Page 1 of 1
					
				Is this true about the recommendation?
				Posted: Wed Nov 17, 2010 3:51 am
				by atkpl
				My major is business.
I got one from my marketing professor whom I worked for as a TA
I got another one from my Japanese professor who loves me, and I took her class for two semesters (High level Japanese classes).
I got the letter from Japanese professor because I honestly believe she knows me better than any of my business professors.
But so many people are saying that I was being stupid not to get both of the letters from business professor.
They are saying that law schools won't really appreciate the one from my Japanese professor.
Is this true? I personally think it is not, but I have to admit I am kinda worried.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is this true about the recommendation?
				Posted: Wed Nov 17, 2010 3:58 am
				by SilverE2
				You're fine. Recommendations don't matter, just another hoop to jump through.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is this true about the recommendation?
				Posted: Wed Nov 17, 2010 4:22 am
				by MysticalWheel
				Yeah, you're good dude/dudette. Rec letters are just to make sure that not everyone hates you.
MW
			 
			
					
				Re: Is this true about the recommendation?
				Posted: Wed Nov 17, 2010 4:25 am
				by gloriouscause
				First of all, always get letters from professors who know you best. It's better to get a letter from a professor outside of your major who says glowing things about you than one from inside your major who just says you're pretty cool. 
Also, they're only another hoop to jump through if they aren't amazing. If you get ridiculously good ones I'm sure they'll help, particularly at certain schools that seem to look at them more heavily than others.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is this true about the recommendation?
				Posted: Wed Nov 17, 2010 5:02 am
				by im_blue
				atkpl wrote:My major is business.
I got one from my marketing professor whom I worked for as a TA
I got another one from my Japanese professor who loves me, and I took her class for two semesters (High level Japanese classes).
I got the letter from Japanese professor because I honestly believe she knows me better than any of my business professors.
But so many people are saying that I was being stupid not to get both of the letters from business professor.
They are saying that law schools won't really appreciate the one from my Japanese professor.
Is this true? I personally think it is not, but I have to admit I am kinda worried.
This might look bad, since many top schools explicitly state that they want letter writers to be faculty who have taught you.
 
			 
			
					
				Re: Is this true about the recommendation?
				Posted: Wed Nov 17, 2010 7:35 am
				by capitalacq
				im_blue wrote:atkpl wrote:My major is business.
I got one from my marketing professor whom I worked for as a TA
I got another one from my Japanese professor who loves me, and I took her class for two semesters (High level Japanese classes).
I got the letter from Japanese professor because I honestly believe she knows me better than any of my business professors.
But so many people are saying that I was being stupid not to get both of the letters from business professor.
They are saying that law schools won't really appreciate the one from my Japanese professor.
Is this true? I personally think it is not, but I have to admit I am kinda worried.
This might look bad, since many top schools explicitly state that they want letter writers to be faculty who have taught you.
 
i think he said he was his marketing prof
 
			 
			
					
				Re: Is this true about the recommendation?
				Posted: Wed Nov 17, 2010 7:36 am
				by capitalacq
				atkpl wrote:My major is business.
I got one from my marketing professor whom I worked for as a TA
I got another one from my Japanese professor who loves me, and I took her class for two semesters (High level Japanese classes).
I got the letter from Japanese professor because I honestly believe she knows me better than any of my business professors.
But so many people are saying that I was being stupid not to get both of the letters from business professor.
They are saying that law schools won't really appreciate the one from my Japanese professor.
Is this true? I personally think it is not, but I have to admit I am kinda worried.
the subject doesn't matter at all. The only concern w/ foreign language professors is if they can write good letters in English.