worried about it. The fact that a firm job with a Aston Martin V12 Vantage salary is available makes it much easier. Even if we have to take that job that perhaps we don't love, we won't be saddled with debt for the rest of our lives. Alternatively, I know SLS has an excellent LRAP program (Dean Deal's post on her blog about it is worth reading), so if you want to do PI, you'll be fine as well.
How have you adjusted to the quarter system (I am assuming you had a semester system in undergrad)?
The first quarter is really a semester. We started at the same time as I did in undergrad (3 weeks before 2/3Ls start), and ended at about the same time (Dec 16th). So far it has been fine, most people are excited about it. What it really means is that our Property and Con law classes are shorter (aka not as much depth), and we have an entire quarter to take whatever we want in the spring. I think this will be an advantage in helping decide what we all want to pursue, in that we will have taken 5 electives (including 1 in the winter) before we have to decide where we want to work during OCI.
It is also awesome because we are in line with the rest of the university. Stanford is ranked in something like the top 5 in 18 graduate programs, and top 3 in 10 of those programs. The rest of the university has a ton of exciting opportunities, and I'm really looking forward to taking classes in other schools. SLS truly is interdisciplinary in that I will be able to take up to 10 classes outside the law school (some schools pay it lip service...Duke told me I could take a total of 2 classes outside the law school). Additionally, it means that the clinics are full-time, which is superb because you treat them like a job and don't have any other distractions during that quarter.
Ask me this question again when I am in class in May and June and I may respond otherwise...
Are you involved in student organizations this year?
I'm not sure about other law schools, but we can get involved in journals as 1Ls. Almost everyone does. I'm on the tech law review, and did blue-booking and editing last quarter. Next quarter I'll be on the board to help decide what articles we publish for next year (while doing more blue-booking and editing). I'm also on the exec board of the SLS Documentary Film Project, which is essentially a journal in the form of a documentary.
The first week of school I got involved in a joint program between the law school and the computer science department that works on legal technology (not to be confused on the law of technology, heh). I sat in on all the meetings for a project that has built an automated IP clearinghouse that saves students 25-80% on coursepacks and enables professors to more easily access new material for classes. I'll be doing projects for them next semester. Pretty much everyone gets involved in student orgs, there are a ton to choose from.
Do you live in Munger? How do you like your living accommodations?
Munger is ridiculous. I live in a 4 bedroom, and we have 4 and 1/2 bathrooms. We have 2 refrigerators for 4 people. I'll post some pics to give you a better idea. It is rather expensive, but is 2 minutes from the law school, and surrounded by palm trees (and next to the 4 story underground heated parking garage).
The best part of Munger is that it really builds the SLS community. 70% of 1Ls live there, and there are always parties/dinners/pre-bar-review-parties happening. My only complaint is that about half-way through the quarter I was desperate for a car to escape from the dreamworld for a bit. It is a wonderful bubble, but it is a bubble and sometimes you need to get out for a night to get a breath of fresh air from the world of law school.
Are you from California? I've never lived anywhere except Texas for longer than three months.
I'm from the midwest and lived in DC for 3 months and the UK for 3 months. At the beginning of the quarter, one of my professors said, "Once you see what living in California is like, you realize that you have been missing the good life." I’d say that is a fair assessment (but people are terrible at driving here, for no apparent reason).
I imagine Texas is pretty sunny all the time, so it won't be as exciting to you as it was for me, but having it sunny virtually every day helps keep me positive between reading/working/etc. Coming back to the midwest for break reminds me of how spoiled we are at SLS because the grey of the midwest is quite oppressive this time of the year. At SLS, after a long day of class in November, you can go outside into the bright sunshine in your light jacket and jeans, and go grab a pitcher of beer at the bar on campus and sit outside and relax with your friends. The fall comes in late November, and it goes from 75 every day to 60 every day. All the leaves turn beautiful colors (like in the midwest), and the air gets crisp. The smell is wonderful.
Another big thing about the geography is that SLS is in the middle of silicon valley. So far I've been to Tesla (5 min away) and Google (15 min away). Facebook/HP/eBay/Apple etc. are all within a 15-20 minute drive. The west border of campus houses all the top venture capital firms, and all the top firms have offices right around the corner from Stanford. It is really energizing, you feel as though you are surrounded by people who are changing the world.
How was your finals experience?
Really weird. SLS has 4 doctrinal classes (Torts, Contracts, Crim, Civ Pro) and legal research and writing. 18 credits total, where the normal max is 14 (with 9 being minimum). SLS has an ABA waiver to make us take so many classes. From what I understand, other law schools have 3 doctrinal classes + research/writing. The upperclassmen and administration essentially tell you that you can't do 100 percent in all the classes. Almost everyone believes this, but there are a handful of people who tried. Not sure if this paid off for them or not.
This means you really need to strategize in how you prepare for exams. Because top 1/3 get Hs and everyone else gets Ps, you could potentially split your time equally and only get a P in every class (and perhaps you are the top P in every class). You'd have the same grade as someone who prepared very very little (or not at all), but the same grade. So the idea is that you "punt" one or two classes, and max out in other classes, giving yourself the best chance at an H in those, knowing that you'll be at the bottom of the Ps in the punted class.
Everyone has done the reading for all their classes and has attended class, since we are 1Ls and work like crazy anyway. So even if you punt a class (Crim for me), you can still barely study at all, and be able to write a 15 page exam paper. It might not be pretty, and it won't be H-worthy, but it should get you a P.
As I mentioned, I planned on punting crim, and trying legitimately for Torts/Contracts/CivPro. I made my own outline for Torts (first exam) and Contracts (third), but by the time I got to CivPro I really was wiped out and only had 36 hours to prepare. So I effectively punted CivPro as well. The CivPro exam actually felt great, but we will see to what that actually translates.
Overall, it was really weird not working for a class (or two). In undergrad I gave pretty much everything 100%, but here it more of a "work smarter" mentality. Looking back, it was a really liberating feeling. I was less stressed during exam week than I had been during the first week of school. I think pretty much every other SLS 1L will say that it sucked, but was not as bad as expected. One night we had a wine party in the library to take a break. Fun stuff. I can't imagine being at a school with real grades, I'm confident that I would have been freaking the heck out. I’m looking forward to getting my exams back not for the grades but for the comments, so I can start to figure out what I was actually doing right or wrong during this last quarter.
(There technically are low passes, but they say you have to write less than a page or show active contempt for the professor to not pass a class.)
Are you job hunting for summer? Are you PI?
Definitely. I want to do tech-related stuff, so I sent in resume/cover letters to firms that have that type of practice in early December. My strategy was to make personal connections with SLS alumni at the firms. 1L firm hiring is often more informal, and I hope that my connecting with partners will have been time well spent. I learned a lot and had a great time connecting with them, so even if a job doesn't come up with them for this summer, I will still have some insight next fall for OCI and knowledge of the practice area. I have an interview at a firm in the valley after break, but we will see if it actually results in an offer.
I'm also in the midst of applying to tech places generally, so I suppose this is just the beginning of the application season. I have friends who have already interviewed at firms or for honors government programs. My friends who have had the interviews at firm have had them through diversity programs, which are more formal and early on the schedule. Honors gov’t programs also are on an early schedule. I'd say maybe 50 percent of people didn't apply for jobs before exams, but I'm not really sure!