Top Law Schools

Anyone have an offer from Milbank NY? If so, what was the timespan between visit and offer?

yep, my friend got her offer the day of her cb.

Anonymous User wrote:yep, my friend got her offer the day of her cb.

Jesus, is that normal?

Anonymous User wrote:

Anonymous User wrote:yep, my friend got her offer the day of her cb.

Jesus, is that normal?

I don't know she said that milbank gives fast offers either day of or next day? But I also know that this firm is head over heels in love with my friend.

Anyone else?

Anonymous User wrote:Anyone else?

I'm still waiting. I had my callback last week. When did you have yours?

Still waiting on my decision regarding if I am getting a callback or not. If the firm really does make offers that quick, it probably explains why (as they would be "wait listing" people at the stage I am sitting at, not at the after callback point).

Anonymous User wrote:Still waiting on my decision regarding if I am getting a callback or not. If the firm really does make offers that quick, it probably explains why (as they would be "wait listing" people at the stage I am sitting at, not at the after callback point).

I don't know. My friend had a callback 2-3 weeks ago. An offer deadline was up, so he called to see if he could get a decision, but they told him they couldn't render a decision, so he withdrew from consideration. It seems like there is a "waitlist" for post-callback people if they told him they couldn't render a decision 2 weeks after his callback.

Does anyone else who has gotten an offer have info on the offer-callback timeline?

I really liked Milbank, but mine's been 10 days now too. I figure no news is good news, for now.

Anonymous User wrote:I really liked Milbank, but mine's been 10 days now too. I figure no news is good news, for now.

Did they tell you when the hiring committee meets? I asked, but I don't think they gave me a precise day.

Also, do you think they are really "waitlisting" post-callback people?

Anonymous User wrote:

Anonymous User wrote:I really liked Milbank, but mine's been 10 days now too. I figure no news is good news, for now.

Did they tell you when the hiring committee meets? I asked, but I don't think they gave me a precise day.

Also, do you think they are really "waitlisting" post-callback people?

I asked too, but they also didn't give me a date. I don't know if they are doing waitlists, but I know lots of firms have "hold" columns. So I'd hold out hope till you get the ding :p Some people hypothesized the change in NALP deadlines might have something to do with it; obviously there's been no real confirmation yet.

Anonymous User wrote:

Anonymous User wrote:

Anonymous User wrote:I really liked Milbank, but mine's been 10 days now too. I figure no news is good news, for now.

Did they tell you when the hiring committee meets? I asked, but I don't think they gave me a precise day.

Also, do you think they are really "waitlisting" post-callback people?

I asked too, but they also didn't give me a date. I don't know if they are doing waitlists, but I know lots of firms have "hold" columns. So I'd hold out hope till you get the ding :p Some people hypothesized the change in NALP deadlines might have something to do with it; obviously there's been no real confirmation yet.

Ok. I really liked Milbank too - I hope we both hear good news soon.

Anyone hear about Milbank offers going out this week?

I interviewed at Milbank NY last Tuesday (9/14) and heard this Monday (9/20)

Congrats! Guess that eliminates the rest of us :p

Congrats! I guess I kind of expected a ding...

If you don't mind me asking, school/rank?

Anything? Going on three weeks now.

Its been two weeks today here and still no offer or ding. Has anyone followed up, and if so received any response?

Do they have some sort of hold process?

Anyone have an idea what Milbank's timeline is looking like? Do rejections come by snail mail?

has anyone been rejected from milbank?

ive heard of people receiving offers but no rejections so far

Anyone else still waiting to hear back? No offer, no ding in almost a month.

Anonymous User wrote:Anyone else still waiting to hear back? No offer, no ding in almost a month.

No word here, but I really don't care anymore. Already got an offer at a firm I liked a lot more - and that is not in New York. Huzzah! I have a feeling Milbank is going to keep people on the list for a good long while, waiting for people like me to trickle off so that they can scoop up the best of what is left to fill in holes in their class.

Anonymous User wrote:

Anonymous User wrote:Anyone else still waiting to hear back? No offer, no ding in almost a month.

No word here, but I really don't care anymore. Already got an offer at a firm I liked a lot more - and that is not in New York. Huzzah! I have a feeling Milbank is going to keep people on the list for a good long while, waiting for people like me to trickle off so that they can scoop up the best of what is left to fill in holes in their class.

People like me would really appreciate if people like you would withdraw themselves.