Page 1 of 1

C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 6:33 pm
by Anonymous User
So I bombed what is essentially intro to business law first semester but managed to get good marks in my other classes. How bad does a C+ in a core business course look to firms, i.e., NY Biglaw? Doesnt help that my high marks were in Legal Theory classes...Am I looking at slim chances for hireback? 2L btw...

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 6:48 pm
by vamedic03
Anonymous User wrote:So I bombed what is essentially intro to business law first semester but managed to get good marks in my other classes. How bad does a C+ in a core business course look to firms, i.e., NY Biglaw? Doesnt help that my high marks were in Legal Theory classes...Am I looking at slim chances for hireback? 2L btw...
(1) Does your firm ask for 2L grades?

(2) It's probably unlikely that if you have a good work product and otherwise did fine that the firm will care. They will have spent >$30k on you by the end of the summer.

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 9:56 pm
by spock
yeah they require 2L transcripts... i dont have any other marks below a b+ but it doesnt look good to get an A in theory and a C in corporate law which is what im presumably being hired to do. Thanks for the advice.

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 11:04 pm
by Anonymous User
Depends on the firm. Does you firm historically have 100% or near thereto offer rates?

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 11:12 pm
by Anonymous User
Similarly... is a no-offer likely to result from a low 3.0 GPA if its all Bs and a B+ (all substantial classes)?

*** assume top school and top firm (100% or close to 100% hiring)

Thanks in advance

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 6:13 pm
by Anonymous User
bump

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 6:50 pm
by Aqualibrium
Anonymous User wrote:Similarly... is a no-offer likely to result from a low 3.0 GPA if its all Bs and a B+ (all substantial classes)?

*** assume top school and top firm (100% or close to 100% hiring)

Thanks in advance

You're fucked.

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 7:31 pm
by Sup Kid
Aqualibrium wrote:
Anonymous User wrote:Similarly... is a no-offer likely to result from a low 3.0 GPA if its all Bs and a B+ (all substantial classes)?

*** assume top school and top firm (100% or close to 100% hiring)

Thanks in advance

You're fucked.
I don't think its that terrible, but you need to bring it back up this semester. So long as you keep your cumulative GPA around where it was (no more than .2 of a point drop, so 3.6 can drop to 3.4 for example), you should be ok.

Edit: You probably also need to be on law review, mock trial, moot court, etc to explain the drop (aka "I was doing other stuff besides classes").

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 7:38 pm
by Aqualibrium
Sup Kid wrote:
Aqualibrium wrote:
Anonymous User wrote:Similarly... is a no-offer likely to result from a low 3.0 GPA if its all Bs and a B+ (all substantial classes)?

*** assume top school and top firm (100% or close to 100% hiring)

Thanks in advance

You're fucked.
I don't think its that terrible, but you need to bring it back up this semester. So long as you keep your cumulative GPA around where it was (no more than .2 of a point drop, so 3.6 can drop to 3.4 for example), you should be ok.

Edit: You probably also need to be on law review, mock trial, moot court, etc to explain the drop (aka "I was doing other stuff besides classes").
I was kidding. My point was that no one can really comment on this except the firm. You're fine/You're fucked from us doesn't mean anything at all.

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 7:40 pm
by Kohinoor
Sup Kid wrote: I don't think its that terrible, but you need to bring it back up this semester. So long as you keep your cumulative GPA around where it was (no more than .2 of a point drop, so 3.6 can drop to 3.4 for example), you should be ok.

Edit: You probably also need to be on law review, mock trial, moot court, etc to explain the drop (aka "I was doing other stuff besides classes").
1. Presumably he had a lowish gpa at the time of his offer since that happened in the fall and one semester of B's wouldn't drop even a 3.3 to a 3.1.

2. Firms probably view a 3.8 to 3.6 very differently from a 3.2 to 3.0. One is regression to the mean.

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 8:10 pm
by Sup Kid
Kohinoor wrote:
Sup Kid wrote: I don't think its that terrible, but you need to bring it back up this semester. So long as you keep your cumulative GPA around where it was (no more than .2 of a point drop, so 3.6 can drop to 3.4 for example), you should be ok.

Edit: You probably also need to be on law review, mock trial, moot court, etc to explain the drop (aka "I was doing other stuff besides classes").
1. Presumably he had a lowish gpa at the time of his offer since that happened in the fall and one semester of B's wouldn't drop even a 3.3 to a 3.1.

2. Firms probably view a 3.8 to 3.6 very differently from a 3.2 to 3.0. One is regression to the mean.
If his cumulative is in the low-3.0, then my original point may not apply. I was under the assumption that this semester his gpa is 3.0ish, and he had a significantly higher gpa after 1L year (thus resulting in a decent cumulative now).

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 9:09 pm
by Anonymous User
I could be wrong, but I've got the impression that it shouldn't make a difference unless you give them a reason not to hire you this summer.

Re: C+ in Business Organizations - No Offer?

Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2011 11:02 pm
by Kohinoor
Anonymous User wrote:I could be wrong, but I've got the impression that it shouldn't make a difference unless you give them a reason not to hire you this summer.
link?