is ED really binding?
Posted: Sun Aug 08, 2010 9:07 pm
What is so "binding" about ED? If someone gets accepted to Yale after applying Gtown ED, how do they get out of their Gtown admission? Is it legally binding?
Law School Discussion Forums
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=126350
Someone link to that bro on LSN that had his Columbia admission rescinded or somethingjdhopeful11 wrote:My hypothetical was strictly technical; not to be taken literally.
How would other schools know that you backed out of an ED? I know that you're "supposed" to go if you get in via ED, but how do they really enforce that? What leverage do they have over you?
http://lawschoolnumbers.com/daninreallife/jdlawschoollll wrote:Someone link to that bro on LSN that had his Columbia admission rescinded or somethingjdhopeful11 wrote:My hypothetical was strictly technical; not to be taken literally.
How would other schools know that you backed out of an ED? I know that you're "supposed" to go if you get in via ED, but how do they really enforce that? What leverage do they have over you?
LSAC sends list to the schools saying who deposited where in June. Schools notify LSAC of people who withdraw from binding ED. The schools work together and will withdraw admissions if you violate a contract with someone else. Law schools care more about helping each other then some random person when they can just give their seat to someone else.jdhopeful11 wrote:My hypothetical was strictly technical; not to be taken literally.
How would other schools know that you backed out of an ED? I know that you're "supposed" to go if you get in via ED, but how do they really enforce that? What leverage do they have over you?
That's a shame. His fit talking about how Law School is a waste of time was pretty priceless.bk187 wrote:
P.S. The daninreallife is fake, but it serves the point.
CyLaw wrote:jdhopeful11 wrote:My hypothetical was strictly technical; not to be taken literally.
How would other schools know that you backed out of an ED? I know that you're "supposed" to go if you get in via ED, but how do they really enforce that? What leverage do they have over you?
If you want to be a lawyer, maybe you should learn that contracts as a matter of principal should be enforced.
OGR3 wrote:OP, the only times one should do ED is for financial reasons (GWU) or a dream school for which you would pay full price and would is a long shot at RD (T14). Don't throw good negotiating status away for anything less.
Also, schools send out the names of their accepted ED students all the time, just so people don't try pulling any shit.
Sorry if I offended you. I just got tired of people asking questions similar to this which really boiled down to "How can I get away with breaking the rules?"jdhopeful11 wrote:CyLaw wrote:jdhopeful11 wrote:My hypothetical was strictly technical; not to be taken literally.
How would other schools know that you backed out of an ED? I know that you're "supposed" to go if you get in via ED, but how do they really enforce that? What leverage do they have over you?
If you want to be a lawyer, maybe you should learn that contracts as a matter of principal should be enforced.
I was asking a question dickhead, don't use it as an excuse to judge my moral character
Wait, NU withdrew your acceptance?NayBoer wrote:Just to underscore how much schools work together: I got into NU ED. The next day, before withdrawing anywhere, I called Cornell to get my decision (rejection) and the admissions person told me that NU withdrew me from consideration, so she couldn't tell me either way.
npCyLaw wrote:Sorry if I offended you.jdhopeful11 wrote:CyLaw wrote:jdhopeful11 wrote:My hypothetical was strictly technical; not to be taken literally.
How would other schools know that you backed out of an ED? I know that you're "supposed" to go if you get in via ED, but how do they really enforce that? What leverage do they have over you?
If you want to be a lawyer, maybe you should learn that contracts as a matter of principal should be enforced.
I was asking a question dickhead, don't use it as an excuse to judge my moral character
I think it's usually a few days after they receive word of acceptance.jdhopeful11 wrote:So if one applies ED and has open apps, how long do they have to withdraw their apps?
If I remember the ED apps I read, I think for most it was just "in a timely manner", while others had specific timelines of say 2 weeks from written notice of acceptance.jdhopeful11 wrote:So if one applies ED and has open apps, how long do they have to withdraw their apps?
Hannibal wrote:Wait, NU withdrew your acceptance?NayBoer wrote:Just to underscore how much schools work together: I got into NU ED. The next day, before withdrawing anywhere, I called Cornell to get my decision (rejection) and the admissions person told me that NU withdrew me from consideration, so she couldn't tell me either way.
If I recall previous threads, this is the correct interpretation.zworykin wrote:Hannibal wrote:Wait, NU withdrew your acceptance?NayBoer wrote:Just to underscore how much schools work together: I got into NU ED. The next day, before withdrawing anywhere, I called Cornell to get my decision (rejection) and the admissions person told me that NU withdrew me from consideration, so she couldn't tell me either way.
I read it that way at first too, but that seemed too unreasonable (it was the very next day!). So now I'm reading it as "NU called Cornell to withdraw my name on my behalf since they had accepted my binding ED app."
Nope. NU emailed UChi as well. When I emailed Uchi they responded back "Good luck at Northwestern."zworykin wrote:Hannibal wrote:Wait, NU withdrew your acceptance?NayBoer wrote:Just to underscore how much schools work together: I got into NU ED. The next day, before withdrawing anywhere, I called Cornell to get my decision (rejection) and the admissions person told me that NU withdrew me from consideration, so she couldn't tell me either way.
I read it that way at first too, but that seemed too unreasonable (it was the very next day!). So now I'm reading it as "NU called Cornell to withdraw my name on my behalf since they had accepted my binding ED app."
How catty of them.Desert Fox wrote:Nope. NU emailed UChi as well. When I emailed Uchi they responded back "Good luck at Northwestern."
Also Harvard got pissed because they didn't get my letter by snail mail, and they sent me a pissy letter about NU.
UChi's wasn't catty at all. Seemed Sincere. Harvard was being a dick. Apparently they are too good for email withdrawals.byunbee wrote:How catty of them.Desert Fox wrote:Nope. NU emailed UChi as well. When I emailed Uchi they responded back "Good luck at Northwestern."
Also Harvard got pissed because they didn't get my letter by snail mail, and they sent me a pissy letter about NU.