Post your contracts Profs preferred definition of "contract"
Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2011 11:58 am
Why? Because it'll be amusing to see how many variations of the same fundamental term are out there... "consideration" would be a good one too.
Law School Discussion Forums
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=172585
What shock said.shock259 wrote:Legally enforceable promise
Bargained-for exchange
Wow, mine prefers "mutual manifestation of assent to an exchange between two or more parties that is also legally enforceable."shock259 wrote:Legally enforceable promise
Bargained-for exchange
That just seems a bit unnecessarily wordy to me.introversional wrote:Wow, mine prefers "mutual manifestation of assent to an exchange between two or more parties that is also legally enforceable."shock259 wrote:Legally enforceable promise
Bargained-for exchange
That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action. The credited definition is a promise or set of promises the breach of which has a legal remedy, like shepdawg said.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
No, because my tort professor defined tort as a non-contract liability. So I guess those are all torts.Bronte wrote:That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
oh dearben4847 wrote:No, because my tort professor defined tort as a non-contract liability. So I guess those are all torts.Bronte wrote:That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
That is not a good definition, because there are contracts which are not based on any promise; that is when they are implied in law.Bronte wrote:That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action. The credited definition is a promise or set of promises the breach of which has a legal remedy, like shepdawg said.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
The title of the thread wasn't "Disagree with other's prof's definitions of contracts," but I'm going to anyway. This definition is also overly broad. It would include, for example, an enforceable agreement that nevertheless had legal effects. For example, an agreement to rob a bank is not a contract because it's unenforceable, but it nevertheless has the legal affect of exposing the counterparties to criminal liability. It's also overly narrow because it excludes nonagreements enforceable based on reliance, which are considered a part of modern contract law.AlexanderSupertramp wrote:An agreement with a legal effect.
I've already explained why your definition doesn't work. It's absurdly over broad. Your response, which I thought was a joke, was that a tort is noncontractual liability. Crimes are definitely not torts and a variety of other civil liability is almost certainly not tort liability.ben4847 wrote:That is not a good definition, because there are contracts which are not based on any promise; that is when they are implied in law.Bronte wrote:That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action. The credited definition is a promise or set of promises the breach of which has a legal remedy, like shepdawg said.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
That is why my definition is superior, since it encompasses any liability imposed which is not based on tort theories.
I think crimes are torts. Assault is a tort, even though it is also a crime. We had a plaintiff's lawyer who sues corporations in M & A deals tell us he was practicing torts, in class today.Bronte wrote:I've already explained why your definition doesn't work. It's absurdly over broad. Your response, which I thought was a joke, was that a tort is noncontractual liability. Crimes are definitely not torts and a variety of other civil liability is almost certainly not tort liability.ben4847 wrote:That is not a good definition, because there are contracts which are not based on any promise; that is when they are implied in law.Bronte wrote:That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action. The credited definition is a promise or set of promises the breach of which has a legal remedy, like shepdawg said.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
That is why my definition is superior, since it encompasses any liability imposed which is not based on tort theories.
As to contracts "implied in law," they arise out of implied promises, so they're not excluded from that definition.
Does that mean that replevin is a contract action in your "superior" definition? What about a child custody suit?ben4847 wrote:That is not a good definition, because there are contracts which are not based on any promise; that is when they are implied in law.Bronte wrote:That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action. The credited definition is a promise or set of promises the breach of which has a legal remedy, like shepdawg said.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
That is why my definition is superior, since it encompasses any liability imposed which is not based on tort theories.
You have no idea what you're talking about.ben4847 wrote:
I think crimes are torts. Assault is a tort, even though it is also a crime. We had a plaintiff's lawyer who sues corporations in M & A deals tell us he was practicing torts, in class today.
And you will have a hard time imagining that a contract implied in law is an implied promise in any sense except that some judges thought you ought to pay.
Also, this.5ky wrote:You have no idea what you're talking about.ben4847 wrote:
I think crimes are torts. Assault is a tort, even though it is also a crime. We had a plaintiff's lawyer who sues corporations in M & A deals tell us he was practicing torts, in class today.
And you will have a hard time imagining that a contract implied in law is an implied promise in any sense except that some judges thought you ought to pay.
Crimes are not torts. Some crimes and torts share the same name. And some actions give rise to both criminal and tort liability, but crimes are not torts. Contracts "implied in law" are a legal fiction either way. It's no harder to "imagine" them as contracts than it is to imagine them as implied contracts.ben4847 wrote:I think crimes are torts. Assault is a tort, even though it is also a crime. We had a plaintiff's lawyer who sues corporations in M & A deals tell us he was practicing torts, in class today.
And you will have a hard time imagining that a contract implied in law is an implied promise in any sense except that some judges thought you ought to pay.
replevin is a contract in my definition. I quote the case of Sherwood v. Walker which begins "Replevin for a cow" (you may have read it in regard to mistake in contracts)Renzo wrote:Does that mean that replevin is a contract action in your "superior" definition? What about a child custody suit?ben4847 wrote:That is not a good definition, because there are contracts which are not based on any promise; that is when they are implied in law.Bronte wrote:That seems too broad. This would include criminal liability and other liability deriving from statute, like an antitrust action. The credited definition is a promise or set of promises the breach of which has a legal remedy, like shepdawg said.ben4847 wrote:A non-tort liability.
That is why my definition is superior, since it encompasses any liability imposed which is not based on tort theories.