Page 1 of 1
Asahi and Worldwide
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 5:38 pm
by Mike12188
I'm confused. Please help.
From what I understand Worldwide says foreseeability that the product could end up in another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment because there was no advertising in the state, etc.
Now O'Connor's plurality opinion in the Asahi case says that mere awareness that goods may be swept into another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment - would need something else like marketing or a special design for that state.
Now the sentence that is confusing me:
"Some courts continue to apply a fairly broad stream-of-commerce approach based on World-Wide, and take jurisdiction in cases that the O'Connor approach would not reach."
I'm confused because I thought they were pretty much saying the same thing.
Re: Asahi and Worldwide
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 5:44 pm
by shoeshine
Mike12188 wrote:I'm confused. Please help.
From what I understand Worldwide says foreseeability that the product could end up in another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment because there was no advertising in the state, etc.
Now O'Connor's plurality opinion in the Asahi case says that mere awareness that goods may be swept into another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment - would need something else like marketing or a special design for that state.
Now the sentence that is confusing me:
"Some courts continue to apply a fairly broad stream-of-commerce approach based on World-Wide, and take jurisdiction in cases that the O'Connor approach would not reach."
I'm confused because I thought they were pretty much saying the same thing.
Did you read Goodyear? It was another split/plurality decision but O'Connor's approach was affirmed.
Also, I think you holding of WWVW is too narrow.
Re: Asahi and Worldwide
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 6:12 pm
by Sapientia
Mike12188 wrote:I'm confused. Please help.
From what I understand Worldwide says foreseeability that the product could end up in another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment because there was no advertising in the state, etc.
Now O'Connor's plurality opinion in the Asahi case says that mere awareness that goods may be swept into another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment - would need something else like marketing or a special design for that state.
Now the sentence that is confusing me:
"Some courts continue to apply a fairly broad stream-of-commerce approach based on World-Wide, and take jurisdiction in cases that the O'Connor approach would not reach."
I'm confused because I thought they were pretty much saying the same thing.
I was confused about this, also. There's a line in WWV that talks about the stream of commerce - “the forum state does not exceed its powers under the due process clause if it asserts personal jurisdiction over a corporation that delivers its products into the stream of commerce w/ the expectation that they will be purchased by consumers in the forum state."
This has been interpreted two different ways - the O'Connor way and the Brennan way.
Pretty sure that's all you need to know for the stream of commerce stuff.
Re: Asahi and Worldwide
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 7:00 pm
by Mike12188
Sapientia wrote:Mike12188 wrote:I'm confused. Please help.
From what I understand Worldwide says foreseeability that the product could end up in another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment because there was no advertising in the state, etc.
Now O'Connor's plurality opinion in the Asahi case says that mere awareness that goods may be swept into another state is not enough to satisfy purposeful availment - would need something else like marketing or a special design for that state.
Now the sentence that is confusing me:
"Some courts continue to apply a fairly broad stream-of-commerce approach based on World-Wide, and take jurisdiction in cases that the O'Connor approach would not reach."
I'm confused because I thought they were pretty much saying the same thing.
I was confused about this, also. There's a line in WWV that talks about the stream of commerce - “the forum state does not exceed its powers under the due process clause if it asserts personal jurisdiction over a corporation that delivers its products into the stream of commerce w/ the expectation that they will be purchased by consumers in the forum state."
This has been interpreted two different ways - the O'Connor way and the Brennan way.
Pretty sure that's all you need to know for the stream of commerce stuff.
Ahh great. I came back here to write that it wasn't sure if that's what they were referring to in ASahi. Thanks a lot.
Re: Asahi and Worldwide
Posted: Sun Apr 01, 2012 9:43 am
by apl6783
Stop reading cases and start listening to Richard D. Freer's audio lecture. He teaches you the entire course in 9 hours. The part about PJ is 30 minutes to an hour or so, and you'll understand it perfectly after that.