Page 1 of 1

ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:33 pm
by DorianGray89
I'm a URM, with not a great GPA and not a great LSAT. My question is, I know I'm not going to get a scholarship from my frist choice, which is a T14. Should I apply ED instead of RD so as to better my chances of admission, and take the risk of not being able to negotiate for financial aid?

I do expect to get some need based financial aid, but almost no merit.

Suggestions?

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:44 pm
by Knock
DorianGray89 wrote:I'm a URM, with not a great GPA and not a great LSAT. My question is, I know I'm not going to get a scholarship from my frist choice, which is a T14. Should I apply ED instead of RD so as to better my chances of admission, and take the risk of not being able to negotiate for financial aid?

I do expect to get some need based financial aid, but almost no merit.

Suggestions?
No one's going to be able this question sufficiently unless you post your numbers.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:08 pm
by DorianGray89
Knockglock wrote:
DorianGray89 wrote:I'm a URM, with not a great GPA and not a great LSAT. My question is, I know I'm not going to get a scholarship from my frist choice, which is a T14. Should I apply ED instead of RD so as to better my chances of admission, and take the risk of not being able to negotiate for financial aid?

I do expect to get some need based financial aid, but almost no merit.

Suggestions?
No one's going to be able this question sufficiently unless you post your numbers.
Numbers don't matter here. The question is ED vs RD. Not if I'm going to get in, but if it's better to forego the little chance I have to get a merit scholarship and apply Early Decision.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:10 pm
by merichard87
Numbers do matter for a URM. Just because you think the school is out of reach doesn't mean it really is. We would need numbers plus at least the range of the T14 school you are talking about i.e., HYS CCN etc..

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:10 pm
by CG614
DorianGray89 wrote:
Knockglock wrote:
DorianGray89 wrote:I'm a URM, with not a great GPA and not a great LSAT. My question is, I know I'm not going to get a scholarship from my frist choice, which is a T14. Should I apply ED instead of RD so as to better my chances of admission, and take the risk of not being able to negotiate for financial aid?

I do expect to get some need based financial aid, but almost no merit.

Suggestions?
No one's going to be able this question sufficiently unless you post your numbers.
Numbers don't matter here. The question is ED vs RD. Not if I'm going to get in, but if it's better to forego the little chance I have to get a merit scholarship and apply Early Decision.
Numbers always matter. If she says otherwise, she is lying.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:11 pm
by DorianGray89
CG614 wrote:
DorianGray89 wrote:
Knockglock wrote:
DorianGray89 wrote:I'm a URM, with not a great GPA and not a great LSAT. My question is, I know I'm not going to get a scholarship from my frist choice, which is a T14. Should I apply ED instead of RD so as to better my chances of admission, and take the risk of not being able to negotiate for financial aid?

I do expect to get some need based financial aid, but almost no merit.

Suggestions?
No one's going to be able this question sufficiently unless you post your numbers.
Numbers don't matter here. The question is ED vs RD. Not if I'm going to get in, but if it's better to forego the little chance I have to get a merit scholarship and apply Early Decision.
Numbers always matter. If she says otherwise, she is lying.
3.5/164
T14 school

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:15 pm
by CG614
DorianGray89 wrote:
3.5/164
T14 school
What kind of URM? T14 is definitely not out of the realm for an URM with those numbers.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:17 pm
by DorianGray89
CG614 wrote:
DorianGray89 wrote:
3.5/164
T14 school
What kind of URM? T14 is definitely not out of the realm for an URM with those numbers.

Mexican American
Would ED be better? I know where I want to go, the only thing that would prevent me from going there is no need based financial aid

100% Mexican American

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:19 pm
by merichard87
DorianGray89 wrote:
3.5/164
T14 school
If you are AA and applying to the one of the lower T14 I might not ED. Depends on the school though and what other softs you have going for you.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:20 pm
by DorianGray89
merichard87 wrote:
DorianGray89 wrote:
3.5/164
T14 school
If you are AA and applying to the one of the lower T14 I might not ED. Depends on the school though and what other softs you have going for you.

Straight out of undergrad, with a lot of real meaningful internships (no bitch work).

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:20 pm
by CG614
DorianGray89 wrote:
CG614 wrote:
DorianGray89 wrote:
3.5/164
T14 school
What kind of URM? T14 is definitely not out of the realm for an URM with those numbers.

Mexican American
Would ED be better? I know where I want to go, the only thing that would prevent me from going there is no need based financial aid

100% Mexican American
I'd say you should ED if you REALLY want one particular school. It will help.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:24 pm
by CG614
Also, if you SN is your name, you should change it. Just some friendly advice.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:43 pm
by dabbadon8
CG614 wrote:Also, if you SN is your name, you should change it. Just some friendly advice.
Right, you would have a very long time to live with that mistake, given that no one destroys your portrait.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:52 pm
by CG614
dabbadon8 wrote:
CG614 wrote:Also, if you SN is your name, you should change it. Just some friendly advice.
Right, you would have a very long time to live with that mistake, given that no one destroys your portrait.
What the F does that even mean?

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:53 pm
by Knock
dabbadon8 wrote:
CG614 wrote:Also, if you SN is your name, you should change it. Just some friendly advice.
Right, you would have a very long time to live with that mistake, given that no one destroys your portrait.
Lol, well done, well done :lol:.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:53 pm
by Knock
CG614 wrote:
dabbadon8 wrote:
CG614 wrote:Also, if you SN is your name, you should change it. Just some friendly advice.
Right, you would have a very long time to live with that mistake, given that no one destroys your portrait.
What the F does that even mean?
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=dorian+gray

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:57 pm
by CG614
Knockglock wrote:
CG614 wrote:
dabbadon8 wrote:
CG614 wrote:Also, if you SN is your name, you should change it. Just some friendly advice.
Right, you would have a very long time to live with that mistake, given that no one destroys your portrait.
What the F does that even mean?
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=dorian+gray
Fair enough. Joke's on me.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 4:35 pm
by DorianGray89
Thanks for the advice.

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 4:38 pm
by thecilent
CG614 wrote:
dabbadon8 wrote:
CG614 wrote:Also, if you SN is your name, you should change it. Just some friendly advice.
Right, you would have a very long time to live with that mistake, given that no one destroys your portrait.
What the F does that even mean?
i lol'd hard when I read this post.

I mean majority would not have gotten that. just saying that was funny

Re: ED vs. RD

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 4:51 pm
by bk1
I'd say check LSN and see what your odds are. If you are on the cusp then ED.

In general, considering your numbers, I think ED seems like the right call here.