Page 1 of 1
Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Thu Oct 26, 2017 11:48 pm
by 38981928
I'm trying to figure out if I should be writing a "Why" essay for all of them. I didn't do one for Cornell (first app sent) and now I'm kind of getting nervous because I just discovered this whole "yield protection" concept on this forum. I am customizing all my personal statements and diversity statements for each school, with a specific program/clinic/[other specific thing] mentioned on the personal statement.
Re: Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 9:32 am
by HenryHankPalmer
MVPD really, really seem to care about Why Xs.
Re: Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 9:42 am
by sparkytrainer
I know for certain Duke cares a lot about a legitimate, well-thought out Why essay.
Re: Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 9:47 am
by Jack_Kelly
I don't think either Vanderbilt or WUSTL do but most of the lower T13 seem to. Pretty sure UVA is the biggest culprit.
http://mylsn.info/s2kcj5/
Re: Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 10:08 am
by HenryHankPalmer
Jack_Kelly wrote:I don't think either Vanderbilt or WUSTL do but most of the lower T13 seem to. Pretty sure UVA is the biggest culprit.
http://mylsn.info/s2kcj5/
Yeah, because of their emphasis on interviews you can get away without doing Whys for Vanderbilt and WUSTL. If you are OOS, Texas really, really wants you to do one.
Re: Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 3:36 pm
by 38981928
HenryHankPalmer wrote:Jack_Kelly wrote:I don't think either Vanderbilt or WUSTL do but most of the lower T13 seem to. Pretty sure UVA is the biggest culprit.
http://mylsn.info/s2kcj5/
Yeah, because of their emphasis on interviews you can get away without doing Whys for Vanderbilt and WUSTL. If you are OOS, Texas really, really wants you to do one.
Good to know! My numbers are above both of Texas's 75th percentiles and they didn't seem like the biggest culprits of YP so I thought I would be fine not writing one for them, but I actually really, really love Texas and I'm out of state. I have thought about moving to Austin for years for a number of personal reasons so I guess I should write one for them too
Re: Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 3:41 pm
by cdotson2
I think yield protect is overblown on this site, but the phenomenon of getting into better schools and waitlisted or rejected at lower ranking schools happens for cnn too. I think only HYS would be completly devoid of this practice. -speaking from personal experience of being waitlisted at all of CNN and getting into H and S
Re: Does every top school (outside HYSCCN) yield protect?
Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 3:52 pm
by 38981928
cdotson2 wrote:I think yield protect is overblown on this site, but the phenomenon of getting into better schools and waitlisted or rejected at lower ranking schools happens for cnn too. I think only HYS would be completly devoid of this practice. -speaking from personal experience of being waitlisted at all of CNN and getting into H and S
Oh wow that's crazy! So would you recommend writing "Why" essays for CCN too? It's not like my numbers are so high that I would be YP-ed from those three (I think?), but I want to help my case as much as possible.