Rough draft. I'm very uncertain about it. Critique please?
Posted: Wed Nov 12, 2014 5:23 pm
.
Law School Discussion Forums
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=239580
Thanks! Yeah, the community reference is definitely the aspect that I'm most uncertain about. I thought it was a very relevant quote, and maybe referencing a TV show would "lighten the mood" a bit? I dunno, it just sounded like a potentially interesting idea to me- albeit a risky one.fats provolone wrote:i'm not sure about the community reference, but i like the theme of being inspired by getting clowned on
Another thing I was worried about. Thanks!lnick93 wrote:Although I do like the idea that you are learning from a really rough situation, I think basing your PS on an experience you had when you were 14 is a stretch.I understand that you are telling a story, but finding a way to tie that story into what you have done later in life (UG or any WE) would probably be a good idea for law school apps.
Thanks, that's great to hear! The quote was definitely the thing I was most hesitant about. After reading your comment, and the other comment on here about it, I think I'm going to remove it.kevgogators wrote:Of the many statements I've read on TLS, this is among my favorites. It has an intriguing hook and also manages to retain reader interest. I also appreciate the structure of it.
With that said, I don't love the ketchup quote in the last paragraph-- it is undoubtedly the weakest point of your PS. I'm not sure what show you are referring to, but it didn't feel..."inspiring" enough. Perhaps my opinion would change if I were familiar with the character, but you can't assume the admissions officer would recognize it anyway.
Just my two cents. Good job overall.