Unfinished PS- Criticism welcome
Posted: Thu Aug 18, 2016 3:52 pm
The writing prompt that lay on the desk in front of me seemed simple enough: “Write an essay arguing either that dissent is good or that dissent is bad.” To an insecure, unprincipled high-school junior, maintaining fraternal bonds and positive social status is as high on the priority list as is inhaling and eating breakfast. So I argued the latter. Dissent, disagreement, and rebellion, after all, were at the root of all of the tense disputes I’d ever had with friends, all of my groundings and boring indoor weekends, and every single one of my detentions and out-of-school suspensions. Feeling self-assured, I pumped out five paragraphs about dissent’s propensity to foster division and disrespect for cherished leaders and institutions. You would be hard pressed, I argued, to find a war in the past 200,000 years which wasn’t the result of someone questioning or assaulting the status quo. As always, I was confident that I was right.
The teacher’s feedback, which proved to be transformative, made it clear that I was wrong. Dissent, he lectured, is the engine of history. Without the bold and pugnacious pursuits of Thomas Jefferson, Susan B. Anthony, and Martin Luther King Jr., among so many others, the world would be stagnant, and would always be marred by death and injustice. In other words, our pivot away from feudalism, slavery, monarchy, fascism, and patriarchy couldn’t have happened without the men and women throughout history who were willing to dissent. The lesson effected my thinking in significant ways. After some time I felt free to stop caring so much about public opinion and to think for myself. I began to ask questions, to raise an eyebrow at questionable claims, and to grapple with friends and family over the issues I thought were important. I probably became a bit more annoying to those around me- sharing highly partisan op-ed articles on social media, inserting myself into discussions with a pretentious “Actually..”- but the benefits of freethinking proved to outweigh the costs. A growing interest in politics, history, and legal issues enriched my worldview and guided my intellectual pursuits for the next five years. Being wrong, it seems, would ultimately serve as the foundation of my decision to apply to law school.
In college, a few things happened which allowed me to transition from a scrappy political hobbyist to an aspiring law school student. First, I decided that I want to devote my life’s work to the problems that I was spending so much time talking and thinking about. I knew that I couldn’t have enjoyed a life selling cars or owning a pastry shop when there are so many more important and stimulating things to work on. The second thing I decided is that having opinions probably wouldn’t suffice alone to help fix things like political unrest, poverty, or climate change. I knew that if I wanted to have any small shot at fixing these problems, there are two things that I would need: an historical mind, and a working understanding of the legal processes and institutions in which these problems would be resolved. The decision to attend law school followed naturally. [Something about desire to go into federal litigation.]
[How the law school I’m applying to meshes well with my interests and aspirations, and how I will contribute to the law school’s academic environment.]
The teacher’s feedback, which proved to be transformative, made it clear that I was wrong. Dissent, he lectured, is the engine of history. Without the bold and pugnacious pursuits of Thomas Jefferson, Susan B. Anthony, and Martin Luther King Jr., among so many others, the world would be stagnant, and would always be marred by death and injustice. In other words, our pivot away from feudalism, slavery, monarchy, fascism, and patriarchy couldn’t have happened without the men and women throughout history who were willing to dissent. The lesson effected my thinking in significant ways. After some time I felt free to stop caring so much about public opinion and to think for myself. I began to ask questions, to raise an eyebrow at questionable claims, and to grapple with friends and family over the issues I thought were important. I probably became a bit more annoying to those around me- sharing highly partisan op-ed articles on social media, inserting myself into discussions with a pretentious “Actually..”- but the benefits of freethinking proved to outweigh the costs. A growing interest in politics, history, and legal issues enriched my worldview and guided my intellectual pursuits for the next five years. Being wrong, it seems, would ultimately serve as the foundation of my decision to apply to law school.
In college, a few things happened which allowed me to transition from a scrappy political hobbyist to an aspiring law school student. First, I decided that I want to devote my life’s work to the problems that I was spending so much time talking and thinking about. I knew that I couldn’t have enjoyed a life selling cars or owning a pastry shop when there are so many more important and stimulating things to work on. The second thing I decided is that having opinions probably wouldn’t suffice alone to help fix things like political unrest, poverty, or climate change. I knew that if I wanted to have any small shot at fixing these problems, there are two things that I would need: an historical mind, and a working understanding of the legal processes and institutions in which these problems would be resolved. The decision to attend law school followed naturally. [Something about desire to go into federal litigation.]
[How the law school I’m applying to meshes well with my interests and aspirations, and how I will contribute to the law school’s academic environment.]