Page 1 of 1

NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 9:25 pm
by Anonymous User
Top 10% at NCG but in at P. Worth going or does it not make a difference for career opps? Want NYC or DC? Have several yrs of policy experience

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 9:51 pm
by bdubs
Stay, particularly if at Cornell for NY or Georgetown for DC. Top 10% at NU will snag you most big NY firms and will give you a shot at DC, particularly if you have ties/good reasons for DC.

Penn will offer you no advantage and you will have to essentially start over at a new school.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 9:55 pm
by ymmv
Anonymous User wrote:Top 10% at NCG but in at P. Worth going or does it not make a difference for career opps? Want NYC or DC? Have several yrs of policy experience
Stay if you have a full ride or if your school will offer you one to keep you from transferring. Transfer if you're already paying sticker and they won't budge. If you're somewhere in between, the choice will be a more difficult one. Are you on LR?

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:41 pm
by toothbrush
Anonymous User wrote:Top 10% at NCG but in at P. Worth going or does it not make a difference for career opps? Want NYC or DC? Have several yrs of policy experience
you only applied to P but you want to be in NYC or DC? I'm so confused.

Is there a "wait for C or H" option?

going to P does 0 things for you unless you hate your school right. i can sympathize so there may be that going for u.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:46 pm
by ymmv
toothbrush wrote:
Anonymous User wrote:Top 10% at NCG but in at P. Worth going or does it not make a difference for career opps? Want NYC or DC? Have several yrs of policy experience
you only applied to P but you want to be in NYC or DC? I'm so confused.

Is there a "wait for C or H" option?

going to P does 0 things for you unless you hate your school right. i can sympathize so there may be that going for u.
Penn's employment figures are markedly better than NC's and significantly better than G's. Again, whether OP should transfer depends on what he is currently paying and whether his school will offer him money to stay.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:48 pm
by toothbrush
ymmv wrote:\
Penn's employment figures are markedly better than NC's and significantly better than G's. Again, whether OP should transfer depends on what he is currently paying and whether his school will offer him money to stay.
yah sure for people at median. not for nyc/dc big law placement for cng top 10%rs.

it's not like there's a magical echelon of firms that open up at a "t6" and not from "dcng".

save wlrk but lul.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:50 pm
by 09042014
lol at transfering within the lower T14. Hell LOL at transfering at all from a T14.

What kind of miserable loser is going to trade up for essentially no gain?

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:51 pm
by toothbrush
Desert Fox wrote:lol at transfering within the lower T14. Hell LOL at transfering at all from a T14.

What kind of miserable loser is going to trade up for essentially no gain?
ur right, only miserable ppl.

there is no real gain like you said tho. so OP your choice is bad unless you have personal reasons.

and even then DF would say ur dumb but thats k

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:54 pm
by 09042014
If I interviewed someone I'd ding them for doing this unless their wife needed to move for a job or something.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:55 pm
by toothbrush
Desert Fox wrote:If I interviewed someone I'd ding them for doing this unless their wife needed to move for a job or something.
do you think that's just your opinion or most interviewers feel that way

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:58 pm
by 09042014
toothbrush wrote:
Desert Fox wrote:If I interviewed someone I'd ding them for doing this unless their wife needed to move for a job or something.
do you think that's just your opinion or most interviewers feel that way
I'm sure I'm way more opinionated than most. But it's weird to transfer.

A guy I know transfered from NU to HLS and then struck out at Chicago firms. I'd imagine tons of NU alumni clicking ding![homophobic language redacted] on his callback eval

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 10:58 pm
by ymmv
Desert Fox wrote:If I interviewed someone I'd ding them for doing this unless their wife needed to move for a job or something.
Come to think of it I've had a couple professors who transferred within the T14 for presumably striverish reasons and they're pretty insufferable. Guess it worked out for their careers though.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 11:02 pm
by 09042014
ymmv wrote:
Desert Fox wrote:If I interviewed someone I'd ding them for doing this unless their wife needed to move for a job or something.
Come to think of it I've had a couple professors who transferred within the T14 for presumably striverish reasons and they're pretty insufferable. Guess it worked out for their careers though.
Only because miserable piece of shit is the culture of academia.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 11:03 pm
by mw115
Desert Fox wrote:A guy I know transfered from NU to HLS and then struck out at Chicago firms. I'd imagine tons of NU alumni clicking ding![Hi; this person hates sunshine and kittens and pleasant things in the world] on his callback eval
Where I worked, you'd get dinged if you transferred from Texas to a T14. Seemed to be the consensus in Houston.

Re: NCG (Top 10%) to P?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 11:11 pm
by toothbrush
mw115 wrote:
Desert Fox wrote:A guy I know transfered from NU to HLS and then struck out at Chicago firms. I'd imagine tons of NU alumni clicking ding![Hi; this person hates sunshine and kittens and pleasant things in the world] on his callback eval
Where I worked, you'd get dinged if you transferred from Texas to a T14. Seemed to be the consensus in Houston.
well if you want Texas and ur at UT and u have th egrades to get T firms why would you transfer. there is no strong T school besides UT.

that is objectively dumb and they deserve to be dinged.