Page 1 of 3
The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:22 pm
by livitup11
I've searched the forum, and while people have been skirting around this question I don't think anyone has asked it flat-out. At least, not in a while.
What are the really important soft factors to law schools? What isn't so important?
People seem to be saying that typically they work in the sense that they will give you an edge in situations where you are up against someone with similar numbers. Is this mostly true, or are there situations where softs can really make a person stand out?
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:37 pm
by thesealocust
edit: n/m
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:38 pm
by Ragged
thesealocust wrote:Top soft factors:
1)URM
2) LSAT
3) GPA
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:15 pm
by traehekat
From what I have heard, the personal statement is probably the most important. I imagine some outstanding work experience can really make an applicant stand out as well.
It is weird. Like others have said, yeah, they don't seem to mean much. However, like YOU said, I feel adcomms have to come across tons of applicants with very similar numbers, so SOMETHING has to make them choose one over the other.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:24 pm
by bees
Join the Army.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:29 pm
by holydonkey
1) LSAT
2) GPA
3) URM
4) Veteran
5) Son or Daughter of Donor/Prominent Government Official
6) Amazing Work Experience (Helped Create Microsoft, Invented Deadly Laser Orbiting the Earth)
7) Hypnotist
8 ) Blackmail
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:33 pm
by Eruannon
I think it really depends. I was talking to a professor who said he helped a auto reject candidate get into Stanford. They co-published a really nice piece of work. This was a very well known political science professor. Other than extremely unusual softs like the one mentioned, I have heard the personal statement is very important. Some schools have specialized soft preference; Northwestern is very impartial to strong work experience.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:33 pm
by Dany
The important soft factors are ones that not many people can accomplish. Volunteer work? Anybody can do that. Rhodes Scholar? Very rare, therefore an important soft.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:35 pm
by Eruannon
eskimo wrote:The important soft factors are ones that not many people can accomplish. Volunteer work? Anybody can do that. Rhodes Scholar? Very rare, therefore an important soft.
Exactly. As I was saying, if you co-publish with a professor and he raves about your work in an LOR that is going to do wonders for your application... This is very very rare which makes it very valuable.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:37 pm
by DoubleChecks
why do ppl keep putting LSAT and GPA as soft factors? they realize those are the "hard numbers" right? lol thus the other things being the "soft factors"
anyways, i would say the most helpful is URM status. after that things that give noticeable boosts would be:
veteran of the US army
peace corps
teach for america
child of a BIG donor/alumni
rhodes scholar and the like
amazing work experience like having your own very successful start-up company
personally, id say an advanced degree BESIDES a masters, i.e. a PhD/MD cuz damn, those take some work to get
those are the ones that come to mind...for the most part, id say softs just help you break ties, assuming you have the "requisite" amount expected of you lol
besides that, only big ones will pop out like, iunno writing harry potter or winning a medal at the olympics
edit: if PS and LORs fall under here, i guess exceptional ones are quite useful, but i mean, thats hard to KNOW you have gold
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:41 pm
by Eruannon
DoubleChecks wrote:why do ppl keep putting LSAT and GPA as soft factors? they realize those are the "hard numbers" right? lol thus the other things being the "soft factors"
anyways, i would say the most helpful is URM status. after that things that give noticeable boosts would be:
veteran of the US army
peace corps
teach for america
child of a BIG donor/alumni
rhodes scholar and the like
amazing work experience like having your own very successful start-up company
personally, id say an advanced degree BESIDES a masters, i.e. a PhD/MD cuz damn, those take some work to get
those are the ones that come to mind...for the most part, id say softs just help you break ties, assuming you have the "requisite" amount expected of you lol
besides that, only big ones will pop out like, iunno writing harry potter or winning a medal at the olympics
edit: if PS and LORs fall under here, i guess exceptional ones are quite useful, but i mean, thats hard to KNOW you have gold
I think it is dependent on the school's situation. If your numbers wont effect their medians at all, there is no way in hell a school will not admit someone with an amazing out of this world soft. It is in their best interest to do so, they want candidates that will improve their numbers and/or go on to do amazing things.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:48 pm
by scribelaw
I think post-UG work experience that is interesting and impressive is a good soft. I don't think it has to be earth shattering -- you don't have to split atoms from 9 to 5 -- but having been successful in another profession and getting some life experience will help.
Also, I haven't seen anyone mention UG quality. I don't personally benefit from this, but I think going to HYP and, to a lesser extent, other Ivys and top-rated UGs is a good soft.
One other one, having a good story to tell in overcoming adversity. If you came from a really poor rural area or something, or overcame cancer, that gives you a powerful story to tell in a DS and I think can make an application a lot stronger. (Again, I don't personally benefit from this soft).
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:54 pm
by rookhawk
-
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 11:08 am
by livitup11
thesealocust wrote:Top soft factors:
1) LSAT
2) GPA
It goes without saying that GPA and LSAT are important, but thanks for being facetious.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 11:11 am
by livitup11
DoubleChecks wrote:why do ppl keep putting LSAT and GPA as soft factors? they realize those are the "hard numbers" right? lol thus the other things being the "soft factors"
Well, I sure hope so or else my previous post is kinda harsh!
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:18 pm
by legends159
For most softs, how you write about it is more important than what is on your resume.
Make sure the PS tells a coherent story about who you are and what your goals and aspirations are. Treat the soft factors (pick a couple) as anecdotes to illustrate who you are. I think that people with mediocre softs on a resume, who can talk it up and make a cohesive story with a sticking point are those that have "great softs."
