Would you forgo a 50k (taxed) signing bonus for a firm that you like better?
Posted: Sun Jul 23, 2023 12:15 pm
.
Law School Discussion Forums
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=314563
You gotta share the firm names here. It's impossible to provide opinions without knowing whether this is like, for NY, DPW vs Milbank or Kirkland vs Latham.Anonymous User wrote: ↑Sun Jul 23, 2023 12:15 pmStuck between two firms. The one that offered a scholarship (F1) expires very soon and the other (F2) expires much later. They aren't peer firms, from what I can gather, but the gap isn't TOO big either, I think. From what I can gather, F1 doesn't really have strong suits in the market that I am looking at but the culture reputation is extremely good. I had weird experiences interviewing with them, however. F2 is where I would choose in a heartbeat if I wasn't offered the scholarship. It has a stellar reputation in my market and I had great experiences interviewing. I prefer the community there, prefer the assignment system, and I think exit options would be better.
I asked F2 to match F1 and they were basically like, "I don't think I can give you an answer by the time F1's offer will expire." Also interviewed with another firm this week that I liked a lot more than I expected--enough to rival F2 for me. Of course, I can't guarantee an offer but it was another place I could see myself in the future (and I also applied to their scholarship as well)
Considering that the money will be heavily taxed too--but it's still a lot for me. I know it's a very personal decision because it is related to my finances, but I am wondering what you would choose.
You don't need to lol, Claire isn't surfing TLS in her free time to pull diversity offers. I get it, being a 1L is neurotic, but try to chill.Anonymous User wrote: ↑Mon Jul 24, 2023 9:41 amSidley, STB (NYC)
Will prob delete in a few days lol
Not litigation. Interest in funds, tech transactions (I know they are two very different things lol)Anonymous User wrote: ↑Mon Jul 24, 2023 11:31 pmGiven the firms, what practice (even generally) and are you angling Chicago?
Ooh. thought it was their "lifestyle" practice group :/Anonymous User wrote: ↑Tue Jul 25, 2023 5:27 pmI gave up 100k to leave STB so take from that what you will. Tech transactions is probably not as bad (and probably useful for a California pivot) but would avoid their funds group like the plague even if it interests you from afar.
Insane to me that you would turn that 50k just to go to Simpson. Sidley is virtually a peer and if it's bad just lateral to Simpson after a few years.Anonymous User wrote: ↑Sun Jul 23, 2023 12:15 pmStuck between two firms. The one that offered a scholarship (F1) expires very soon and the other (F2) expires much later. They aren't peer firms, from what I can gather, but the gap isn't TOO big either, I think. From what I can gather, F1 doesn't really have strong suits in the market that I am looking at but the culture reputation is extremely good. I had weird experiences interviewing with them, however. F2 is where I would choose in a heartbeat if I wasn't offered the scholarship. It has a stellar reputation in my market and I had great experiences interviewing. I prefer the community there, prefer the assignment system, and I think exit options would be better.
I asked F2 to match F1 and they were basically like, "I don't think I can give you an answer by the time F1's offer will expire." Also interviewed with another firm this week that I liked a lot more than I expected--enough to rival F2 for me. Of course, I can't guarantee an offer but it was another place I could see myself in the future (and I also applied to their scholarship as well)
Considering that the money will be heavily taxed too--but it's still a lot for me. I know it's a very personal decision because it is related to my finances, but I am wondering what you would choose.
It's a lifestyle if working is your lifestyle lol I wouldn't overall rate it a pleasant place to work and didn't know anyone who enjoyed their time there.Anonymous User wrote: ↑Tue Jul 25, 2023 5:49 pmOoh. thought it was their "lifestyle" practice group :/Anonymous User wrote: ↑Tue Jul 25, 2023 5:27 pmI gave up 100k to leave STB so take from that what you will. Tech transactions is probably not as bad (and probably useful for a California pivot) but would avoid their funds group like the plague even if it interests you from afar.
Moneytrees wrote: ↑Tue Jul 25, 2023 5:52 pmInsane to me that you would turn that 50k just to go to Simpson. Sidley is virtually a peer and if it's bad just lateral to Simpson after a few years.Anonymous User wrote: ↑Sun Jul 23, 2023 12:15 pmStuck between two firms. The one that offered a scholarship (F1) expires very soon and the other (F2) expires much later. They aren't peer firms, from what I can gather, but the gap isn't TOO big either, I think. From what I can gather, F1 doesn't really have strong suits in the market that I am looking at but the culture reputation is extremely good. I had weird experiences interviewing with them, however. F2 is where I would choose in a heartbeat if I wasn't offered the scholarship. It has a stellar reputation in my market and I had great experiences interviewing. I prefer the community there, prefer the assignment system, and I think exit options would be better.
I asked F2 to match F1 and they were basically like, "I don't think I can give you an answer by the time F1's offer will expire." Also interviewed with another firm this week that I liked a lot more than I expected--enough to rival F2 for me. Of course, I can't guarantee an offer but it was another place I could see myself in the future (and I also applied to their scholarship as well)
Considering that the money will be heavily taxed too--but it's still a lot for me. I know it's a very personal decision because it is related to my finances, but I am wondering what you would choose.