Page 1 of 1
Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 10:09 pm
by Anonymous User
I just finished up all my CBs and am down to choosing between these 3- am struggling to decide and would appreciate feedback on what people consider the best option.
Some info about myself:
I intend to stay in NY long term (not originally from here), am primarily interested in litigation but absolutely want to try transactional work this summer just in case, and while I think Sidley is the best in terms of "fit," I am generally a very easygoing person and found all 3 to have pleasant people that I could see myself working with. I am also going in with the mindset that I want to be on a partner-track, but given how unrealistic that goal is I am also very concerned about optimizing my exit options. Also, a CCN student.
Any advice?
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 10:14 pm
by Anonymous User
I loved STB on my callback - Congrats those are all great firms.
Mind sharing when your CB was/when they called with offer?
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 10:18 pm
by Anonymous User
Anonymous User wrote:I loved STB on my callback - Congrats those are all great firms.
Mind sharing when your CB was/when they called with offer?
Thanks! Sidley CB was last week, the other two were this week. S&C offer on the spot, and the other calls both came in Wednesday/Thursday.
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 10:25 pm
by thesealocust
Sidley NYC is noticeably less-fancy-pants-prestigious than S&C and STB, which are close enough for government work (at least without some kind of much more narrow desire). I feel like I remember Sidley having economic troubles lately too.
Edit: yeah, I just double checked chambers. I really don't think you should be considering Sidley unless you get bad vibes from S&C/STB or have some other good reason.
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 10:41 pm
by Anonymous User
thesealocust wrote:Sidley NYC is noticeably less-fancy-pants-prestigious than S&C and STB, which are close enough for government work (at least without some kind of much more narrow desire). I feel like I remember Sidley having economic troubles lately too.
Edit: yeah, I just double checked chambers. I really don't think you should be considering Sidley unless you get bad vibes from S&C/STB or have some other good reason.
The only reason I could think to prefer Sidley would be a future relocation to Chicago, which is unlikely...thanks for the input!
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 10:42 pm
by Anonymous User
S&C is stronger for lit.
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 11:34 pm
by Anonymous User
When ever there's a poll about top firms, DPW/STB/Cleary would always get a lot of favorable votes while Cravath/S&C/Skadden would always get dissed.
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2013 11:41 pm
by Anonymous User
Simpson by a mile. Hth
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Fri Sep 06, 2013 8:51 am
by Anonymous User
Anonymous User wrote:When ever there's a poll about top firms, DPW/STB/Cleary would always get a lot of favorable votes while Cravath/S&C/Skadden would always get dissed.
This reminds me of selecting colleges a few years back. At that time, people on CollegeConfidential always say that Harvard College has a bad culture (i.e. uncaring professors, gunning classmates who study too much), and people should go to Stanford/Yale/Dartmouth instead.
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Fri Sep 06, 2013 8:53 am
by Danger Zone
Anonymous User wrote:Anonymous User wrote:When ever there's a poll about top firms, DPW/STB/Cleary would always get a lot of favorable votes while Cravath/S&C/Skadden would always get dissed.
This reminds me of selecting colleges a few years back. At that time, people on CollegeConfidential always say that Harvard College has a bad culture (i.e. uncaring professors, gunning classmates who study too much), and people should go to Stanford/Yale/Dartmouth instead.
White people problems.
Re: Would appreciate opinions on: STB v. S&C v. Sidley (all NY)
Posted: Fri Sep 06, 2013 11:36 am
by Anonymous User
Anonymous User wrote:Simpson by a mile. Hth
Any reason for this?