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:29 pm
by WhiskeyGuy
livitup11 wrote:thesealocust wrote:Top soft factors:
1) LSAT
2) GPA
It goes without saying that GPA and LSAT are important, but thanks for being facetious.
Not to mention that LSAT and GPA are not soft factors.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:31 pm
by WhiskeyGuy
legends159 wrote:For most softs, how you write about it is more important than what is on your resume.
Make sure the PS tells a coherent story about who you are and what your goals and aspirations are. Treat the soft factors (pick a couple) as anecdotes to illustrate who you are. I think that people with mediocre softs on a resume, who can talk it up and make a cohesive story with a sticking point are those that have "great softs."
I think this is on point. A good number of those who get into reach schools a) say that they spend loads of time on their essays, b) were told by ad comms that their essays were persuasive and enjoyable to read.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:40 pm
by Nom Sawyer
Best soft factor? A heartfelt, honest one-on-one chat during a visit to the admissions office.
Hint, hint:
--ImageRemoved--
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:54 pm
by Marisa5252
People are posting LSAT and GPA as "softs" because obviously if your gpa and lsat aren't good enough it pretty much doesn't matter what your softs are (unless you're URM, or maybe a Vet or did peace corps). Otherwise schools really only care about numbers. As for good softs that may distinguish you from other applicants with the same numbers think about what sounds impressive in an admissions brochure:
"3% of our matriculating class wrote Pulitzer winners!" (ok I know that's ridiculous but you get the idea) sounds impressive
"10% of our matriculating class studied abroad!" sounds less impressive
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 1:52 pm
by LurkerNoMore
legends159 wrote:For most softs, how you write about it is more important than what is on your resume.
Make sure the PS tells a coherent story about who you are and what your goals and aspirations are. Treat the soft factors (pick a couple) as anecdotes to illustrate who you are. I think that people with mediocre softs on a resume, who can talk it up and make a cohesive story with a sticking point are those that have "great softs."
This is absolutely the correct answer.
Once you are past the numbers, it is much more about how you tell your story than what the component parts of that story are. Adcoms are looking to see what you bring to the table -- what you did doesn't tell them that, how you have incorporated what you have done into your life/world view does. Some people roll through life doing "impressive" things, but don't really internalize them. Some people pull great insight out of "mundane" experiences.
You want your personal statement (and resume) to indicate that you will contribute something of value when you are sitting in the classroom.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2010 2:28 am
by bees
DoubleChecks wrote:why do ppl keep putting LSAT and GPA as soft factors? they realize those are the "hard numbers" right? lol thus the other things being the "soft factors"
anyways, i would say the most helpful is URM status. after that things that give noticeable boosts would be:
veteran of the US army
peace corps
teach for america
child of a BIG donor/alumni
rhodes scholar and the like
amazing work experience like having your own very successful start-up company
personally, id say an advanced degree BESIDES a masters, i.e. a PhD/MD cuz damn, those take some work to get
those are the ones that come to mind...for the most part, id say softs just help you break ties, assuming you have the "requisite" amount expected of you lol
besides that, only big ones will pop out like, iunno writing harry potter or winning a medal at the olympics
edit: if PS and LORs fall under here, i guess exceptional ones are quite useful, but i mean, thats hard to KNOW you have gold
Just because it's bugging me: TFA shouldn't really be on that list, right?
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2010 5:06 pm
by rookhawk
-
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2010 6:09 pm
by WhiskeyGuy
bees wrote:DoubleChecks wrote:why do ppl keep putting LSAT and GPA as soft factors? they realize those are the "hard numbers" right? lol thus the other things being the "soft factors"
anyways, i would say the most helpful is URM status. after that things that give noticeable boosts would be:
veteran of the US army
peace corps
teach for america
child of a BIG donor/alumni
rhodes scholar and the like
amazing work experience like having your own very successful start-up company
personally, id say an advanced degree BESIDES a masters, i.e. a PhD/MD cuz damn, those take some work to get
those are the ones that come to mind...for the most part, id say softs just help you break ties, assuming you have the "requisite" amount expected of you lol
besides that, only big ones will pop out like, iunno writing harry potter or winning a medal at the olympics
edit: if PS and LORs fall under here, i guess exceptional ones are quite useful, but i mean, thats hard to KNOW you have gold
Just because it's bugging me: TFA shouldn't really be on that list, right?
TFA should be on the list. Anyone who teaches in deprived areas and for little pay gets points in my book.
Re: The most important soft factors
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2010 6:23 pm
by sven
WhiskeyGuy wrote:bees wrote:DoubleChecks wrote:why do ppl keep putting LSAT and GPA as soft factors? they realize those are the "hard numbers" right? lol thus the other things being the "soft factors"
anyways, i would say the most helpful is URM status. after that things that give noticeable boosts would be:
veteran of the US army
peace corps
teach for america
child of a BIG donor/alumni
rhodes scholar and the like
amazing work experience like having your own very successful start-up company
personally, id say an advanced degree BESIDES a masters, i.e. a PhD/MD cuz damn, those take some work to get
those are the ones that come to mind...for the most part, id say softs just help you break ties, assuming you have the "requisite" amount expected of you lol
besides that, only big ones will pop out like, iunno writing harry potter or winning a medal at the olympics
edit: if PS and LORs fall under here, i guess exceptional ones are quite useful, but i mean, thats hard to KNOW you have gold
Just because it's bugging me: TFA shouldn't really be on that list, right?
TFA should be on the list. Anyone who teaches in deprived areas and for little pay gets points in my book.
I think u mean Americorps Vista. TFAers get plenty of money.