Calling All Commerce Clause Experts
Posted: Fri Mar 15, 2013 8:51 pm
So, our prof gave us a practice hypo for the CC. I have been studying up on this for the past few days but still am unsure how exactly the approach the problem. Here is the essential problem:
Congress passes the Endangered Species Act. They delegate to an agency to maintain a list of endangered species. Some developer applies for a permit with the agency, but the permit gets denied because the agency is an ass. So essentially, I think the question is whether Congress is validly exercising its CC power in creating the ESA.
My Questions:
1.) Are there any issues I should be addressing other than CC? Such as standing?
2.) Under the CC analysis I know Congress can regulate things that substantially affect commerce under the third prong articulated in Lopez. I also understand that there is a big distinction between Economic vs. Noneconomic. Do I first argue that this should be seen as economic because there is some commercial value in protecting endangered things? And then since this is arguably economic we can take into account the aggregate affects of keeping endangered species? Do I then go down the line of, if it is NOT economic then other factors come into account to determine whether congress can regulate? (Is this where things such as jurisdictional hook, legislative findings, traditional state concern?)
3.) Is the necessary and proper argument completely separate from the CC analysis?
I have searched these forums for a straight forward application of how this is to be analyzed and cant seem to make sense of it all. I think most of my confusion stems from what happens once it is determined that the activity is NOT ECONOMIC...what factors then come into play to determine whether Congress can regulate the activity. Thanks to anyone that takes a stab at this.
Congress passes the Endangered Species Act. They delegate to an agency to maintain a list of endangered species. Some developer applies for a permit with the agency, but the permit gets denied because the agency is an ass. So essentially, I think the question is whether Congress is validly exercising its CC power in creating the ESA.
My Questions:
1.) Are there any issues I should be addressing other than CC? Such as standing?
2.) Under the CC analysis I know Congress can regulate things that substantially affect commerce under the third prong articulated in Lopez. I also understand that there is a big distinction between Economic vs. Noneconomic. Do I first argue that this should be seen as economic because there is some commercial value in protecting endangered things? And then since this is arguably economic we can take into account the aggregate affects of keeping endangered species? Do I then go down the line of, if it is NOT economic then other factors come into account to determine whether congress can regulate? (Is this where things such as jurisdictional hook, legislative findings, traditional state concern?)
3.) Is the necessary and proper argument completely separate from the CC analysis?
I have searched these forums for a straight forward application of how this is to be analyzed and cant seem to make sense of it all. I think most of my confusion stems from what happens once it is determined that the activity is NOT ECONOMIC...what factors then come into play to determine whether Congress can regulate the activity. Thanks to anyone that takes a stab at this.