Page 1 of 4
Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:37 pm
by RealTalk
First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:40 pm
by miamiman
cool, bro.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:41 pm
by quickquestionthanks
If the person you are talking to doesn't realize that Yale is a big deal, I wouldn't worry about impressing them.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:41 pm
by soullesswonder
RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
Harvard now has virtually the same grading system as Yale and Stanford, fyi
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:43 pm
by Unemployed
RealTalk wrote:I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
(reviews UGPA and LSAT score)

Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:46 pm
by KibblesAndVick
I believe that anyone intelligent enough to be admitted to both Yale and Harvard would not think the way you do about the choice before them. They might still pick Harvard, but not for these reasons. As such, your point is a bit moot

Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:46 pm
by Fark-o-vision
RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
My AWESOME meter just went off the charts. Am I right?
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:48 pm
by cardnal124
Unemployed wrote:RealTalk wrote:I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
(reviews UGPA and LSAT score)

+1
Also, Harvard may carry more clout than Yale for a random person on the street, but they are the ones giving you employment. Here's my analysis. Yale > Harvard for law academia, research, and clerkships. Harvard > Yale for politics (more potential connections with a bigger class) and BigLaw (although mostly due to self-selection).
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:49 pm
by qualster
RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
I would choose Harvard because every movie set at an elite school seems to use Harvard as the default. It's just the coolest. The Paper Chase, Legally Blonde, Soul Man, etc.
The fact that I would choose based almost solely on this basis indicates my level of intelligence. I obviously do not have the Harvard or Yale option.
I didn't apply to Harvard because I scored in the mid 160 range on the LSAT, but my "Why Harvard" essay would have been ridiculous if I'd decided to waste $80.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:50 pm
by prezidentv8
RealTalk wrote:
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
I can appreciate that you prefer Harvard to Yale. That is fine.
But - competitititititititive skewl iz stooooooopid.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:50 pm
by RVP11
RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
There are plenty of applicants who would prefer Harvard over Yale. But they presumably have that preference for, ya know...non-retarded reasons.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:53 pm
by 20121109
Nope. You're not alone. For me, Harvard > Yale. But that's just because I have international career endeavors and I feel Harvard's international reputation beats Yale's. Of course, I'm not expecting to get into Yale, so the prospect of turning down Yale just seems easier...just because I probably would never have the opportunity. I think my chances at HLS are decent, but I doubt I'm awesome enough for Yale, lol...
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:59 pm
by APimpNamedSlickback
no, op.
i almost certainly would take hls over any other school. i find the sheer breadth of opportunities at cambridge pretty exciting relative to those anywhere else, including yale.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:04 pm
by tomhobbes
RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
Have you been accepted to both?
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:05 pm
by dextermorgan
Yes, you are nuts.
Then again there are quite a few schools I would choose over HLS.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:05 pm
by r6_philly
I would take Y over H without a blink. It is worth to note that I came to this realization after about a year of research. It is hard to overcome the tought that H is the best university in the world, but to me and everything I want to achieve, Y is a much over choice. I believe in almost every aspect that I looked at, Y is better than H. Not saying that it is universally better, but better from my perspective, it is just a better fit for me. The one thing I do like about H more is the ability to cross register at MIT.
Well I don't know if I really have a fighting chance at H anyway so the point may be moot for me.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:21 pm
by tomhobbes
I did a little research on your behalf OP and I discovered that you are not alone. At Harvard, the best law school in the nation, a slim majority of the students agree that Harvard Law School is better than Yale Law School: --LinkRemoved--
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:36 pm
by Herb Watchfell
tomhobbes wrote:I did a little research on your behalf OP and I discovered that you are not alone. At Harvard, the best law school in the nation, a slim majority of the students agree that Harvard Law School is better than Yale Law School: --LinkRemoved--
Tyler Bowen is a rockstar.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:37 pm
by RealTalk
tomhobbes wrote:RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
Have you been accepted to both?
not yet but just contemplating if it were to come true
so far my cycle has gone much better than my numbers would indicate primarily cause I'm so great when it comes to softs
biomedical engineering grad from Princeton w/ alot of accomplishments
I suspect Harvard as a likely admit while Yale is a long shot
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:39 pm
by utexas2010
RealTalk wrote:tomhobbes wrote:RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
Have you been accepted to both?
not yet but just contemplating if it were to come true
so far my cycle has gone much better than my numbers would indicate primarily cause I'm so great when it comes to softs
biomedical engineering grad from Princeton w/ alot of accomplishments
I suspect Harvard as a likely admit while Yale is a long shot
Sure there is not another "great" soft you are failing to mention?
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:41 pm
by rayiner
tomhobbes wrote:RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
Have you been accepted to both?
Of course not. You think a Yalie would be douchey enough to post in a thread like this?
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:41 pm
by RealTalk
GAIAtheCHEERLEADER wrote:Nope. You're not alone. For me, Harvard > Yale. But that's just because I have international career endeavors and I feel Harvard's international reputation beats Yale's. Of course, I'm not expecting to get into Yale, so the prospect of turning down Yale just seems easier...just because I probably would never have the opportunity. I think my chances at HLS are decent, but I doubt I'm awesome enough for Yale, lol...
true
I know that saying I went to Harvard will impress anyone no matter where they are in the world. Its practically the only American university anyone outside this country knows.
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:45 pm
by RealTalk
rayiner wrote:tomhobbes wrote:RealTalk wrote:First of all, let me be blunt I care only about prestige when it comes to picking a school. I know Yale has been number one in the USNWR rankings forever. However as we all know when it comes to impressing the random person in the street the name Harvard carries way more clout than Yale. Harvard is universally recognized as the best university in the world and a degree from it is worth more than a degree from any other institution of higher learning.
Yale may get more respect than Harvard in the legal community but the margin is so small its almost irrelevant. Its not like your job prospects are any better from graduating at the top of your class in Yale as opposed to Harvard.
I'm also really competitive so the fact Yale doesn't give out grades is a turn-off. I'd much rather prove myself in a competitive grade driven environment such as Harvard rather than the laid back nature I've heard about from Yale. Also the fact Harvard has almost 3x the number of students as Yale w/o a drop-off in terms of quality (GPA and LSAT) makes the place even more competitive. Thus being top of your class in Harvard is way more impressive IMO than being top of your class at Yale.
Am I crazy or are there other prospective 1L's that also rank Harvard above Yale?
Have you been accepted to both?
Of course not. You think a Yalie would be douchey enough to post in a thread like this?
I'm all about prestige dude. I went to Princeton for undergrad simply because Harvard waitlisted me eventhough at that time Princeton was #1 in ranking while Harvard was #2.
Yale simply just doesn't have the lay prestige of Harvard.
Why is it so hard for people to believe that some people don't care about USNWR's rankings?
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:47 pm
by Herb Watchfell
RealTalk wrote:not yet but . . . I suspect Harvard as a likely admit . . . .
3.3/164 FTL
Re: Am I the only one that would easily pick HLS over YLS?
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:48 pm
by RealTalk
Herb Watchfell wrote:RealTalk wrote:not yet but . . . I suspect Harvard as a likely admit . . . .
3.3/164 FTL
u gotta love affirmative action
