Page 1 of 1

Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:17 am
by Extension_Cord
Does anyone have a general outline of an appellate oral argument? I have mine on Thursday and I was thinking there must be a general outline on how to do these things.

Thanks.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:29 am
by MrPapagiorgio
I don't see much utility in one. As soon as one of the judges asks you a question, any plan of attack may go to shit, especially with a hot bench. Mine was just a bunch of short phrases to jog my memory of my argument if the questions threw me off track and I wasn't able to re-group from memory. And besides, the better argument is one where you don't need to look down at all.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:35 am
by Flips88
just make a 2 page bullet point outline of your argument. Have an opening road map for your argument. Say "your honor" frequently.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:40 am
by MrPapagiorgio
Also, avoid any synonym of "As I previously stated" and never, ever respond to a judge's question with "I will be getting to that later."

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:43 am
by Flips88
Oh and one good tip we got: don't use phrases like "I would argue that" or "Appellants believe" or "Appellants would argue..." Just say what your point without prefacing.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 8:49 am
by Extension_Cord
good stuff, thanks.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 11:01 pm
by jess
.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 11:09 pm
by ilovesf
Jessuf wrote:
My outline followed that format. My bench was surprisingly cold. I didn't get questions until I got to my fourth point. It's always good to be prepared for that. I also included answers to possible questions they might have that I didn't necessarily want to discuss unless asked about.
My outline was pretty much the same. However I started to get questions during my theme and they continued pretty heavily throughout my 12 minutes. I only talked about my last point for 1 minute.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 11:32 pm
by lobolawyer
Jessuf wrote:Intro
May it please the court. My name is ___________. And I represent the appellant/appellee __________. [I respectfully request one minute for rebuttal. - if appellant] [Catchy theme or policy sentence that weaves in critical facts of case – sentence or two – zinger.] Therefore, appellant/appellee respectfully requests that this court ___________ for [1,2,3] reasons. First, first reason. Second, second reason. Third, third reason. Turning to my first point:

Body
First point: Similar to point heading of your brief.
Rule (statutes, cases)
Case description (case name, court name, year decided, facts, holding, reasoning)
Your facts
Mini Conclusion

Second point: Copy above format

Third point: Copy above format

Conclusion
For the reasons above, ___________________. [Request relief again]

Rebuttal
May it please the court. I have [1,2] point(s) for rebuttal. The opposing counsel has stated _______. However, blah blah.


My outline followed that format. My bench was surprisingly cold. I didn't get questions until I got to my fourth point. It's always good to be prepared for that. I also included answers to possible questions they might have that I didn't necessarily want to discuss unless asked about.
This. But, you'll probably enter an appearance before the arguments, so you can lose the my name is/I represent.

Re: Appellate Oral Argument Outline?

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 12:19 am
by jess
.