Page 1 of 1

Accidentally submitted wrong PS

Posted: Sat Feb 02, 2013 10:51 pm
by Lagunitan
.

Re: Accidentally submitted wrong PS

Posted: Sat Feb 02, 2013 11:11 pm
by bbsg
I'm of no help but I am interested in the outcome -- do come back and update! I'd probably call them first thing Monday, for what it's worth.

Re: Accidentally submitted wrong PS

Posted: Sat Feb 02, 2013 11:13 pm
by Lagunitan
.

Re: Accidentally submitted wrong PS

Posted: Sat Feb 02, 2013 11:32 pm
by b123
Call Monday. You have nothing to lose unless they're really into stream of consciousness, in which case your original submission should work well.

Re: Accidentally submitted wrong PS

Posted: Sun Feb 03, 2013 3:49 am
by ManOfTheMinute
Lagunitan wrote:This is for one of HYS. Assume I otherwise have numbers/softs that would make me competitive (but not an auto-admit) for this school. I had two files with different extensions but the same name on my computer, and accidentally uploaded the wrong file. It's an earlier draft of the PS, but isn't even a coherent document - it was never close to final form for an application. I have the correct original PS, which the time stamp shows was not edited after the deadline for the school I applied to.

Is it worth calling first thing Monday morning to ask if I can resubmit the essay? The alternative is just withdrawing the application - as is, the incorrect essay would almost surely get me auto-dinged. If I withdraw, I'll probably be looking to reapply next year - not sure whether it's better to reapply having withdrawn before going under review or to reapply after alerting admissions that I made a careless mistake on my application.

Anyone have experience with trying to send in a corrected PS after the deadline?
Soooo... when you clicked "Preview Application," you did not infact, preview the application? Totally honest, if I were adcom at HYS the simple act of doing this would DQ you forever and always. Your only real hope is withdrawing the application and hoping that no one ever looks at it.

Re: Accidentally submitted wrong PS

Posted: Sun Feb 03, 2013 4:31 am
by Ti Malice
Call and ask. I know someone who got into HLS after initially forgetting to include her résumé. Some adcomms will be chill enough to let you make the amendment. And it's worth pointing out the date stamp so it doesn't look like you benefited from extra time. If they don't let you amend (and very tactfully refuse to take a no from a receptionist, by the way), then withdraw.

Re: Accidentally submitted wrong PS

Posted: Sun Feb 03, 2013 11:13 am
by LRGhost
ManOfTheMinute wrote:
Lagunitan wrote:This is for one of HYS. Assume I otherwise have numbers/softs that would make me competitive (but not an auto-admit) for this school. I had two files with different extensions but the same name on my computer, and accidentally uploaded the wrong file. It's an earlier draft of the PS, but isn't even a coherent document - it was never close to final form for an application. I have the correct original PS, which the time stamp shows was not edited after the deadline for the school I applied to.

Is it worth calling first thing Monday morning to ask if I can resubmit the essay? The alternative is just withdrawing the application - as is, the incorrect essay would almost surely get me auto-dinged. If I withdraw, I'll probably be looking to reapply next year - not sure whether it's better to reapply having withdrawn before going under review or to reapply after alerting admissions that I made a careless mistake on my application.

Anyone have experience with trying to send in a corrected PS after the deadline?
Soooo... when you clicked "Preview Application," you did not infact, preview the application? Totally honest, if I were adcom at HYS the simple act of doing this would DQ you forever and always. Your only real hope is withdrawing the application and hoping that no one ever looks at it.
People make mistakes and after doing half a dozen or more applications, 'previewing' it after the second one is just whatever.

OP, just call them up. This is almost surely not a big deal and it just feels that way in the moment.