I wrote out an analysis for a recording acts question. Could someone please tell me if I am correct?
Problem #1
A -> B
O -> A
B -> C
C records
A -> D (actual knowledge of O->A)
D records
O -> E
E records
See my analysis below:
A -> B
This is a wild deed that is never recorded. B will never win anything.
O -> A
At common law, A wins.
B -> C
C is a BFP without notice. In a notice jx, C wins here.
C records
C is a BFP without notice first to record. In a race notice jx, C wins here.
A -> D (actual knowledge of O->A)
Because A->B was never recorded, B -> C's recording will not provide notice down the chain. D wins here in a notice jurisidction.
D records
D wins here in a race notice jurisidiction for the above reasons.
O -> E
E records
E wins here because E is a BFP without notice. Since O-> A was never recorded, A -> B is a wild deed and its recording won't provide notice down the chain of title. Same goes for A->D. D should have recorded the entire chain back to O. What an idiot.
Problem #2
O -> A
O -> B (actual knowledge of O-> A)
O -> C
B -> D (actual knowledge of O -> B)
A records.
B records.
D records.
See my analysis below:
O -> A
A wins at common law. First in time.
O -> B (actual knowledge of O-> A)
B is not a BFP. A still wins.
O -> C
C is a BFP. In a notice jurisdiction, C wins here. Race notice still gives it to A.
B -> D (actual knowledge of O -> B)
D is a BFP without notice of O->A. Although B->D is wild, D wins in a notice jurisdiction. A still wins in race notice.
A records.
Too little too late. D still wins in notice. A wins in race notice.
B records.
B is not a BFP. B is out of luck.
D records.
D wins in notice. A still wins race notice because A won the race.
Recording Acts question -- can someone please help? Forum
(Study Tips, Dealing With Stress, Maintaining a Social Life, Financial Aid, Internships, Bar Exam, Careers in Law . . . )
- greenchair
- Posts: 150
- Joined: Sat May 08, 2010 1:04 am
Recording Acts question -- can someone please help?
Post by greenchair » Wed Dec 12, 2012 11:21 pm
Return to “Forum for Law School Students”
Jump to
- Law School Admissions
- ↳ Law School Admissions Forum
- ↳ Law School Personal Statements
- ↳ LSAT Prep and Discussion Forum
- ↳ Law School Acceptances, Denials, and Waitlists
- ↳ Law School Visits
- ↳ Choosing a Law School
- ↳ What are my chances?
- ↳ Financial Aid
- ↳ Ask a Law Student / Graduate
- ↳ Transfers
- Law School
- ↳ Forum for Law School Students
- ↳ Ask a Law Student
- ↳ Non-US Law Schools Forum
- ↳ Bar Exam Prep and Discussion Forum
- ↳ Law School Courses
- Law School Class Forums
- ↳ TLS Class of 2025 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2024 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2023 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2022 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2021 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2020 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2019 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2018 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2017 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2016 Forum
- Legal Employment/Careers
- ↳ Legal Employment
- ↳ Judicial Clerkships
- ↳ OCI
- ↳ In-House
- ↳ Small & Midsized Firms
- ↳ 1st Year and 2nd Year Summer
- ↳ Big Law/Private Practice Jobs
- ↳ Public Interest & Government
- ↳ Alternative Careers
- ↳ Lateral Moves
- ↳ Interview Tips
- ↳ Resume Tips
- Underrepresented Lawyers and Students
- ↳ Black Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Hispanic and Latino Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Asian Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ American Indian Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Women Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ LGBTQ+ Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Disabled Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ First Generation Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Veteran Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Single Parent Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Underrepresented Law Students
- Legal Practice
- ↳ Forum for Law School Graduates Only
- ↳ Discussion of Practice Areas
- ↳ Legal News/Law Firm Gossip
- ↳ Firm Q&A by Region
- Legal Advice
- ↳ Free Help and Advice from Professionals
- Off-Topic
- ↳ Buy - Exchange - Giveaway - Sell
- ↳ TLS Content Competitions
- ↳ Other forums not on the main forum index page
- ↳ TLS Class of 2015 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2014 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2013 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2012 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2011 Forum
- ↳ TLS wiki forum
- ↳ TLS Web Logs (Blogs)